I think you are right about the interior quality. But that isn't that important. As far the safety goes, you might want to check out the iihs.org crash tests. The front impact crash tests of the evo are slightly better than the golf. The side impact crash tests are slighty better in the golf. It is basically even. As far as the build quality goes, unless vw has dramatically improved things with the golf, the reliability might be better, maybe much better in the evo. I mean think of all the check engine lights, etc. that vw has historically had problems with. I know this for a fact. Japan quality is almost always going to be more reliable. Also, there might better better leg room for people who have to sit in the back. I have heard that the leg room in the back of the evo is very good, maybe better than in the Golf. The Golf does have an advantage having the windshield wiper in the back, for it is very handy to get mud, etc off for visiblility. But how much better is the ride quality in a golf vs the evo?