Before I settled on the R I considered an S3, M140i, Focus RS & A45 mainly. The more thought I gave it the more of an obvious choice it became.
A45 is more powerful but couldn't justify the price difference for the gain over the R.
M140i has a beautiful sounding engine there is no doubt, but its hardly a looker in my opinion and potentially lethal in the wet.
Focus RS was probably the closest but its a bit too obvious for me, grabs attention in a similar way to a brick in the face.
S3 is what it is, very similar to the R but i've owned one previously so wanted a change.
I don't think anyone can argue with the 'bang per buck' the R provides, I don't think there is anything else quite like it on the roads.