Don't quite follow you there ???
I'd be quite happy getting my full "invoice price" back should the worst happen. I'd still get a new car, and just add a few more £'s towards it.Â
What if you had full replacement gap (which you would have had to pay more for) but wanted a slightly higher spec R next time ? Would you still look for a used R as a replacement then ?  Same thing really if you see where I'm coming from ?? Â
Why settle for a payout that won't even buy a new car of the same spec as the original? Why not insure that final difference, next year its 20% vat and probably more price increases, so the gap will get wider, not smaller. . .
For the small additional premium i know i'd rather make sure the car was insured to the Brochure price, rather than the invoice price seeing as i saved quite a bit on my car from list.