I had an RS3 on order as soon as they started taking orders (Dec 2010) but because of the extended delivery times, I started looking at other cars. I bought an R32 as a stopgap in May 2011, loved it so much I put the Golf R on order. My high spec (incl. sun roof) brought the Golf within £2k of the RS3 price but the real clincher for me was being able to order the ACC on the Golf. Strangely although the S3 has the option of the 'magnetic ride' active suspension (which has no manually adjustable settings), you can't get it on the RS3.
When the RS3 arrived I did drive it, thinking that if I REALLY liked it, I'd cancel the Golf R. But after the test drive I jumped back in the R32 and cancelled the RS3 the next morning. Now I've got the R, I've not regretted it for a moment.
The good thing about the RS3 is the fantastic engine but taken as a complete package, I believe that the Golf R is better (and in my opinion it looks better). If you want more power, go for one of the many tuning mods.
I hope this helpsÂ
What did you not like about the RS3? Did the salesmen let you have a proper go in it? I.e did you get to explore the full rev range and chassis set up? Have you got DSG in your R?
I had a 8P S3 and cant help but think the R is the same car with a different body, no doubt it handles better than the S3 though!
Why do you think the R is better as a complete package?
Sorry to be a pain asking all the questions but it is good to hear from a person like you who has previous experience