Hi All,
I've been an 'R' Owner for just over a month. I quite like the car; it's quick, practical and great fun when throwing it about in all weathers. Just one factor is holding me back from loving it - the DSG gearbox.
Now I know this has been the topic of much debate, and I'm at risk of kicking off pages of arguing (which I partly attribute to owners justifying their purchase choice =P~ ), but I feel quite strongly about this.Â
After years or reading praise in the motoring press, many stating that DSG was finally the replacement for a stick, I specifically searched for a car with DSG. Maybe in hindsight I should have been more patient and tested a manual car for comparison; though I assumed tens of motoring journalists with far more experience than I couldn't be wrong.
I've got nothing against auto shifters in general, my last two cars had them; a C32 AMG and a 123d. The Merc system was old and a bit slow witted, and the BMW system wasn't as fast shifting as the DSG in manual mode; but both systems seemed to work more seamlessly with the accompanying drivetrain in everyday use. Both autos seemed to allow you to stroke the cars along whilst hanging on to the appropriate amount of torque for the occasion, whilst also smoothly down changing if you asked for more. The DSG system is too quick to change up (and often mentioned criticism on this forum) I assume for economy, and then needs a firm prod on the throttle to down change; this often resulting in a clunky change and double the rate acceleration wanted. The 'R' has the capability to deliver surging torque, though the DSG software setup doen't seem to compliment the drivetrain to enable this.
In contrast the manual mode is brilliant and can be truly engaging when attacking a few bends, allowing 100% focus on the job at hand. Though when not at full attack, and just moving at a nice pace through the countryside, I feel like I'm missing out on some of the driving experience (especially the subtleties of heel toeing). To add to this I have managed to confuse it a few times, resulting in harsh changes. In a manual I'm in control, with only myself to blame when things go wrong.
So, to get to my point... DSG. Not as good as every day as a full Auto, not as involving as a manual... unless you are a track-day regular or looking to go to jail.
Anyone near Stockholm want to swap a Manual for DSG? (p.s. I'd also have a preference for 18s) O0
:Dons flame suit: