My dads got an m135i and it really is a fabulous car - it sounds great and drives really well in my opinion, I also think it looks quite.
I've ordered a golf R without having driven one due to a 3 day window before the lease deal ended and all local dealers either not having an R to test or the sales manager had taken it home for the weekend (I find it totally bemusing how dealers can allow this!). So if the golf is better and faster than the m135i, it's a very, very good car.
Even though all reports suggest the R is better, if they were the same price (they weren't with the lease deal a month ago) then it would still be a tough choice on paper for me - I prefer the idea/image and looks of the golf, but the 6 cylinder 3l engine is a big tick.
I've mentioned the evo and autocar road tests more than a couple of times to my dad since ordering though!