MagicCat
Members-
Posts
17 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Articles
Forums
Events
Store
Classifieds
Everything posted by MagicCat
-
Absolutely kick off at VW. You will not get anywhere without kicking up a stink. Tweet VW UK with your complaint to get it in the public forum and then go see the dealer your car is coming through. Reading some forums, people have been in similar situations and give Golf GTD's to tide them over for free. I would go see the dealer on a Sat or Sun when its busy, and speak loudly when your complaining. They will soon want to appease you! If they still wont do anything tell them your not happy and you want to escalate it further up the chain. I would also fire off an email with your complaint to; alex.smith@volkswagen.co.uk, chris.craft@volkswagen.co.uk Easy cowboy. For a minute there I thought Dom Littlewood had bought a Golf R and was on the forum to offer advice. OP that has the insurance issues etc. Your best bet is to go and speak quietly, politely and in private to the head of business, or dealer principle. More often than not the people in these positions can remedy your situation easily without resorting to the tactics described above. I've seen similar situations resolved, and I'm sure others on the forum who've been in the trade will attest to the same.
-
Launch control stopped working. Restricted for lease?
MagicCat replied to Ronald_yonk's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
Having not read up too much on the launch control limitations is there a maximum amount of times it can be performed before the clutch gives up? Although with only 600 miles on the clock a bit of mechanical sympathy probably wouldn't be a bad idea -
Agreed, but who would enter into a house purchase without the mortgage paperwork signed by the mortgage provider first? There is surely a degree of responsibility by the buyers too, despite the laxness of the dealers (plural). A poor analogy. The difference is that the vendor and finance broker are one and the same, unlike a house purchase which involves multiple parties. Also you do not sign any paperwork until the car is near delivery. This is due to the fact chassis and registration numbers have to be entered into the VWFS system before the finance docs are printed. As I understand the situation the buyer was always purchasing using a VWFS product. He changed his mind and contacted the dealer to change the order. The dealer did so completing all paperwork to tie up the order, but did not re-propose the finance to account for the changes; essential in this instance as it's effectively a model change. The buyer would be none the wiser as no paperwork is generated to confirm the finance proposal, and I believe he was given the new figures? It only came to light when he rang to ensure the GFV changes would not affect his purchase as delivery was some time away. I'm surprised about that. Whilst I agree the actual financial papers don't get signed until the VIN/VRN is known, my order form did contain cash purchase price and also what funding mechanism at what payments would be used. I would be concerned if that proposal did not reflect what I verbally or via email agreed, since if it doesn't there is no legal paperwork in place to protect either party. Nothing I haven't mentioned before in my follow the contract/paperwork post.... I again, what does the order form actually say as that is the only version of the truth ... How even it the order form did stipulate it, and the dealer was naughty by updating the paperwork but not underwriting the funding with a check with company, then I would double check the termination clauses as they would be daft if there wasn't a way for them to get out of it if the product can no longer be delivered. Contracts hold the key on what actually has been agreed, and what each parties obligation and rights are in such situation. No opinion on here will change those. I agree that there will be opinion and conjecture in this thread, as well as the 'net in General when it comes to situations such as this. Taking things at face value it would appear the dealer did everything, including generating all paperwork, but did not re-propose the finance. Obviously only the dealer and OP know if this is the case. With regards to paperwork: In the dealerships I worked I could easily given you an order form with the correct car stated, method of funding, and part exchange. The order form would also break down the part exchange, deposit and finance figure total. I could also have given you a finance quote with the exact figures for monthly repayments, interest charged, GFV etc However the only way you'd know I'd proposed the finance is if you sat and watched me do it. People do genuinely only leave with an order form and a receipt for payment of deposit. It can seem a little strange when ordering a car, especially at some of the prices cars retail at these days. Naturally every dealer is different, and may have other checks and balances in place. However as far as VWFS is concerned no paperwork pertaining to your vehicle is generated until long after order.
-
Agreed, but who would enter into a house purchase without the mortgage paperwork signed by the mortgage provider first? There is surely a degree of responsibility by the buyers too, despite the laxness of the dealers (plural). A poor analogy. The difference is that the vendor and finance broker are one and the same, unlike a house purchase which involves multiple parties. Also you do not sign any paperwork until the car is near delivery. This is due to the fact chassis and registration numbers have to be entered into the VWFS system before the finance docs are printed. As I understand the situation the buyer was always purchasing using a VWFS product. He changed his mind and contacted the dealer to change the order. The dealer did so completing all paperwork to tie up the order, but did not re-propose the finance to account for the changes; essential in this instance as it's effectively a model change. The buyer would be none the wiser as no paperwork is generated to confirm the finance proposal, and I believe he was given the new figures? It only came to light when he rang to ensure the GFV changes would not affect his purchase as delivery was some time away.
-
At the moment i have been dealing with my sales person and then yesterday a person from the accounts/finance department - i am due to get some more information tomorrow as i believe the sales manager was getting involved today. To be fair i have no reason to escalate anything at this point as i believe my issue is being dealt with. Fair enough mate. My experience, for what it's worth is that often salesmen like to keep things quiet as long as they can until the problem hopefully goes away. I've worked with a few who let some truly shocking situations simmer away for months hoping the customer would desist. My advice would be get your ducks in a row. Best of luck
-
If possible that may well be a good option thanks. Finney I am in the same position. Car ordered and deposit paid based on a monthly pcp figure. After hearing about GFV change I called them to check if my deal was still all good. That's when they said that had not done a finance proposal when I ordered it so will do one now. Low behold they want a lot more money off me now. They won't budge on this even though it's there fault. All they are prepared to do is give me back my deposit and let me walk away. I am trying to find a private/3rd party company to quote me a Pcp deal on this car before I give up on the order as it has a very strong part ex for my current vehicle tied into it. It is a bit poor tbh, salesman told me that the GFV change caught them completely by surprise. Like you i think they would prefer me to walk away with my deposit back. After all they will have no issue selling my order to another buyer. Who have you spoken to within the dealership about what's happened?
-
A motor trade paradox in a manner of speaking. If it is assumed the customer knows everything invariably something goes wrong; assume they know nothing and you're accused of patronising them. It's a fine balance. Ultimately salesmen are paid their basic salary to ensure the pre and post sales process is correctly done, and their commission for closing deals and shifting metal. In my relatively short time in the trade I worked for two different manufacturers under various managers and bosses. I guarantee none would have asked me when dissecting the problem posted above if the customer suggested re-proposing the finance due to an order change. Rather I'd have been asked if I ensured all the paperwork was correct to change the order, and if I didn't know if something had to be changed with VWFS, they'd ask why I did not. Most customers don't understand the idiosyncrasies that come with financing cars, and why should they? As long as they understand key facts they shouldn't have to worry about sales staff not completing things properly. In fact most people struggle with the whole buying process. A prime example was having to explain to a professor of statistics why I was not discounting the car by 20% during a no VAT campaign. Rather I was not adding 20% on to the net price. He failed to appreciate that taking 20% off the retail price would render the car below its net price before VAT. Needless to say he had an embarrassing light bulb moment when we went over it with a coffee. So if a man as brilliant as that cannot grasp at first look the issue of discount, how or why should the masses be expected to know how funding lines and finance proposals work?
-
The best advice I could give is not to 'name and shame' or listen too much at the 'advice' offered by online experts. I say this as there's been a few similar tales floating around the bizarres, and sometimes it's best to take a balanced rational approach than taking the advice of some who love being 'barrack room lawyers' Your best bet is to gather all paperwork together. Draft a letter in chronological order that details the events. Decide what it is you require to continue with your order. Make an appointment to speak with the dealer principle (or person of similar standing) and discuss what has happened. Salesman and sales managers at this point are probably best bypassed as it's unlikely they can authorise what's required to potentially put things right. However it's probably wise to inform them of your intentions.
-
I have to be honest, for me it was the cost of the lease that hooked me in. I've owned a couple of VAG cars; Audi TT (225) and a Golf GT Sport, and worked for a VAG dealership before moving on to BMW, and then pastures new away from the trade. Currently have a 1 series and it's due back next year so I was looking around for replacement options. The M135i was on the cards, and despite the looks which people either love or hate, it is a stunning car. However the cost compared to the Golf made choosing the 'R' a simple task. I spotted the deal online and initially thought it was a mistake, being so cheap. Once I realised it was a legitimate offer I knew I'd have to move quickly. I had enquired with contacts in the trade, but due to working away with restrictive telephone / internet access, as well as being month end, with the deals due to end, time was against me. I ended up going with a broker who was able to conduct the proposal etc all via the 'net very quickly. They were superb, organising everything via their online system. I'm paying more than the cheapest deals, but still more than happy with the deal I secured. I have not driven, nor seen one in the flesh, so going on reviews only. I'm sure it'll be as good as everyone states.
-
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
I'd be interested to see how you've worked all the figures to conclude that you'll gain more interest on your 22k in the bank, than what you'll pay in fees and interest, and/or loose by taking PCP? Obviously I'm not expecting you to dissect your finances on a public forum. Rather you'd have to be getting more than 3% on your money to gain more than the interest on your PCP payments surely? Whatever happens I do hope things work out for you -
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
The picture is a little clearer Matt, thanks. I'm a little confused however how you've managed to crunch the numbers to work out that buying on PCP would be of benefit, and leaving your savings in the bank would net you more return over the interest paid? You've even said yourself it was only circa £700 MORE to finance so exactly what is / was the gain in financing? That said you have the more tricky issue of 'he said, I said, I assumed, they assumed' regarding the finance. Your story is the main reason that when I worked in the trade I proposed all finance before the quote became invalid. Hedging your bets that the deal or rate would hold, or indeed get better is dangerous. My advice? Ask to meet the dealer principle. Explain the whole transaction to him and ask what he's prepared to do. If you cannot resolve it take your custom elsewhere, pay cash or bite the finance bullet. Or you could walk away completely? -
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
Ok, as you ask, i don't feel like I can be shot for this post. For many marques, the GFV may not have too much bearing on real-life residuals, but having bought and traded in 6 new VWs before my current GTD (and also what I have been offered for my GTD against the R), history tells me that VW are usually pretty accurate with GFV and expectations to get a grand or so above GFV have always come about. With a published GFV at the time of order placement being £18576 (5 door manual) after 36 months, and looking at what 2011 6Rs have been going for, aiming to get £18600-19600 in p/x in 3 years time seemed very reasonable. Then we have leasegate 2 which will supposedly put far more Rs on the road (and some say there will be a glut of them used, certainly there will be more out there than 6R) and a £3k drop in GFV. VW have backtracked on the 15 year history I have of them putting their money where their mouth is in terms of GFV closely related to a fair residual. Would I prefer the sure thing of being able to walk away from the car at the end of the term I will keep it, at a guaranteed value rather than buy cash and hope it is worth £3k+ more than GFV? Of course I would. It may just be the VW bean counters showing an extreme level of caution they've never shown before and we really will end up with residuals £3k better than the prevailing GFV, but it's the first time it will have happened to me on what will be my 8th new VW. Comparing cash to the finance deal (with max deposit down), best case scenario is £700 better off buying cash (residuals are up at £19600, a grand over the old GFV, as I usually expect), worst case is £2000 better off PCPing on the old GFV terms (if these Rs really are only worth £16600 after 3 years). Previous history suggests strongly that VW GFVs are usually an accurate measurement of true residuals, if that is still the case, this £3k adjustment down is a concern. I do find it interesting that those people who object to this thread's contents are generally already with their Rs, with those great GFVs locked in place should the worst happen. There are some others here who are in the early stages of ordering that could potentially be paying £100 a month more than they thought they were going to if they were expecting to finance but their terms aren't locked it. It was those people who stand to benefit from hearing about the lower GFVs and ensuring at an early stage that they will get the terms that they thought were going to be available from order right up to collection of the car. Why read something that annoys you? If you were a few chapters into a crap book you'd stop reading it wouldn't you? Residuals are important to me, and probably to many here, especially those that ordered in Sept/Oct rather than lease. There are more than a few good cars out there with horrendous depreciation or even average depreciation. VW and Audi residuals made them good value for money despite their high price tag. If Golfs depreciated like Vauxhalls and Renaults, we'd all be paying £550 a month for our Rs. This big chop in GFV is a step in that direction if residuals drop in line with the lower GFVs. Matt, I certainly have not been reading a thread that annoys me, rather I was trying to understand a situation so that if I was to provide a response it would be measured and hopefully helpful. As I understand things you at the very outset were a cash buyer, who was then considering finance based on the £199.00 service deal. You have an order form with the service offer stated as an option, and you at the time saw finance figures on the salesman's computer screen. However the finance was not proposed. The problem you have, and I am playing advocatus diaboli with this so bear with me, is this: The salesman could claim that he offered you a deal based on the order / deal form you have with the £199 servicing option included. However his defence may centre on the fact that to gain the servicing it is presupposed that you are taking finance, but the finance must be proposed within 30 days of quote. So whilst your defence rests upon the argument that as they've quoted the servicing pack in the order / deal form, therefore meaning you were taking finance, they could argue, either: that they explained you needed to provide details for a full finance proposal within 30 days, and / or that the order / deal form was to show the overall cost. Ultimately they may probably use the defence that it was explained at the time of order that to receive the service offer you required finance and you did not provide details in the relevant time scale. Who is right and wrong in this situation is hard to prove. I have had customers who would come in and order cars, pay deposits and then behave in a manner that I can only describe as avoidance, leaving me wondering if the dealership would be left with a deposit and car but no customer to sign finance and collect. I am NOT saying you have done this, but it often happens that customers are given the option of finance to gain a bonus such as cheap or free servicing but do not take the offer up in time and then complain they cannot get what they want. Again I am not saying this is what you have done, rather, it often happens and perhaps the dealer either thinks this, or will use this defence. To return to the issue of GFV. I cannot see how gaining finance under the 'old' GFV which was higher can really benefit you at this time. If you had paid cash the GFV forecast would not assist you in any way other than give an indication that VW are expecting future values to be around that amount. You would be hoping to gain that amount or possibly a little more at trade-in point. There are really just two scenarios now: 1. You agreed to pay cash at order and actually do so at the time of collection. In this instance you will loose whatever value from the car the market dictates at the time of part-ex. No GFV makes a bit of difference to you. 2. You propose the finance at the old rate etc make your payments which are lower with the higher GFV than they are now with the new lower GFV. In this instance it makes not a bit of difference as despite what VW set as the GFV the market will dictate the future value. If as you predict the bottom falls out the market then you will have a car that's massively in negative equity so you'll have to walk away. If not then you may have equity. Key to all this is that VW are not going to give you a trade in price based on the GFV. It will be based on the market value at the time. That is the whole safety feature built into PCP over say lease purchase. It protects you from the market collapsing. It does not guarantee you a trade in price. In fact the more I read the thread and understand your situation it appears that you were perhaps happy to pay cash based on a GFV because you thought it was fair chance you'd get a good PX value. Now however that GFVs have taken a dive you want to take PCP at the old rates as it works out cheaper overall. It strikes me as wanting one's cake and eating it; correct me if I'm wrong though -
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
Monkeyhanger, any chance you could answer these questions, just so I, and many others no doubt can understand what you are seeking? Why are you so concerned over the GFV? What are you hoping to achieve by taking finance now? I ask as GFVs are often misunderstood. -
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
Monkeyhanger, Basically it's simple: If you receive a quotation in the dealer tagged with your details it's valid for 30 days. If you do not accept this proposal within this time then it's no longer valid. To be guaranteed this rate / offer the dealer must propose the finance and gain an accept from VWFS. It then sits on the system until the car is near collection at which point you sign the finance, date it and the dealer scans it along with proofs (if not done already) VWFS check it and pay out to the dealer. You then collect the car. That is how it works. I know because I've been on both sides of a VAG group desk. If you want the same deal the dealer may be able to select another VWFS product and 'tweak' it. More likely though they'll have to use a third party finance company such as Northridge, Black Horse et al and tweak their commission etc to get to a payment you're happy with. Given your argument is about GFV then that's a lot harder. This is due to the value being pretty fixed and only slightly malleable when things like mileage and finance term are changed. I've had customers before who financed because of the offer available and left their money in the bank; normally 0% deals though. When you're dealing with more complex situations that require GMV ' s etc being factored in I'd question if it's worth the hassle? -
GFVs have taken a real kicking with Nov 14 price rise
MagicCat replied to monkeyhanger's topic in VW Golf R MK7 Chat
Guys, I worked for a short while for a VW group franchise. It was some time ago so bear with me. My understanding was that any quote done on VWFS tagged with a customers' name was valid for 30 days regardless. A proposed and accepted finance deal stood regardless of period of delivery. This was evident during some of Skoda's campaigns when the Yeti had long waiting times. I never saw any customer pay more than the proposed finance figures.