Just swapped a standard pp 64 plate gti for an R I picked up yesterday, long drive there and back so very interesting to compare.
The R doesn't feel as fast as I thought it would compared to the gti, obviously much faster but I think it's deceptive as it's the mid range shove and the way the power and speed keep on building that's the most noticeable. Not scientific but I thought the M135i I had a few months ago felt faster however that may be because it's not as polished so there's more sense of speed.
The ride is pretty much the same, both dcc cars, if anything the r rides better!
noise, again similar, but better in the R - love the blips and pops.
Handling and cornering ability, too similar to judge at the moment,need to have it for longer to make a decent comparison.
Options wise the gti had dynaudio and keyless, miss keyless but no major difference I can ascertain in Dynaudio vs standard until you get to high volumes. The R counters with a sunroof which is great and nice, light and airy in a black on black car.
the R's DSG does feel better and smoother when pulling off than the gti but I think I just got a bad one there.