Ive been really lucky and have driven the M2 and the M4 (and the GTS - bleeding scary, that thing). On a normal road I'm confident I'd be faster in my golf than either of the BM's.
That, however is probably more of a reflection of the condition of the UK's roads and my driving skill than anything else. On a track with a skilled driver there would be a massive time difference - but what percentage of driving is like that?
Saying that I love the M2 and would have a Sapphire Black DCT in a heartbeat if it wasnt the bones of 50k for the proper spec (plus the waiting list). It really feels special and I guess that lack of 'specialness' is both the R's USP and its low point for me. Half the time I love going under the radar but occasionally Id like to be in something a little bit overtly exciting.