Jump to content

Older VCDS cable


taffybloke

Recommended Posts

@taffybloke: Hi.

 

Yours is a simple one-paragraph question that alas requires a more complex answer - hence the unfortunate length of this response !

 

The answer to your first question depends on which model "R" you own and it also depends on what your future needs are likely to be!

 

First, I'm not sure what you mean by "version 2" - I assume that it means the current release HEX-NET series devices on sale at the Ross-Tech web-site.

 

As things currently stand, NO version of VCDS will work on the latest model VAG cars that have SFD protection. This means that if this car is later than the mk7.5 Golf R - none of the VCDS devices will be compatible with MQB-evo platform vehicles (like the Golf mk8) because VCDS can't generate the "Token" that is needed to release SFD protection

 

To clarify this point - VCDS can be used to unlock SFD protection if the user has a legitimate "Token" - but VCDS can NOT generate the Token. So a VCDS user must use another method to get the Token. For the "enthusiast market sector", there is NO workable method for generating these Tokens (the professional market sector can buy a subscription service from VW to generate these tokens)

 

Nevertheless, if you believe that Ross-Tech devices are the "industry standard" (as many users do so believe), you could buy the Hex-Net VCDS and wait until/if Ross -Tech eventually develops an integrated solution for SFD. This said, Uwe Ross has been promising an integrated solution for SFD protected cars for almost 4 years now - without success.

 

IMO, this means one of 2 x things: either VCDS has been working diligently over the past 4 x years and Ross-Tech is close to announcing a SFD solution - or there is a fundamental problem with the design of VCDS devices that makes a SFD solution extremely difficult (and expensive) to implement. Again, these options are IMO - but unfortunately (and perhaps, unbelievably) apart from Ross-Tech's many promises, no other explanation for the failure has been provided to VCDS users over the past 4 x years!

 

The other approach is OBD11 - which was the very first third-party diagnostic device to have a fully integrated solution for SFD protection. The software for OBD11's solution for SFD is now mature - so new users get the benefit of not having to test early release version software (which invariably results in bad user experience)

 

BUT (yes, there is always a "but") - another consideration is the future-proof of your chosen diagnostic device - meaning what is the risk of you being in the very same situation when you buy your next car? At the present time, not even OBD11 can unlock SFD2 protection - which is the very latest version protection for VAG cars! However, OBD11 does have a proven track record - something VCDS is lacking, alas!

 

Once again, the choice is entirely yours!

 

And yet other consideration is the cost of OBD11 versus VCDS - which is very different to the purchase price!!

 

Currently (underlined for emphasis), VCDS has no ongoing cost -which is a good thing!. However, the current VCDS pricing regime is sans a SFD solution - I don't know how Ross-Tech will recoup their development costs for SFD over the last 4 years + future years. Hint: very, very likely these costs will NOT be absorbed by Ross-Tech because they are generous!! This is not intended as a criticism of Ross-Tech - it's just a fact of commercial life and to believe otherwise is simply naive!!!!

 

On the down-side - all VCDS devices are subject to a VIN limit of 3, or 10, or unlimited. So VCDS users pay a premium for VIN licenses!

 

In the alternative, OBD11 users must pay an annual subscription fee for their PRO version accounts on top of the purchase price (the physical dongle is the same - the PRO option is a software license). The basic version of OBD11 will only allow basic functionality - like SCANs and access to One-Click-Apps (I suggest that you don't use OCAs). For module coding, you will need a PRO account. OBD11 products have no VIN limits !

 

Finally, VCDS and OBD11 have different technical limitations that are very real for the "user experience" (I love this term). VCDS when used in cable-mode operates entirely from a laptop - whereas OBD11 requires a good ISP service at the place of operation. So if you are using the diagnostic device in a dungeon, or in a building basement - maybe consider the digital signal environment in your choice

 

And finally, finally - don't forget that there are other good diagnostic devices from other manufacturers!!

 

Don

 

PS: the answer to your second question is "YES" -assuming this is a genuine VCDS cable and depending on what you mean by the term "worth anything". I sold my trusty HEX+CAN cable for a very reasonable price on a local forum - albeit the exchange rate for our "Pacific-peso" (i.e. Aussie-dollar) might not translate well to your UK currency! 😉

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@dv52 Hi Don. Thanks for you reply to my simple question 😀 it is much appreciated. I have had the old hex can cable for a few years and used on an 06 Octvia an 08 Passat and my trusty 2013 Exeo with no issues but I now have a 2020 Golf R 7.5 and a 2020 Leon FR 1.5.

 

My main interest would be simply to check any error codes generated and decide if I could fix and clear them myself or decide a visit to a workshop was needed.  I would also like to to do some changes like turning down the soundaktor ect.

 

Mike

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@taffybloke: OK, if this car is truly a mk7.5 (and NOT a mk8) and if your VCDS is a genuine VCDS device, you should be able to still read most of the basic error codes and you should be able to make lots of coding changes (including the soundaktor) with your HEX+CAN cable

 

This said, there will be errors on some modules on your new car that will return the following message :

"U1123 00 [00001001] - Received Error Message [New feature! Extended UDS fault detail is only supported by current gen. interfaces]"

 

Again, the choice is yours as to which device you choose - as I've said in my previous reply

 

Don

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...