I'll be honest.. I want a GTi PP but the reason i'm looking at an R is because I can get one cheaper second hand (up to 1 year old) by a good couple K.
I have my Heart saying .. (it would be fun to own an R for a while and you can always flog it after a year or so) then i have my head saying.. but the resale value isn't as good as the GTi PP and you would keep that longer...
On top of that ... I'm thinking why on earth am i looking at p*ssing £22 - £29k on a car? WTF ! The answer is I want something under 1 year old, relatively quick, good build quality, reliable, decent resale value and half decent MPG.
Only other options are a focus ST (i don't like), Cupra (already have a leon) or a BMW M140i which i find dog ugly.