This is my first auto (owned) and I'm highly impressed with the DSG. It's effortless around town and cruising - and if you want some fun then use the paddles. At this moment in time I'm thinking why haven't I had an auto before, its great! Its no less engaging than a manual and I'm now converted (and I was a die hard manual driver!)
I've driven plenty of faster cars than the R, and they were manual and they're great fun and you really do feel in control of the gears - and I was always put off the thought of an auto as the idea of a car changing gear for me when I didn't want it to put me off - but that's not the case with the DSG, with the paddles you can do what you want, when you want.
The dynaudio is a great option for £500 - it certainly makes everything 'bassier' - but when listening at volume it can be a bit overpowering IMO. However, I don't miss it on my R compared to my mk 7 GTI PP with dynaudio. Oh, and if you're getting a GTI PP I wouldn't go down the DSG route - its not quick enough to warrant an auto box IMO.