Re: 70k- I was comparing new with new. Yes they may be 55k but you'll add 10-15k of options to a Porsche in a blink- nice wheels? nice colour? Cruise? Nav? Uprated sounds? BANG! 15k please.
Having owned one for 7 years and had many dealer loan cars, I think my opinion is valid.
In day to day driving, the Cayman does nothing significantly better than the R.
High revving? Both redline about 7400rpm Heavy? 30kg difference.
The performance difference is negligible and so is the braking and road holding. This leaves the steering feel. I admit the Gen 1 Cayman had a slightly better feel than the R- say the difference between washing the dishes in Marigolds or bare-handed but the latest incarnation is almost identical to the R. There is also less sensation of speed and it doesn't feel as well built as the R.
So, for double the money you get a prettier car, with double the running costs, half the boot and person space and any tradesmen visiting your house that see it, will immediately add 20% to the bill. As a consolation the neighbours will think you are richer than them.
The sad truth is other manufacturers do things so well now, that the massive advantage Porsche had over other cars in the past, is now a myth. "I have seen behind the curtain and there was no Wizard of Oz... just a normal person"