To answer your question an APR stage 1 high torque remap (360-370bhp) is on a par with a new A45.
My work colleague picked up a new A45 (376bhp) less than six months ago. I’m running the APR stage 1 high torque map on my DSG R, no hardware mods. The performance of the two cars is virtually identical at all speeds above about 30mph. We didn’t try a standing start comparison.
We had numerous drags in different gears and the R always edged it by a car length or so. The R was running on 99 RON petrol and the tank was virtually empty, the A45 was running on 97 RON and the tank was three quarters full. Both cars were one up.
The stage 1 R eases away from a standard car by several car lengths over a drag but the speed difference will always be more pronounced if the modified car gets on the throttle earlier. Remaps are obviously available on the A45 too. DMS tout 420bhp for their stage 1, something my colleague is now looking at.
Away from performance I like the A45s brakes, seats, interior and sports exhaust better than the R but the Rs damping (with DCC), steering feel, standard adaptive cruise (not sure if Merc has this as an option), heated windscreen and looks are better. I’d happily drive either car but prefer the softer riding Golf.