I haven't seen the review so I don't know what has been said, but I drive a Civic Type R FK8 as my current daily driver.
It is a wonderful car and truth be told I would keep it for the track if I had the space and the cash. It is an always on machine. Poised and ready to rip its front tyres to shreds. I've got a Golf R on order for two key reasons.
The first is the styling; despite what a stunning car the Civic is to drive, I just feel so conscious getting out of it - especially when I am seeing clients. If they toned this down a little, I am sure they would sell far more. Especially at its price point.
My second reason is that I am looking for something that can be a little calmer for day to day driving. The Golf R fits that bill perfectly.
From my test drive I can say that it does feel heavier. It is hard to describe - whilst it is quicker in the numbers, it just feels a little more laboured and slightly less aggressive. Ultimately I think I would say a little less fun. Some of that is perhaps down to DSG v Manual too.
Both wonderful machines without doubt.