Jump to content

MK8.5 R - OBD-eleven connection help


nw83

Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, Booth11 said:


And presumably the other side fully illuminates when braking?  

Yes the drivers side seems to operate perfectly (and no dash error warnings)

 

Just the passenger side that has no brake light, and this outer surround light is intermittent 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 29
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

2 minutes ago, nw83 said:

Yes the drivers side seems to operate perfectly (and no dash error warnings)

 

Just the passenger side that has no brake light, and this outer surround light is intermittent 


If the full surround lights up on unlocking but not when braking, that does suggest it’s not a failure of the cluster itself. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Booth11 said:


I think @dv52 posted a helpful response a page back in this thread regarding the lights and suggested checking a few things.

 

It sounds like there is a real fault with the passenger side brake light then, not just an error showing up.  

 

I’m no obdeleven expert, just an amateur user, so all I can do is see if I get the same issue you are encountering with obdeleven in not being able to connect to modules other than gateway.  My previous attempts (in order to code) suggest this is the case due to SFD2 protection (the modules are present but inaccessible). I can’t remember the message it came up with but will check tomorrow morning.  My experience when running scans is that it is not unusual to get intermittent errors showing up and for the most part usually nothing to be concerned about.  
 

I think it’s unlikely that detailing would result in the light cluster failing and water would only get into the cluster of there is some defect that allows it in.  I’ve detailed my car fully and done severe, washes and no water ingress into lights at all. 
 

No worries about explaining, I understand it’s been a long day for you and trying to get to the bottom of this.  


Hi, I scanned my car this morning (ignition on, bonnet unlocked) with obdeleven and it scanned through all 25 control units but as you have found (and in line with my previous experience) you can only access unit 19 - Gateway and clear faults that appear under that unit.  I tried a random selection of other control units and as before get the ‘Control unit not responding, Check ignition and try again.  I think this is the SFD2 protection preventing access.  So if the faults are appearing in any of the CU’s that you can’t access, I don’t think you’ll be able to clear them.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Booth11 said:


Hi, I scanned my car this morning (ignition on, bonnet unlocked) with obdeleven and it scanned through all 25 control units but as you have found (and in line with my previous experience) you can only access unit 19 - Gateway and clear faults that appear under that unit.  I tried a random selection of other control units and as before get the ‘Control unit not responding, Check ignition and try again.  I think this is the SFD2 protection preventing access.  So if the faults are appearing in any of the CU’s that you can’t access, I don’t think you’ll be able to clear them.  

 

Ok thank you .. Well at least I know that now and I wont waste any more time with the dongle.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 30/01/2025 at 03:24, nw83 said:

Hi. Sorry.. new here.. Got a 2025 golf with a few faults after a tracker install (owner also on here and knows about them)

 

I've bought an obdeleven next gen device, set up my account, confirmed email, set up google 2 factor, got the bonnet open.

 

I'm using the 'for vag' app as the other one keeps getting in a cycle of telling me my authentication is good and then asking me to re connect.

 

The 'for vag' app seems to connect but takes FOREVER to search for installed modules and then tells me there arent any other than the gateway module?

 

is this normal?

 

Any help greatly appreciated before I accept defeat and pay for it to go back to a dealer 

 

@nw83: Hi.

 

So - as mentioned by others in this thread - I'm not sure that OBD11 will be of much value in fixing the brake-light problem on this car. This is not particularly an OBD11 matter because ALL third-party diagnostic devices are facing the same issues with the newest VAG protection protocols.

 

As for your " but takes FOREVER to search for installed modules" comment" - OBD11's performance involves lots of communication traffic between the mobile-phone/tablet and the central servers on the OBD11 mother-ship.

So the quality of the local internet connection at the place-of-use is crucial to the speed of operation. I'm not sure if this is the case in this instance - but ISP issues are often the cause of slow device performance.

 

Anyhow - why do you need OBD11 to diagnose this problem? Because of SFD2, the tracker install process could NOT have involved coding changes- so unlocking the central electrics module doesn't appear to be either a priority task, or necessary at all (IMO, of course)

 

Without intending any offense, and accepting that anything is possible when fault-finding (and more important, acknowledging that I know nothing about the tracker install process) - isn't the task here checking for a possible wiring-loom/connector problem (which doesn't need SFD2 to be unlocked)?  So, while I agree that a SCAN report would be nice - isn't a wiring diagram of the left tail-light more useful (again, no offense intended)?

 

I don't have a wiring diagram for a Golf 8.5 - but I include below the set-up for the left tail-light on a Golf mk8, which I suspect will be very similar:

D2FjY0R.png

 

 In my picture, "J519" is the module that OBD11 calls the central electrics module. As shown, the left Brake light (M9) is directly connected to the module at pin #71 on Socket A (so there are no intervening coupling points on the wire). The wire color for the left brake-light is black/red.

 

Maybe eyeball the black/red wire in the area that work on the tracker install happened? Also, check that the 12V brake-light signal is reaching pin #3 on the left-tail light connector.

 

Don

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, dv52 said:

 

@nw83: Hi.

 

So - as mentioned by others in this thread - I'm not sure that OBD11 will be of much value in fixing the brake-light problem on this car. This is not particularly an OBD11 matter because ALL third-party diagnostic devices are facing the same issues with the newest VAG protection protocols.

 

As for your " but takes FOREVER to search for installed modules" comment" - OBD11's performance involves lots of communication traffic between the mobile-phone/tablet and the central servers on the OBD11 mother-ship.

So the quality of the local internet connection at the place-of-use is crucial to the speed of operation. I'm not sure if this is the case in this instance - but ISP issues are often the cause of slow device performance.

 

Anyhow - why do you need OBD11 to diagnose this problem? Because of SFD2, the tracker install process could NOT have involved coding changes- so unlocking the central electrics module doesn't appear to be either a priority task, or necessary at all (IMO, of course)

 

Without intending any offense, and accepting that anything is possible when fault-finding (and more important, acknowledging that I know nothing about the tracker install process) - isn't the task here checking for a possible wiring-loom/connector problem (which doesn't need SFD2 to be unlocked)?  So, while I agree that a SCAN report would be nice - isn't a wiring diagram of the left tail-light more useful (again, no offense intended)?

 

I don't have a wiring diagram for a Golf 8.5 - but I include below the set-up for the left tail-light on a Golf mk8, which I suspect will be very similar:

D2FjY0R.png

 

 In my picture, "J519" is the module that OBD11 calls the central electrics module. As shown, the left Brake light (M9) is directly connected to the module at pin #71 on Socket A (so there are no intervening coupling points on the wire). The wire color for the left brake-light is black/red.

 

Maybe eyeball the black/red wire in the area that work on the tracker install happened? Also, check that the 12V brake-light signal is reaching pin #3 on the left-tail light connector.

 

Don

 

 

Appreciate this and don't worry, no offence received.

 

For clarity.. are we talking about the thin black module that is next to the fuse box behind the glove box? With 3 large plugs in it? (typically I'd recognise this as the body control module on other cars)

 

If so, the tracker is not wired in there and I didn't go near that module and actually, it looks like the fuse board needs to come out to even get to the plugs so while I'm happy to do more work and try to check it, it looks more destructive to try to take it out.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@dv52 further to this... a couple of new developments.

 

I checked the CCTV from last week when the car was outside getting washed following the tracker installation and before the detailing. the brake lights were working normally.

 

Also... to rule out any crossed earth etc, I disconnected the tracker and immobiliser this eve. The rear passenger light still had the fault (although thinking about it now perhaps I should have also then disconnected the battery earth for a few mins to reset everything and THEN see if the light behaved itself?)

 

Even though I feel its un likely I caused this with the wiring... I don't like just giving cars back to customers with issues.

 

Do you think it would be beneficial to get to the plug on that light and check the power and earths are getting through properly. If they are... surely that means an internal fault in the actual lamp?

 

If not... still a potential wiring issue somewhere?

 

This is a 2025 car with the IQ lights. I don't suppose you have a wiring diagram for these?

 

Also.. just to clarify.. the issue I'm having is that when you unlock the car and turn the ignition on the light behaves normally as pictured.

 

IQRpNDOTq3GkQbWRlvW4YWdoAUAsWsldL_cZK4cv

 

As soon as you press the brake pedal to start the car, you get the error on the dash 'check rear left light' 'rear left brake light fault' (or very similar wording to that effect). And when I'm standing looking at the rear lamp when someone pressed the brake, the brake lamp part doesn't come on (high level lamp and drivers brake lamp come on fine) and the outer LED part then partly goes out.

 

IQTAy3OlMOnXRbNw-ksF089hAVVF5yOx-ps5gO2c

 

The rest of the light functions fine. Indicators still flash and the side light / running light still stays on.

 

Also just to double check.. the lower brake light part lights up (but dimly as you see in the pics here)... not bright like when the brake is applied) when I walk up to the car with the key. Is that normal?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, nw83 said:

For clarity.. are we talking about the thin black module that is next to the fuse box behind the glove box? With 3 large plugs in it? (typically I'd recognise this as the body control module on other cars)

Yes, we are indeed "talking about the thin black module .....with 3 large plugs in it". And also yes, you are correct to "recognise this as the body control module on other cars".

 

However, I suspect that I'm more of a pendant than you (it's my deficiency, not yours!) - the term BCM is peculiarly a VCDS thing when talking about diagnostic devices. You will find that OBD11 will call the thin black module central electrics module. So, the 2 x identifiers for the module that lives @ address 09 on the CAN network are interchangeable - a rose by another name, if you like!!


I prefer to name the 09 module depending on the flavor of diagnostic device that is being discussed - hence the silent BCM when referring to OBD11!!

 

 

16 hours ago, nw83 said:

If so, the tracker is not wired in there and I didn't go near that module and actually, it looks like the fuse board needs to come out to even get to the plugs so while I'm happy to do more work and try to check it, it looks more destructive to try to take it out.

Agreed, it's a real pain in the backside to get to the BCM - my suggestion was simply to try and eyeball the area of the wiring looms that emanate from the module. I suspect that the black/red wire for the brake-light will be deeply buried in one of these looms - so it's a low probability suggestion!!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, nw83 said:

Do you think it would be beneficial to get to the plug on that light and check the power and earths are getting through properly. If they are... surely that means an internal fault in the actual lamp?

 

If not... still a potential wiring issue somewhere?

 

This is a 2025 car with the IQ lights. I don't suppose you have a wiring diagram for these?

As I said in my first reply "I don't have a wiring diagram for a Golf 8.5" - but I've cobbled together a wiring diagram for the "up-market" version  of the left-outer tail-light fitting from my Golf mk8 material. I don't know if my diagram is relevant to this later model car:

6s9NZZs.png

 

I'm not sure of your background -  but my observation of different models/brands in the VAG fleet is that the wiring for Brake-lights is treated with special care. Probably for safety reasons, brake light wires on VAG cars tend to be directly connected from the module to the lamp socket. This happens for the brake-light on both the wiring diagrams that I've posted-up.  So, I find it difficult to understand how your install work would interfere with the Brake light itself, or the signal wire (unless you spliced into the wire - which you have said didn't happen).

 

BUT, up-market fittings like IQ lights contain extra smarts and additional circuitry - for example, these fittings  require a separate battery rail voltage that's terminated onto the tail-light connector and lamp operations are more interdependent.

 

So, even if my mk8 set-up above is not relevant to this car -notice the presence of TIUL in my wiring diagram. I bring this to your attention as an example of how a seemingly unrelated component (in this case, a coupling point inside the cabin), can affect tail-light operation.

 

4 hours ago, nw83 said:

Also.. just to clarify.. the issue I'm having is that when you unlock the car and turn the ignition on the light behaves normally as pictured.

 

As soon as you press the brake pedal to start the car, you get the error on the dash 'check rear left light' 'rear left brake light fault' (or very similar wording to that effect).

 As I said earlier, the operation of the Brake lights is treated specially on VAG cars for safety reasons.  On later model Golfs (i.e. MQB platform Golf mk7/mk7.5 and MQB-evo platform - Golf mk8/mk8.5) there are 2 x independent Brake light switch facilities. This "redundancy" for the brake-light switch probably is best demonstrated in the freeze-frame data when a fault occurs.

 

Below is a copy of the freeze-frame data from a fault as reported by OBD11.  There's nothing particularly special about this fault - it's simply provided for illustrative purpose:

 

Fault:
B1330F0 - Anti-theft alarm system sensor
Data record invalid
static
Priority - 4
Malfunction frequency counter - 1
Unlearning counter - 69
km-Mileage - 33504 km
Terminal 15 status - On
Terminal 50 status - Off
Voltage - 14.6 V
Outside air temperature - 15.0 °C
Status Bremslichtschalter (HW) - Off
Status Bremslichtschalter (CAN) - Off
Off - operated
Parking light - not activated
Automatic high beam assist - not activated
Low beam - not activated
Parking light left - not activated
Parking light right - not activated
Letzte Weckursache/ Werte [00;2E] - keine Störschutzursache
CAN-Bus aktiv - On
 

Notice "Status Bremslichtschalter" (in English, "Status Brake light switch") in the list of freeze-frame records -  and in particular, notice that there is 2 x paths for the brake light switch. This means that the Brake light can be switched by physical hardware (i.e. pressing the brake pedal), or it can be activated via a CAN based message. These are entirely independent  mechanisms!

 

So, I expect that "when you unlock the car and turn the ignition on the light behaves normally" because the act of turning-ON the ignition generates a CAN wake-up signal for the modules in the car - which subsequently results in a type of POST (Power-On System Test) that flashes the brake light via the CAN mechanism.  Clearly the CAN based brake-light switch passes the POST procedure

 

However, "as soon as you press the brake pedal to start the car, you get the error on the dash" because by pressing the brake pedal , you are invoking the Hardware option of the brake-light mechanism. Obviously the fault is binding in the hardware version of the brake-light switch.

 

Hope this makes sense - my apology if my explanation is confusing!!

Don

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the info and help. I understood most of it. 

 

I took the cover off the rear light and immediately I could see the wiring was different to your diagrams so I didn't actually go any further as it must all be can bus type data signals now which I don't really know how to check anyway.

 

Its just got 3 wires going into the light. 

 

Brown

Black / White

Purple / Brown or Yellow.. couldn't quite tell.

 

IQR88lI8uuq2QZTQznHhCDV1AVl4UIxGLgDlezAq

 

So... short of still hoping that an error code reset will fix this... I'm stumped and it will have to go to the dealers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@nw83: Yes, I wasn't hopeful that my mk8 wiring diagram would be the same as the mk8.5 - but I thought, worth a try !

 

On VAG cars, the brown wire is invariably earth (see my pictures). I guess you could put an oscilloscope trace on the remaining 2 x wires - but this would only prove your "CAN bus" suspicion (which I suspect has to be true - since the active wire-count appears to be less than the lamp count for the fitting).

 

I'm not sure that I have any other suggestions - other than  a plea if anyone else here has a wiring diagram for this car?

 

Don

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...

Hi, I was just wondering if you ever found out what was the issue?

 

I have just bought a MK 8.5 and my brake lights have stopped working, but the 3rd brake light still functions. It is going back to the garage tomorrow but just wondering what it could be after reading this thread. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, JamesR27 said:

Hi, I was just wondering if you ever found out what was the issue?

 

I have just bought a MK 8.5 and my brake lights have stopped working, but the 3rd brake light still functions. It is going back to the garage tomorrow but just wondering what it could be after reading this thread. 

Hi James, it was my car that NW83 was working on. The dealer diagnosed it as a faulty rear light cluster and it was replaced under warranty.  Mine was just the LHS but same fault as yours, tail light working but not the brake light.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, nn7man said:

Hi James, it was my car that NW83 was working on. The dealer diagnosed it as a faulty rear light cluster and it was replaced under warranty.  Mine was just the LHS but same fault as yours, tail light working but not the brake light.


thanks for the quick reply. That is what the service manager mentioned when I booked it in and was hoping it was something else as only just had the car ceramic protected. 
 

When I started the car the left one went and then shortly after the right one went which was strange. Will see what happens tomorrow. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...