R'men Posted January 5, 2015 Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 Tony - complete misunderstanding; considering I'm Polish it must be due to my limited English It's not decelerating, but opening throttle, that does *indeed* prepare the lower gear (kick-down being the extreme though unrelated example). I hadn't even realised you weren't a native English speaker! So you're English is very good Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 5, 2015 Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 Tony - complete misunderstanding; considering I'm Polish it must be due to my limited English It's not decelerating, but opening throttle, that does *indeed* prepare the lower gear (kick-down being the extreme though unrelated example). This might help explain it (source: http://www.vw.ca/en/shopping_tools/innovation/powertrain/dsg/gear_changes.html ) The principle behind overlapping gear changes in the DSG is that when one gear is engaged, another gear is always preselected. If a gear change is about to occur, one clutch opens within three to four hundredths of a second while the other closes. The mechatronics unit ensures that this takes place quickly and accurately in a way that would not be possible manually. As such, the change of gear is imperceptible to the driver and is achieved without any interruption of driving power. The decision as to which gear should be engaged next is taken by the control unit based on the position/operation of the accelerator, engine speed and vehicle speed. If the accelerator pedal is pressed and the vehicle speeds up, the next-highest gear will be preselected before the shift point is reached. If the accelerator is not operated, however, i.e. the vehicle is in overrun, the next-lowest gear will be preselected. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 5, 2015 Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 Kickdown is an exception as it will select the optimum gear for performance and may skip gears to achieve. Even in manual mode if you are pootling around in 5th at 40 mph and floor the throttle past the soft stop it will kickdown several gears. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
R Soul Posted January 6, 2015 Report Share Posted January 6, 2015 I'm not 100% certain but I think I might have a solution to at least part of this problem of yours MoldCAD.. OK so my car is a Mark 6 and has had a DSG remap but even when it was still on stock software it very definitely blips on down changes when in manual mode. I drive in manual 80% of the time (never in 'S') and I think I might know what's going on in terms of why you might be getting severe jerkiness in the lower gears on down changes if using the paddles or lever. Even in manual mode, the software is set so that if you don't make a change down manually when decelerating, it'll do it for you. The limit which this 'nanny' mode kicks in is normally set at around 1,200rpm but can be higher depending on whether you're breaking at the rime of deceleration. This is to prevent the car from under-revving or stalling in the event of you, the driver, forgetting to change down manually. Therefore if in manual mode the driver decides to change down manually by using the lever or paddle at the same time as nanny is saying 'OMG he's forgotten to tell me want to do so I'm going to do it myself', all sorts of mayhem ensues as the poor old DSG is basically having an argument with itself. This is particularly noticeable in my car when in 2nd gear changing down to 1st but does happen in 3rd to 2nd as well. My solution to this is either to let nanny do the changes down to 2nd and 1st, or make sure that I'm changing down at high enough revs to avoid the conflict. This normally works but even I get caught our occasionally, at which point I apologise to the box and promise it won't happen again. I've not yet driven the Mark 7 (I've so far resisted the temptation as I know if I do, I'll be disappointed in my current car which I've promised myself I will keep until the R400 comes out) but I know that the box software should blip the throttle when the car is decelerating (i.e. when the driver's foot is off the accelerator) and it gets a command from the driver to change down using the paddle or the lever. If your car does not do this then I would suggest that you have a problem. I'm no great expert on the workings of the boxes or the software which controls it but it might just be a case of your dealer re-installing the DSG software. There might even be an update if the problem has been reported by others. I hope this helps. Re: Tony - complete misunderstanding; considering I'm Polish it must be due to my limited English If all British born members on this forum had such a good command of the English language as you MoldCAD, I would spend considerably less time trying to work out what the hell they were saying. You are to be congratulated! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
koffee Posted January 6, 2015 Report Share Posted January 6, 2015 OK, so I took my R for another, more "intelligent" test of the manual mode. Since I wasn't sure which approach to adopt, it was not a spirited ride I tried yesterday, but instead a normal (which in my books is dynamic, but not at all sporty) drive around the town. I kept in mind that - even though I've had my R for over 3 months now - I never used it (or any other DSG car) in manual mode before, so coming from my BMW SAT I must learn how to drive it, and keep it easy. Results? A full success, i.e. my DSG can be downshifted manually without a single lurch. Of course I realize even better now that in order to drive it at its limit and still keep it smooth using paddles requires learning, as it's quite a different beast than a regular manual (obviously), my old E46 SMG (not so obvious but true), and above all - than a fully automatic transmission like the one in my BMW when used in manual (paddles override), too. Specifically, preparing the car to enter a sharp corner by manually downshifting to the optimum gear - especially with lower speeds/gears - requires real skill. And even though I didn't train it today yet, I realize now that it's the driver who is responsible for rev-matching; the R implementation of DSG manual mode will NOT do it for you all by itself! Anyway - all this is a good thing in that I have started becoming bored with driving either of my cars (SAT8 BMW and DSG R) in full Auto mode; using paddles in the F10 is not exciting at all either (way too many gears). Now I know that DSG gearbox in my R is a new exciting toy, which I need to master and enjoy afterwards! It's going to be very rewarding BTW until now I wished it had at least 7 gears (for fuel economy and comfort on those long motorway stretches), but now I understand why VAG chose to put only 6 gears in the R's DSG... The only one thing that spoils the game a little is the opposite directions the "stick" works in the two cars... Some things should really get standardized! I have read it twice but can't find what is the best way to do the proper downshift? I am having my R in few weeks (fingers crossed) but want to know the way I should behave - it would be my first auto / dsg - so I am little bit scared.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 6, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 6, 2015 I have read it twice but can't find what is the best way to do the proper downshift? I am having my R in few weeks (fingers crossed) but want to know the way I should behave - it would be my first auto / dsg - so I am little bit scared.. OK, so from what I managed to learn (gosh, with some 43 years of driving experience, I came to write about learning the basics again ) - assuming I'm in the Manual mode, and only use paddles or the gear selector: 1. When just coasting/slowing down (like when approaching street lights): really there is not much new to it; you can as well let DSG upshift for you through gears when rpm drops below certain threshold (ca. 1200 rpm) 2. When decelerating/braking hard, and using engine braking for aiding the brakes: as long as your foot is pressing the brake (and not the gas) pedal, again nothing special to it: just pull the left paddle at the rpm YOU think appropriate (the higher it is the more engine braking); it will blip throttle for you (3->2 and especially 2->1 may be a little jerky, but are "dumped" by the wheel braking forces; BTW they are felt this way when braking hard in Auto/Sport modes as well - again the lurches mitigated by the braking action) 3. During spirited driving, when preparing the car to enter a sharp curve in what YOU consider to be the right gear for power-exiting: your foot MAY happen to be on the gas and not on the brake pedal (yes you are slowing down, but hey - didn't I say it's a spirited driving?) , so you must remember to "tell" your DSG to prepare the lower gear for you; just step on the gas very quickly RIGHT before downshifting by pulling the left paddle (all this should last fractions of a second) Of course the scenario No 3 is the most difficult one, as actually it's YOU (and not your DSG) who is doing the rev-matching. It really takes some training! And remember: in the scenario No 3, always be aware what you right foot is doing; if it's not braking and you're about to manually downshift (especially 3->2 or 2->1), never let feather the gas pedal - this will make DSG anticipate upshift rather than downshift, so when you pull that left paddle there will be nothing happening for a long while, and a violent jerk as it finally does what you expect. If you want to test this logic, do the following experiment: - in D mode (auto), drive with any speed and gear DSG chosen for it (e.g. 50 km/h at D4); than do exactly what I described above as feathering (or slightly lifting off) on the gas pedal and watch the area between the clocks; you will see the upshift as DSG will switch to the highest gear possible for the given speed; this is done with fuel efficiency in mind (so for example the "D4" indicator will change to "D5"). To summarize: anyone following the development of my "Manual mode DSG jerkiness" thread may think that - either my DSG is out of order - or I don't know how to use it properly But the truth is - and I realize it more and more - that my impressions are heavily biased by where I'm coming from: the silky smooth Sport Automatic Transmission by ZF I have in my BMW. No clutch/double clutch, mechanical transmission can be as smooth as the hydrokinetic torque converter of a modern AT! In fact, the ZF8 SAT is so good (not only smooth, but fast, too), that I picked it over the classic 6MT when configuring my "last true bimmer" - the M235i; yes it's gonna be RWD as a real bimmer should, but no more stick for me! I need both hands to control fishtailing But I guess I'm digressing koffee 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 6, 2015 Report Share Posted January 6, 2015 The only times I have encountered scenario 3 is when trundling along at low rpm and deciding I need to change down for a hill or to pass. In spirited driving I am changing down in braking zones, changing up whilst accelerating. I guess a corner may be tighter than expected and more speed is lost requiring another downshift but that wouldn't be the norm that you are changing down on throttle. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 7, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 But I said just that - in scenario 3, when you're into the corner and see it is sharper than expected and requires more slow-down and another downshift, just rev-up slightly for a fraction of a second before executing it; otherwise your foot stays on the brake, not the gas pedal - and you have scenario 2, basically. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AgentFruit Posted January 7, 2015 Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 If I was a newcomer I'd be reading that thinking omg! Either it's become second nature to me or we've got DSG'so that are behaving quite differently. I don't have to do any throttle blipping to rev match...I've been testing whilst dropping down a gear to accelerate rather than decelerate. Still haven't been able to produce a jerk, though R Soul's post did remind me of the early days when I hadn't got the hang of it....coasting, followed by a manual override downshift at the same time that the box dropped down a gear...now that was lumpy! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 7, 2015 Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 But I said just that - in scenario 3, when you're into the corner and see it is sharper than expected and requires more slow-down and another downshift, just rev-up slightly for a fraction of a second before executing it; otherwise your foot stays on the brake, not the gas pedal - and you have scenario 2, basically. Still not getting this, if you are still slowing down and require another downshift a tug on the left paddle will perform a rev matched fast shift. Accelerating briefly (remember you can't rev without accelerating in a DSG) will tell the box to preselect the next higher gear which is not what you want. Unless I am missing something (and I have had a previous DSG for four years) it really is incredibly simple. Slow down and changing down will give the fastest rev matched downshifts, accelerating full throttle the fastest upshifts. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 7, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 Please understand I had a very specific situation in mind when I wrote about pressing the gas pedal briefly (i.e. just blipping the throttle, not "accelerating") just before (heck - almost at the same time as) pulling the left paddle to downshift. As most posters in this thread agreed, the 2->1 upshift can indeed introduce a lag and jerkiness; so please test my advice by rolling slowly in the 2nd gear at some 2-2,5k rpm and trying to downshift to the 1st gear while maintaining the speed (i.e. not slowing down or braking). Without this brief blip (not "acceleration"!!!), you will most probably wait a while (the lag), followed by sort of a jerk backwards at the moment the 1st is actually engaged... All I'm saying is you can avoid it completely with this momentary gas addition (again: not actual acceleration - the blip is not supposed to last long enough to cause any - even in Race mode where throttle lag is minimal). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 7, 2015 Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 I see, I presume the throttle blip is enough to prepare the box for kickdown and select the lower gear as staying on a light throttle the box will be prepared to change up. Can't say I have ever tried to change to first whilst maintaining speed, under braking it is fine (rev matches and changes quickly). The only time I have ever encountered delays on downshifts are manually overriding when in D and want to downshift whilst not slowing down, I guess a blip here could speed up the process, I'll give it a go! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 7, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 I see, I presume the throttle blip is enough to prepare the box for kickdown and select the lower gear as staying on a light throttle the box will be prepared to change up. Exactly what I mean, Tony Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Adamf1991 Posted January 7, 2015 Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 Sorry I know this has been covered else where with the jumpy downshifts, but the cars in now for the issue. I've spoke to 'dsg specialist' and he tells me that the gearbox adapts to a driving style is this correct?? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitkat Posted January 7, 2015 Report Share Posted January 7, 2015 yes adam that is correct. it does adapt to different driving styles Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.