MoldCAD Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 OK guys, it's been too beautiful to be true - a car as technology-stuffed as the R not showing any serious flaw even once since new - so here is my first serious flaw (or malfunction) report... I just took it for a ride and - having just passed some 3000 miles - switched it to Race, the DSG lever to the right and expected some thrill from spirited driving using paddles. All was fine until the first deceleration and downshifts; 5->4 was OK, 4->3 - still no drama, but a little jerky. But the 3->2 and especially 2->1 were so bad i really thought the car is seriously broken: - takes for ages - when finally decides to shift it does it so violently I almost cry out of my mechanical sympathy for the car So I repeated the exercise, this time trying to analyse what's going on - and I'm 90% positive my R doesn't increase rpm at manual downshifts! So you can imagine the result - it's as if somebody with a regular manual transmission forced the 1st gear in and just let go on the clutch... Do your DSGs ever behave like this? Is it an "operator error" (possible, as I have muscle memory from my BMWs with SMG years ago, and 8AT with silky smooth manual mode now), design flaw, or what?!! No message in the Car Status, no error light, BTW. The same in all modes (well - didn't try ECO). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JonnyG Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 I don't think any of my DSG cars have "rev matched" in manual mode (by automatically blipping the throttle), but they have definitely all done it in S mode. It really is trial and error sometimes to find the best method with DSG. You need to remember that when you are in 3rd gear, the DSG box will have 2nd or 4th pre-engaged on the other clutch and ready to change to. I suspect your box had 4th preloaded, hence the delay and drama when you requested 2nd. So you need to change your driving style to find a way to get 2nd preloaded in this situation (i.e experiment with your right foot eg, on accelerator & how much, or on the brake, or neither) My current car is a bit similar, very jerky if I'm cruising at say 35mph up to a car in 3rd (in manual mode), and I want to change down to 2nd for a quick overtake. If I keep my foot on the accelerator it is slow and jerky to change to 2nd. However through trial and error I have found that if I momentarily take my foot off the accelerator, then change gear to 2nd, then reapply the accelerator it is a lot lot smoother. Don't ask me why, but that works for me ! When braking from high speed on dual carriageways for roundabouts I have found S-mode is best (you get the engine braking and the throttle blips on downchange), and then I switch back to M mode just before the give way line to keep hold of 2nd gear. A quick change right through from Smode - D - M will keep hold of the original gear S mode had engaged (i.e. before D mode has chance to alter it) but it needs to be done all in one movement fairly quickly. Its a shame you can't go direct from S-mode to M-mode. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 4, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 Yeah - well, didn't know Tiptronic mode is not supposed to match-rev; thanks for that tip (pun unintended). Furthermore, I'm more and more into thinking it has been my fault - DSG really seems to be quite a different animal from anything I drove (and drive) so far. One thing is for sure: when in Manual, you just need to know exactly what you're going to do next (accelerate? slow-down with engine braking?); it simply doesn't tolerate playing with it (like downshifting without clear intent, which - as I see it now after a second thought - I did). Anyway, the article linked to in this forum not so long time ago (http://forums.vwvortex.com/showthread.php?5989734-How-to-Play-The-DSG-Game-and-Win-DSG-Driving-Tips-and-Tricks) needs another reading by somebody who - like myself: - never had a car with DSG before his/her R - during break-in period, mainly used it in auto (D) mode One thing I'm going to test at the nearest opportunity is flip it to Manual again, and: - go 4->3->2->1 while braking (typical slow-down with engine-aided braking scenario) - try the 2->1 downshift with the throttle substantially open (in order to force the "performance mode", so that the 1st gear is "prepared" rather than the 3rd - which is what might have happened today, when I was feathering on the gas pedal if I remember correctly). If my DSG passes both tests I'm just going to assume all is OK, and focus on my own driving technique rather than arranging a visit at the dealer Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
R'men Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 Can't comment on the R DSG box as I've gone manual this time. However, on my last car, a S-Tronic S4, the engine always revved matched going down. This was in D, S or manual and going down in every gear. I'm sure it will be the same in th R. Certainly yours doesn't seem right from your description. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rick@UnicornMotorDev Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 The DSG works by pre selecting a gear. The pre selected gear is engaged and it switches over smoothly. If you choose a non pre selected gear, then it takes a long time to select it hence the delay. if you are braking then it will usually preselect a low gear, but if accelerating it will have a higher gear ready. McLaren amoungst others have a driver pre select where a gentle pull on the paddle will preselect a gear, then a firm pull will select it. Rick Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 4, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 I don't think any of my DSG cars have "rev matched" in manual mode (by automatically blipping the throttle), a S-Tronic S4, the engine always revved matched going down. This was in D, S or manual and going down in every gear. I'm sure it will be the same in th R. Certainly yours doesn't seem right from your description. These are 100% opposite opinions (at least when talking of Manual mode) - and the subject is so important that a definite answer must exist. So I did a quick Google search - and - to my disbelief - haven't found a definite answer!!! So: does anyone know for a fact that the 7R's DSG is supposed to rev-match (aka throttle-blip) when downshifting in Manual mode (i.e. using the paddles or selector)? Note: I'm stressing "manual mode" here as my recent experience would indicate it doesn't do rev-matching, relying solely on clutch slippage - and with a high rpm "offset" (like when downshifting 2->1 at a rather high speed) - it downshifts slowly and extremely jerky. On the other hand, when slowing down in auto mode (D or S), it definitely does throttle-blip (you can feel and hear it); sometimes it even "overdoes" whereby - after downshifting say from 3->2 you can feel that were your foot not be braking the car sufficiently, it would jump forward (meaning rising revs too high before actually downshifting and biting)... So, again: does anyone know for sure? Cause - depending on the answer - either I need some learning how to operate my DSG in M properly, or my R's DSG needs a good inspection... Opinions welcome! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 Both My DSG R and the test drive car throttle blip on downshift in manual mode in any driver selection profile. It is very noticeable and more aggressive in race mode. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 4, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 I must tell you guys I'm at a loss. The closest thing to DSG I ever used was BMW's MSG; when driving on the 2nd gear with a speed corresponding to engine rpm that would still be inside allowable range after downshifting to the 1st and pulling the "-" paddle, before anything happened I could always hear (and see on the rev counter) the absolutely precise up-rev, so that - after the 1st gear engaged and the clutch was released - there was hardly any lurch (not to mention jerk) of the car... Mine was the first generation of SMG, so it was waaay slower than DSG is in the 7R - but does it explain that I can't notice the same happen with my R when downshifting in Manual? The rev counter needle goes up at the very moment of downshift completion, not before - so how can it be even called "rev-matching"? I'd really think my DSG is just out of order, but other than those manual downshifts the unit is working flawlessly... Could it be so poorly designed in this area? Because the more I browse the Internet, the more doubts and questions similar to mine - and not a single conclusive answer. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AgentFruit Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 Assuming you're showing the car a degree of mechanical sympathy and are lifting off slightly before each downshift, no this jerkiness that you describe is not normal (although some others have described it). If the car is badly driven it's jerky, or if there's a fault of course it'd be jerky, but I can assure you that my DSG is seamless when it downshifts. It's almost imperceptible. When the box was new (under 1000 miles) and I was a bit of a numpty driving it, the 2>1 was lumpy (in manual or paddles override), but as soon as it wore in and I remembered that it needs to be driven with intelligence, just as you'd drive a manual, it was fine. Better than any fully manual downshift could ever be. Having read your post today I've been out and driven mine like an idiot, downshifting without lifting off, and even then it isn't jerky....just a little noticeable. I suggest you take it to the garage. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
R'men Posted January 4, 2015 Report Share Posted January 4, 2015 OK I think we have established rev matching should happen on the R DSG in manual. Both from my experiences of other VAG DSG (my S4 and I've driven lots others - RS4, S5, 2.0lt TSi A4's) So the question is, is it working properly on yours? When you change down when in S or D does is feel different than when changing down in manual? The actual rev matching should feel the same. Rev matching on a DSG gearbox is very quick. The engine will literally rev milliseconds ahead of the engagement of the wheel speed to the gearbox. So may not be easily visible or be blatently obvious to the uninitiated One other point to bear in mind is as Rick said, this is a DSG box, not an auto. So gear changes are not as smooth as a conventional auto. Think of it a manual with an auto change. The rev matching will smooth out the clunkiness but not make a totally seemless gear change when your 'on it' and making big downshifts. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 5, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 When you change down when in S or D does is feel different than when changing down in manual? The actual rev matching should feel the same. Well - as I said, in any mode other than Manual it downshifts OK. But then again - in D or S, it only downshifts when the rpm gets too low for the current gear (I'm talking slow-down or braking, of course), and in such scenario also downshifts in manual mode are seamless. It's only when I downshift manually at rpm higher than the minimum, required for the gear I am currently in... If I just release the throttle completely and let the car slow down to the halt by itself, I can feel and see (on the rev counter) absolutely smooth downshifts, one by one, down to and including the 1st gear - in all modes, including Manual! I still hope it just takes some more getting used to on my side. If only I knew which of the 2 contradictory "recipes" to use; each sounds logical but both cannot work the same, right? - recommendation to "lift-off slightly" before downshifting: sounds along the mechanical sympathy line, but by doing so, my DSG will "prepare" the higher rather than the lower gear, and the downshift may be longish and clunky - recommendation to momentarily open the throttle just before downshifting: this should tell DSG to prepare the lower gear OK, but when braking through gears rather hard, doesn't pressing on the accelerator defy logic? Anyway: I will test and learn and - should the latter method work the best - it would mean it's not DSG that does rev-matching but the driver Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AgentFruit Posted January 5, 2015 Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 Lifting off momentarily before downshifting will NOT prepare the higher gear. If you're referring to a link you've read to a guide to DSG elsewhere it doesn't tally with this box. If you lift off it stops any jerkiness in ALL driving modes. I spend most of my time either in fully manual stick to the left, or paddles overriden D (Normal). The only situation that can cause the slightest non-smoothness is downshifting without lifting off, but in a manual car that'd be classed as driving like a plonker. 2-1 takes a little practice in manual - it's just a question of getting the revs right by changing down at the right time. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 5, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 OK, so I took my R for another, more "intelligent" test of the manual mode. Since I wasn't sure which approach to adopt, it was not a spirited ride I tried yesterday, but instead a normal (which in my books is dynamic, but not at all sporty) drive around the town. I kept in mind that - even though I've had my R for over 3 months now - I never used it (or any other DSG car) in manual mode before, so coming from my BMW SAT I must learn how to drive it, and keep it easy. Results? A full success, i.e. my DSG can be downshifted manually without a single lurch. Of course I realize even better now that in order to drive it at its limit and still keep it smooth using paddles requires learning, as it's quite a different beast than a regular manual (obviously), my old E46 SMG (not so obvious but true), and above all - than a fully automatic transmission like the one in my BMW when used in manual (paddles override), too. Specifically, preparing the car to enter a sharp corner by manually downshifting to the optimum gear - especially with lower speeds/gears - requires real skill. And even though I didn't train it today yet, I realize now that it's the driver who is responsible for rev-matching; the R implementation of DSG manual mode will NOT do it for you all by itself! Anyway - all this is a good thing in that I have started becoming bored with driving either of my cars (SAT8 BMW and DSG R) in full Auto mode; using paddles in the F10 is not exciting at all either (way too many gears). Now I know that DSG gearbox in my R is a new exciting toy, which I need to master and enjoy afterwards! It's going to be very rewarding BTW until now I wished it had at least 7 gears (for fuel economy and comfort on those long motorway stretches), but now I understand why VAG chose to put only 6 gears in the R's DSG... The only one thing that spoils the game a little is the opposite directions the "stick" works in the two cars... Some things should really get standardized! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted January 5, 2015 Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 - recommendation to momentarily open the throttle just before downshifting: this should tell DSG to prepare the lower gear OK, but when braking through gears rather hard, doesn't pressing on the accelerator defy logic? More than hard, more like impossible as pressing the brake cuts the fuel! Not sure where you saw that as decelerating prepares the lower gear. All the driver needs to do is lift off (and more likely brake) and change down and a perfect blipped downshift is the result! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoldCAD Posted January 5, 2015 Author Report Share Posted January 5, 2015 More than hard, more like impossible as pressing the brake cuts the fuel! Not sure where you saw that as decelerating prepares the lower gear. All the driver needs to do is lift off (and more likely brake) and change down and a perfect blipped downshift is the result! Tony - complete misunderstanding; considering I'm Polish it must be due to my limited English It's not decelerating, but opening throttle, that does *indeed* prepare the lower gear (kick-down being the extreme though unrelated example). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.