Jump to content

TonyR

Members
  • Posts

    148
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TonyR

  1. TonyR

    DSG?

    Congrats! I think as a piece of tech the DSG is fantastic but as my last 3 cars have been DSG, manual, DSG I agree the arguments are pretty well balanced. For an enthusiast the DSG makes an automatic an option, yet for me it is still a tough decision and there is no wrong choice IMHO. I can't agree with the extreme views either way and there seems a lot of misunderstanding how a DSG works and couldn't care less about a fraction of a second 0-60 advantage either when it comes to ticking the box.
  2. TonyR

    DSG?

    You are describing a sequential gearbox, motorcyclists have managed to drop down to the right gear to overtake for years! Regardless if you are really that caught out in the wrong gear through lack of anticipation you can simply bury the throttle past the soft stop and force a kick down override. Otherwise the DSG can be driven just like any sequential manual if you choose in terms of gear selection.
  3. The differences aren't as huge as people may like to think. Having driven manuals for thirty odd years a DSG is quite instinctive. I rode a motorbike without any form of gear indicator for years too, it quickly becomes very intuitive what you need to do to quickly gain acceleration by the sound of the engine and rev counter. Regardless if you ever do find yourself needing to accelerate instantly simply burying your right foot into the bulkhead initiates kickdown which is pretty impressive in this car. I genuinely do see why people may prefer a manual over DSG but the whole being out of control of the gearbox is overstated IMHO, it is really easy to manage with a small learning curve.
  4. I referred to the DSG vs manual debate bringing out the worst in people and gave examples of both sides, it was an observation of many posts not just yours. As you say we get manual snobs who sneer at a pipe and slippers "automatic" which is way off the mark. However, there is nothing wrong with finding having more to do more engaging. Fast road driving is one big feel good fantasy anyway, "lap times" on public roads are more a measure of how big a nutter someone is prepared to be rather than a measure of skill, you need a track or rally stage for that. Doesn't stop you having some fun though but thinking this is what Sébastien Ogier would do on the same road in a competitive environment is beyond fantasy!
  5. The DSG vs manual debate seems to bring the worst out in people - real men drive manuals, DSG is faster etc. Those that like the opposite are incapable at driving flat out on public roads. Of course we could change "incapable" with "unwilling" yet still have a desire to be entertained whilst driving with boundaries of responsibility. Then it comes down to personal choice. My last four cars have been manual, DSG, manual, DSG. For me the perfect box would have a "proper" sequential shifter like a rally/race car with an optional clutch for setting off and a full auto option for stop start traffic. Maybe even a full manual mode with clutch thrown in too!
  6. Checked and topped up twice so far at 3k miles. Seems pretty normal for a new car in my experience (Alfa, Audi, BMW).
  7. Wait until the owner posts their figures on the mpg thread here
  8. The R-Line Passat has been around a while. Doesn't seem much different to Audi having S models and an S-Line trim option, Just covering all bases, the R-Line doesn't make it look like an R with a 1.4 engine, it is still different.
  9. Pretty much sums it up for me. The R matches my needs as a dual purpose comfortable, quiet, smooth family car with a cabin that more than rivals my previous Audi and BMW company cars which can transform into a genuine hot hatch. If I just wanted a performance car I would probably go for something a bit more overt - a two-seater or coupe most likely, maybe an RS? Whereas the RS will be bought IMHO primarily as a performance car which just happens to have some decent rear passenger space and boot but who really cares, it is an RS.
  10. The former yes, the latter seems pointless but maybe that is just me, the "winner" is just who backs off last and in these cars accelerating to license losing speeds in a "duel" is just a few seconds. Maybe I am just getting old!
  11. Yeh, ECO feels a bit like it has turned your R into a 1.4 because the throttle response is so dull but flooring it will still give it everything, no need to fiddle with the driver profile menu, just try to push the throttle through the bulkhead!
  12. Another ex Alfa owner here, having owned a 33 1.7IE, GTV 2.0TS, 156 v6 2.5 and the wife had a 147 2.0TS. Still love the older Alfas but they really seem to have lost their way for the last decade or so. We keep hearing of a revival and new models but have yet to materialise. The Giulia was originally planned for release in 2011. Changes in management drastically revised the plans and maybe 2015 or 2016 but it could all change again. Not wishing to speak ill of the dead but the appointment of ex BMW Karl Heinz Kalbfell as CEO led to Alfa trying to out German the Germans which with the best will in the world was never going to be Alfa's strength and having their own unique identity is for me their biggest draw. On taking the position Kalfbell said: "You can't find financially minded people in this company," he says. "It's full of engineers who all want to launch new cars and don't want to deal with the boring bits in between." Personally I loved the fact the company was inspired by people who loved cars rather than bean counters. Alfas were the kind of cars that you could forgive the odd issue or deficit to other marques. Things I simply won't accept with the Audi, BMW & VW I have had since my Alfas. In the decade that followed the demise of Alfa Romeo sports saloons has been sad to see and I really hope that turns around.
  13. Yes you need to know what you are doing so as not to be a menace on the roads but sports cars, fast saloons, homologation specials etc. are all about making the driver feel good on public roads, it is pure fantasy. Close your favourite B road and make it a rally stage with an experienced race/rally driver on board your car and the speeds will be very significantly faster. As n4aat says, commitment is a much bigger factor than car performance and it has been for a very long time IMHO. Right back to hot hatches and sports saloons in the late seventies.
  14. TonyR

    DSG

    I see, I presume the throttle blip is enough to prepare the box for kickdown and select the lower gear as staying on a light throttle the box will be prepared to change up. Can't say I have ever tried to change to first whilst maintaining speed, under braking it is fine (rev matches and changes quickly). The only time I have ever encountered delays on downshifts are manually overriding when in D and want to downshift whilst not slowing down, I guess a blip here could speed up the process, I'll give it a go!
  15. TonyR

    DSG

    Still not getting this, if you are still slowing down and require another downshift a tug on the left paddle will perform a rev matched fast shift. Accelerating briefly (remember you can't rev without accelerating in a DSG) will tell the box to preselect the next higher gear which is not what you want. Unless I am missing something (and I have had a previous DSG for four years) it really is incredibly simple. Slow down and changing down will give the fastest rev matched downshifts, accelerating full throttle the fastest upshifts.
  16. IMHO the Golf R is the perfect car to have a mid life crisis and keep it quiet Having owned a couple of Sunbeam Ti in my youth when they were current I fancied a modern day hot hatch in my fifties. The R pulls it off without it looking like I am trying desperately to recapture said youth. The only potential issue I can see is that it may almost be too accomplished at the whole dual personality thing. It really can behave like a "normal" Golf which is great. The Sunbeam was a lot more raw with its twin Weber 40s, lumpy idle, 19mpg and less drivable at low revs. All for a puny (by today's standards) 100bhp! The fact the R is pushing 300bhp yet still incredibly good at being smooth and docile is a testament to the engineers. Yet the Sunbeam was a constant reminder you were in a homologation special car (even if it got trounced by the pesky new generation of FWD hot hatches). The R responds to how you want to drive, racey or docile so there isn't that constant reminder you are in a car with the same power as a WRC rally car and this may disappoint some who are thinking it is an uncompromising special. Something like an Impreza with a big exhaust was never going to be agreeable to Mrs R and the mid life crisis jibes would be unbearable so the R does the job perfectly!
  17. TonyR

    DSG

    The only times I have encountered scenario 3 is when trundling along at low rpm and deciding I need to change down for a hill or to pass. In spirited driving I am changing down in braking zones, changing up whilst accelerating. I guess a corner may be tighter than expected and more speed is lost requiring another downshift but that wouldn't be the norm that you are changing down on throttle.
  18. The current 1 series is getting FWD in the 2 series active tourer but the next generation Mk 3 will be FWD and 4WD I believe
  19. It is confirmed as FWD sharing the Mini platform. I thought long and hard about a M135i as a bit of a last chance of six cylinder RWD hot hatch, eventually the Golf R beat it on practicality and I felt the interior looked a bit more like a top of the range car than the BMW. It was very close though and I would have been happy with either.
  20. TonyR

    DSG

    Kickdown is an exception as it will select the optimum gear for performance and may skip gears to achieve. Even in manual mode if you are pootling around in 5th at 40 mph and floor the throttle past the soft stop it will kickdown several gears.
  21. TonyR

    DSG

    This might help explain it (source: http://www.vw.ca/en/shopping_tools/innovation/powertrain/dsg/gear_changes.html ) The principle behind overlapping gear changes in the DSG is that when one gear is engaged, another gear is always preselected. If a gear change is about to occur, one clutch opens within three to four hundredths of a second while the other closes. The mechatronics unit ensures that this takes place quickly and accurately in a way that would not be possible manually. As such, the change of gear is imperceptible to the driver and is achieved without any interruption of driving power. The decision as to which gear should be engaged next is taken by the control unit based on the position/operation of the accelerator, engine speed and vehicle speed. If the accelerator pedal is pressed and the vehicle speeds up, the next-highest gear will be preselected before the shift point is reached. If the accelerator is not operated, however, i.e. the vehicle is in overrun, the next-lowest gear will be preselected.
×
×
  • Create New...