Jump to content

Help me decide...


Kram67

Recommended Posts

Mark, you seem from '67 and I am from '59. ;) The older I get the more I tend to smaller cars which bring me fun, sheer power and luxury. My current 130i manual with AFS is an awesome car but I did not want to wait another year or more for the next release. I had a small peek at the Audi S3 but its current version is just not state of art anymore. Than I came at the VW DSG. (BMW only has their DCT for a few cars available)

 

Try the GTI or R, get DSG (if you prefer that) leather and other options which suit you. success !! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Mark, you seem from '67 and I am from '59. ;) The older I get the more I tend to smaller cars which bring me fun, sheer power and luxury. My current 130i manual with AFS is an awesome car but I did not want to wait another year or more for the next release. I had a small peek at the Audi S3 but its current version is just not state of art anymore. Than I came at the VW DSG. (BMW only has their DCT for a few cars available)

 

Try the GTI or R, get DSG (if you prefer that) leather and other options which suit you. success !! :)

 

I had a great offer on a 135i yesterday - good trade in on mine and they will deliver and collect my car with no hassle - very tempting.  Until that it is, I read the real-world MPG people are getting!!! So that is now discounted.

 

The GTI is of no interest - the Golf R it has to be!

 

There is a good spec R for £30k, but they will not move on price and they are not interested in my car -making it very hard to do a deal!!!!

 

I think I will just sit tight.... maybe they will be a little keener to do a deal the closer to the end of year we get?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

End of year makes no difference really, end of month is the time.................. leave it a few days before the end of the month and then give them a ring. Targets on month by month basis thats if its not sold before then............... gamble you've got to take. But then your car isn't getting to them till the end of the month so will have a book drop straight away probably so will offer you less..............

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I had a great offer on a 135i yesterday - good trade in on mine and they will deliver and collect my car with no hassle - very tempting.  Until that it is, I read the real-world MPG people are getting!!! So that is now discounted.

 

The GTI is of no interest - the Golf R it has to be!

 

There is a good spec R for £30k, but they will not move on price and they are not interested in my car -making it very hard to do a deal!!!!

 

I think I will just sit tight.... maybe they will be a little keener to do a deal the closer to the end of year we get?

 

on the 135i: agree here with Soulboy who says "I must admit to being very tempted by a 135, but two things just made my mind up. Firstly, I know every time I would look at the 135, I would have thought, you are a great car, but you're not the prettiest thing ?

 

why not waiting for the new 1M next year in spring ? Only disadvantage it still looks like a 135i  :D

 

I was also convinced I could do the best deal with my BMW dealer but I was wrong. never thought the VW dealer would return more money for both our Bimmers (MY 2006 130i and MY 2006 325iT)  >:(

 

Have you already driven the R ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I had a great offer on a 135i yesterday - good trade in on mine and they will deliver and collect my car with no hassle - very tempting.  Until that it is, I read the real-world MPG people are getting!!! So that is now discounted.

 

The GTI is of no interest - the Golf R it has to be!

 

There is a good spec R for £30k, but they will not move on price and they are not interested in my car -making it very hard to do a deal!!!!

 

I think I will just sit tight.... maybe they will be a little keener to do a deal the closer to the end of year we get?

 

on the 135i: agree here with Soulboy who says "I must admit to being very tempted by a 135, but two things just made my mind up. Firstly, I know every time I would look at the 135, I would have thought, you are a great car, but you're not the prettiest thing ?

 

why not waiting for the new 1M next year in spring ? Only disadvantage it still looks like a 135i  :D

 

I was also convinced I could do the best deal with my BMW dealer but I was wrong. never thought the VW dealer would return more money for both our Bimmers (MY 2006 130i and MY 2006 325iT)  >:(

 

Have you already driven the R ?

 

..each to their own. I really like the look of the 1 series coupe.  I hate the look of the 3 and 5 door version though!

 

Yes I have driven one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well Kram, I'm jumping in the topic a bit late but I find the debate interesting. One thing hasn't really been mentionned and it's "exclusivity"

 

IMHO BMW 1XXi or Xi or 3 series are note really noticeable. I have my R since June and each and eveytime I get in front of it I simply LOVE the look of it. The DRL's makes it as well really beautifull on the road.

 

At the end of the day I believe that if you are looking for an all-rounder that can thrill you on a blast, or bring you comfortably from a place to another it's really the right car.

 

I've driven 2'600 km (1'600 miles) last week between Tuesday and Saturday and I was more than happy to have that R.

 

Honestly ACC brings you that 10% extra comfort that makes things easier on long trips, but standard is ok. And the Sport mode is usable while blasting but the road must be smooth or you'll brake your back.

 

Anyway go for the R, it's something special and I'm sure it's among the best car ever produced by VW  8)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would argue that the Golf R is even less noticeable, especially over a GTI!  The average person would not know the difference between the R and standard Golf, of which there a lot on our roads. Thankfully my preference is a "Q-car" and the Golf R fits the bill.

 

If I wanted a “hot hatch†with limited build run and more stand out, then maybe a Focus RS is the right car - not for me though. :-&

 

ACC sounds good but is not on my "must have" list - if the car has it on, then great,  but I will not pay extra for it.

 

I appreciate this a "Golf R" Forum and therefore the view will be slightly biased, and it may be the best car that VW have ever produced, but there are other manufacturers! ;)

 

I am not knocking the car, quite the contrary, I think it is great little car and will hopefully buy one, provided I can get the right deal. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

on the 135i: agree here with Soulboy who says "I must admit to being very tempted by a 135, but two things just made my mind up. Firstly, I know every time I would look at the 135, I would have thought, you are a great car, but you're not the prettiest thing ?

 

why not waiting for the new 1M next year in spring ? Only disadvantage it still looks like a 135i  :D

 

and you genuinely believe the Golf R looks better than this?

 

bmw_1m_coupe_by_jonsibal-d2yrcdj.jpg

 

bmw_1m_coupe_rear_quarter_view_by_jonsibal-d309hsk.jpg

 

Okay so it's a mock up, but if it looks remotely like that it will be very desirable...IMHO!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure you got a point, the R is a "Q-car" and it's part of why we like it.

 

Honestly I won't really be at ease in this BMW, ok it sticks out but unlike M3 or M5 it hasn't got the "imperial" feel, looks more like cheap tunning  :-X

 

And of course we are biaised !! However the 4 wheel drive gives you ultimate grip on greazy roads, and I'm sure you have some at least 6 month a year !! The BMW is only propulsion... (I personaly love the AWD)

 

And it's only 2 doors (okay not an issue for you...)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a wanna be!!!

 

Its like a young boy trying to be like his elder brother.

 

Doesn't work for me. It still looks pig ugly underneath all that Halfords frippery.

 

It says "GOD, I REALLY WANT A FAST BMW, BUT I COULD ONLY AFFORD THIS FISHER PRICE VERSION"

 

I think i've made my point. A bit harsh perhaps...bet hey ho  :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a wanna be!!!

 

Its like a young boy trying to be like his elder brother.

 

Doesn't work for me. It still looks pig ugly underneath all that Halfords frippery.

 

It says "GOD, I REALLY WANT A FAST BMW, BUT I COULD ONLY AFFORD THIS FISHER PRICE VERSION"

 

I think i've made my point. A bit harsh perhaps...bet hey ho  :D

:D hey boy racer!! You've said it, but it still knows how to kick your a$$ you on red light grand prix...  >:-D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a wanna be!!!

 

Its like a young boy trying to be like his elder brother.

 

Doesn't work for me. It still looks pig ugly underneath all that Halfords frippery.

 

It says "GOD, I REALLY WANT A FAST BMW, BUT I COULD ONLY AFFORD THIS FISHER PRICE VERSION"

 

I think i've made my point. A bit harsh perhaps...bet hey ho  :D

 

Take the above pics with a pinch of salt - they are rendered, so it is almost certain that the car will not look like that.  BMW don't as a rule produce "halfords specials"  ;)

 

So by your analogy M3 owners should aspire to own an M5 or M6?  Basically if any car has a “bigger†or “faster†brother than that is what you should aspire to?   So do you have to be top of the food chain in the manufacturer you can afford – is that why you bought a Golf R?

 

The 135i is a great driver's car that has the best 6 cylinder engine in production today.  You don't really want to compare the performance of the Golf R to a 135i or M1 do you... you would look very silly!

 

 

RWD is so much better and more fun to drive than FWD or RWD... You should try it!  Your little incident the other day with the rear stepping out while "turning and accelerating"  (LOL) that put a smile on your face can be achieved far easier and more controllable in a RWD car... only takes a bit of tuition. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok where do i start...

 

"So do you have to be top of the food chain in the manufacturer you can afford – is that why you bought a Golf R?" Yes, I think that's what I'm saying. Its just a "thing" i have

 

The M3 is the top of its tree. The M5 is a much bigger beast, and i would say quite different. Its kind of a German Ferrari with 4 doors. Same with M6. I think the M1 is a wanna be M3. I stand by that.  :)

 

"You don't really want to compare the performance of the Golf R to a 135i or M1 do you... you would look very silly!" I'm used to looking silly, but you're probably right  8-|

 

"RWD is so much better and more fun to drive than FWD or RWD... You should try it!  Your little incident the other day with the rear stepping out while "turning and accelerating"  (LOL) that put a smile on your face can be achieved far easier and more controllable in a RWD car... only takes a bit of tuition." I must have a go some day.....

 

About it being more fun to drive than 4WD, I dont know about that!! I think the thrill of going round a corner like you're on rails, and feeling your face being removed on one side, is a thrill I first experienced on a Lancia Delta Integrale, and I love in this new R. Albeit after a bit of larking about the Lancia would come to a set of traffic lights and break down (no joke)  :-[

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a wanna be!!!

 

Its like a young boy trying to be like his elder brother.

 

Doesn't work for me. It still looks pig ugly underneath all that Halfords frippery.

 

It says "GOD, I REALLY WANT A FAST BMW, BUT I COULD ONLY AFFORD THIS FISHER PRICE VERSION"

 

I think i've made my point. A bit harsh perhaps...bet hey ho  :D

:D hey boy racer!! You've said it, but it still knows how to kick your a$$ you on red light grand prix...  >:-D

 

 

What, exactly are you saying!!!??!!!  ;D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So by your analogy M3 owners should aspire to own an M5 or M6?  Basically if any car has a “bigger†or “faster†brother than that is what you should aspire to?   So do you have to be top of the food chain in the manufacturer you can afford – is that why you bought a Golf R?

 

In a way, yes and no... It's like the Porsche dilemma, if you own a Boxster, even if it is a great car, it is an advertisement that you can't own a 911...?

 

The M3 vs. M5 / M6 doesn't fit, in my opinion, the same dilemma but for the GTI vs. the R, yes.

 

The 135i is a great driver's car that has the best 6 cylinder engine in production today.  You don't really want to compare the performance of the Golf R to a 135i or M1 do you... you would look very silly!

 

I already tried and lost to a 135i.... Great car, but not my cup of tea for 2 reasons. Switzerland has snow. Lots of it. My old car, a 350Z was a BILLION times better than my R in my opinion, but the R is a car with a dual personality. Comfy and fast. Its the jack of all trades!

 

RWD is so much better and more fun to drive than FWD or RWD... You should try it!  Your little incident the other day with the rear stepping out while "turning and accelerating"  (LOL) that put a smile on your face can be achieved far easier and more controllable in a RWD car... only takes a bit of tuition. ;)

 

RWD is awesome except in snow. 300 BHP + fat 275 rear tires = my death last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...