Jump to content

Help me decide...


Kram67

Recommended Posts

I am looking a replacing my BMW 123d as it is coming up for 3 years old - great car with 200bhp that returns 40mpg all day long - however, been there done that...

 

So I am considering a Golf R - looks like a good car, if a bit too expensive!  :o 

 

Use: daily workhorse, back and forth to work with a bit of fun thrown in.

 

Positives:

Reasonable performance

4wd

low emissions - sensible tax

reasonable MPG - late 20's...?  Most of my mileage is up and down the M4

Build Quality

 

Negatives:

30k+ for a Golf!!!

 

So the spec - must have:

 

Leather,

DSG

Heated seats

 

Nice to have:

Sat Nav

 

Not sure about:

18" or 19" wheels - I don't really care about aesthetics - what is the ride like?

ACC - does it really make that much difference?

 

I really like the Grey, however the only one I can find at the price point I am willing to pay is the Blue - looks nice, although I haven't seen one in the flesh and is similar to my 123d...

 

I am also considering a remap - anyone used Bluefin?  Seems very reasonably priced for the gains.

 

However I am also looking at:

 

Scirocco R

Megane 250 - bloody good value (relatively)

BMW 135i

 

or sod it and put another 20k miles on mine.

 

So what am I after?  Advice from people who have been in a similar position. I just can't seem to make up my mind - is the golf really worth the extra...?

 

Thanks, Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hi Mark

 

agree that it sounds confusing, i am not based in UK so i cannot comment on price/tax/emissions. but generally, 123d is not comparable to the golf R. i say it is more comparable to GTI/GTD which have similar build quality of the R but slightly less performance. and if you are going to use the car for mainly driving back and forth from work with a bit of fun then the GTI/GTD will do it perfectly. there is no much difference in perforamcne betwen the GTI/GTD and 123d. but if you looking for performance upgrade then the R is your choice.

 

mentioning 135i, that is a serious performance upgrade even compared the R and more expensive too.

 

finally, i always advise you to do a test drive before final decision.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark

 

agree that it sounds confusing, i am not based in UK so i cannot comment on price/tax/emissions. but generally, 123d is not comparable to the golf R. i say it is more comparable to GTI/GTD which have similar build quality of the R but slightly less performance. and if you are going to use the car for mainly driving back and forth from work with a bit of fun then the GTI/GTD will do it perfectly. there is no much difference in performance between the GTI/GTD and 123d. but if you looking for performance upgrade then the R is your choice.

 

I am not sure I agree with you there - the 123d really is a cracking engine with a great chassis.

 

mentioning 135i, that is a serious performance upgrade even compared the R and more expensive too.

 

finally, i always advise you to do a test drive before final decision.

 

 

The 135i is tempting!

 

What about the Megane 250?  - http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/ ... ?logcode=p

 

A lot of car (relatively) for the money

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My advice to you is to forget the badge and the price and drive the car - then you'll know whether it's worth it for you. Remember it is predominantly a front wheel drive car so will not steer or handle in the same way as a BMW, although with the right technique it will corner just as (or more) quickly.

 

Now it's begun to loosen up I'm getting 35mpg on a regular motorway cruise with a light foot but overall around 30mpg. The ride with 19's and ACC is firm but never what I'd call uncomfortable.

 

There are lots of nice cars you can get for the price of an R but none which are as quick and as good all-round as the R.

 

Don't even bother with the Renault  :-X

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My advice to you is to forget the badge and the price and drive the car - then you'll know whether it's worth it for you. Remember it is predominantly a front wheel drive car so will not steer or handle in the same way as a BMW, although with the right technique it will corner just as (or more) quickly.

 

I have had a few VW's over the years - Golf VR6, Corrado VR6 Storm, Golf MK (3?) GTI 16v...

 

So the way they drive is fine - I test drove a Golf R on Monday and it was very nice.

 

Now it's begun to loosen up I'm getting 35mpg on a regular motorway cruise with a light foot but overall around 30mpg. The ride with 19's and ACC is firm but never what I'd call uncomfortable.

 

There are lots of nice cars you can get for the price of an R but none which are as quick and as good all-round as the R.

 

30mpg - that's very good - I would be very happy with that.

 

Don't even bother with the Renault  :-X

 

Why...?  To be honest I am not sure I could bring myself to buy one, although it does get very good reviews and it just seems very good value for many.

 

I can't remember the last time I bought anything other than a German car!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could go for the Renault. Very quick and quite well reviewed, but then you'd own a Renault  ;D

 

Test drive will be the only sensible way to make a decision. Wasn't an option for me, as i ordered before any demos were in the UK.

 

I love it mate. The other car i would have considered would have been the RS4, second hand....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could go for the Renault. Very quick and quite well reviewed, but then you'd own a Renault  ;D

 

Test drive will be the only sensible way to make a decision. Wasn't an option for me, as i ordered before any demos were in the UK.

 

I love it mate. The other car i would have considered would have been the RS4, second hand....

 

An RS4.... that has crossed my mind!  Also another option is an E90 M3 and it is a perfect everyday car - they are down at the 30k mark!  Unfortunately they are expensive to run if you are doing mileage - I have had an E46 M3 and CSL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could go for the Renault. Very quick and quite well reviewed, but then you'd own a Renault  ;D

 

Test drive will be the only sensible way to make a decision. Wasn't an option for me, as i ordered before any demos were in the UK.

 

I love it mate. The other car i would have considered would have been the RS4, second hand....

 

An RS4.... that has crossed my mind!  Also another option is an E90 M3 and it is a perfect everyday car - they are down at the 30k mark!  Unfortunately they are expensive to run if you are doing mileage - I have had an E46 M3 and CSL.

 

 

 

Despite what Clarkson says, i think the RS4 is a little less tosserish than an M3, as capable as it is!! I would have gone for the black one as it really suits the car, and boy what a nice growl that V8 makes!!! It's like a bat out of Hades

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could go for the Renault. Very quick and quite well reviewed, but then you'd own a Renault  ;D

 

Test drive will be the only sensible way to make a decision. Wasn't an option for me, as i ordered before any demos were in the UK.

 

I love it mate. The other car i would have considered would have been the RS4, second hand....

 

An RS4.... that has crossed my mind!  Also another option is an E90 M3 and it is a perfect everyday car - they are down at the 30k mark!  Unfortunately they are expensive to run if you are doing mileage - I have had an E46 M3 and CSL.

 

 

 

Despite what Clarkson says, i think the RS4 is a little less tosserish than an M3, as capable as it is!! I would have gone for the black one as it really suits the car, and boy what a nice growl that V8 makes!!! It's like a bat out of Hades

 

"Tosserish"  :o

 

You and I clearly have differing views on the M3!  I agree the older models are often the chariot of choice for the Burberry cap brigade; however the current M3 is lovely.  Also, without any doubt the best colour is white by a country mile!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not sure I agree with you there - the 123d really is a cracking engine with a great chassis.

 

 

I agree it should be very good car. but from numbers, 270 bhp in Golf R is much bigger figure compared to the 200 bhp of the 123d. GTI is 210 bhp which makes it more in the same bracket.

 

and please dont ask me about any french car... :D :-X :-[

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...