Jump to content

Help me decide...


Kram67

Recommended Posts

I am not sure I agree with you there - the 123d really is a cracking engine with a great chassis.

 

 

I agree it should be very good car. but from numbers, 270 bhp in Golf R is much bigger figure compared to the 200 bhp of the 123d. GTI is 210 bhp which makes it more in the same bracket.

 

and please dont ask me about any french car... :D :-X :-[

 

Agree it is no comparison to the Golf R.  I thought you were stating that it is similar to the GTD.  Re-read your post!  :)

 

Why does everyone hate the Renault?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

LoL .. my wife has a new Renault Megane (a cheap 1.6 litre Petrol)  :P  8-|

 

Have to say I quite like it ... nothings gone wrong with it, it feels solid with no rattles (although not as good a quality as the Golf).....reasonably nice to drive too (comfortable with good handling).  :D 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could go for the Renault. Very quick and quite well reviewed, but then you'd own a Renault  ;D

 

Test drive will be the only sensible way to make a decision. Wasn't an option for me, as i ordered before any demos were in the UK.

 

I love it mate. The other car i would have considered would have been the RS4, second hand....

 

An RS4.... that has crossed my mind!  Also another option is an E90 M3 and it is a perfect everyday car - they are down at the 30k mark!  Unfortunately they are expensive to run if you are doing mileage - I have had an E46 M3 and CSL.

 

 

 

Despite what Clarkson says, i think the RS4 is a little less tosserish than an M3, as capable as it is!! I would have gone for the black one as it really suits the car, and boy what a nice growl that V8 makes!!! It's like a bat out of Hades

 

"Tosserish"  :o

 

You and I clearly have differing views on the M3!  I agree the older models are often the chariot of choice for the Burberry cap brigade; however the current M3 is lovely.  Also, without any doubt the best colour is white by a country mile!

 

 

Yeah i agree actually the new one is a great car. White ones look good too. Black for the RS4 though :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just bought my Golf R last month, after a similar predicament.

My short list was Golf R, Cayman, BMW 135, another S3.

 

I must admit to being very tempted by a 135, but two things just made my mind up.

Firstly, I know every time I would look at the 135, I would have thought, you are a great car, but you're not the prettiest thing. :o

 

Second, I have driven 4wd for the last 10 years now. I dont like to think of 300hp through the rear wheels. I would have ended up stuffing it into a tree. Not too mention I live on a hill, and very few cars were moving last January. The S3 just drove like the snow wasn't there.

 

The Porsche was impractical (as the g/f has got a TT).

 

So I went for the Golf (having owned both R32's previously) and have been enormously impressed. Its everything I want from a car.

 

To be honest, I wouldn't have considered the French option. I normally find Golfs age really well. They are not too radical at first, but they mature like good wine

Flashier choices (Astra VRX, Civic Type R etc) look great at first. Then start looking a bit 'snidey' when they have been around a while.

 

However, the Golf is very expensive for what it is. But it should help keep them rare and thus improve residuals. So you should get the exra cost back.

 

Just my opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for your post Soulboy - I think the Golf R really suits my needs.  Just need to find the right one at the right price.

 

How important is ACC - does it really make that much difference? Or am I suffering from tick box syndrome!

 

I can't see any cars under £33k with it on - which is way more than I want to spend.

 

As I am in business start-up mode I have to stick to a tight budget - first time in many years!   :'(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark

 

I dont have ACC and I am more than happy with the car...........in fact it never even crosses my mind.

 

In fact the only options I would pick would be colour / parking sensors / folding mirrors / 19 inch wheels / Hi-fi upgrade.

 

The other big cost options hold no interest for me:

 

I really like the standard seats, and not being leather they dont really need to be heated. I have had leather in my last few cars and I would suggest you dont discount the standard seats till you have tried them.

Each to there own on this one, but having had VW leather in the past......it is once bitten twice shy.

 

I despised DSG on a previous mk5 R32 and was glad to get back into a manual when it got stolen. I disliked the lack of control compared to a manual.

e.g. Approaching a roundabout in 6th, and a quick flick down into 2nd. Easy in a manual, not so easy in DSG even in manual mode.

 

IMHO 95% of the car is there in standard form and I would never spend a fortune on options, to get another 5%............unless it only cost an extra 5%.

 

I dont think forums help in this respect, as everyone looks what other people have and think 'ooh, am I missing out if I dont get that'.

 

And as for performance upgrades. If I want a faster car, I would buy something faster in standard form (M3 or whatever).

 

I got a good deal on mine in the end. Just keep your eyes peeled and the right car at the right price will come along.

Mine had 25 miles on the clock as a few weeks old demonstrator and I got 15% off list and a great deal on my p/x.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMHO 95% of the car is there in standard form

 

Agree with this. The only things I think are absolutely necessary are the 19's and an RCD510, and those are essentially cosmetic.

 

It's difficult to explain, but in some ways I think the standard suspension would be better than the ACC on my car, as it's not dependent on a computer messing around with things and (inevitably) getting it wrong sometimes. Having said that it does make a difference but unless you are going to be driving two R's, with and without ACC you'll not be aware of it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark

 

I dont have ACC and I am more than happy with the car...........in fact it never even crosses my mind.

 

In fact the only options I would pick would be colour / parking sensors / folding mirrors / 19 inch wheels / Hi-fi upgrade.

 

The other big cost options hold no interest for me:

 

I really like the standard seats, and not being leather they dont really need to be heated. I have had leather in my last few cars and I would suggest you dont discount the standard seats till you have tried them.

Each to there own on this one, but having had VW leather in the past......it is once bitten twice shy.

 

I despised DSG on a previous mk5 R32 and was glad to get back into a manual when it got stolen. I disliked the lack of control compared to a manual.

e.g. Approaching a roundabout in 6th, and a quick flick down into 2nd. Easy in a manual, not so easy in DSG even in manual mode.

 

IMHO 95% of the car is there in standard form and I would never spend a fortune on options, to get another 5%............unless it only cost an extra 5%.

 

I dont think forums help in this respect, as everyone looks what other people have and think 'ooh, am I missing out if I dont get that'.

 

And as for performance upgrades. If I want a faster car, I would buy something faster in standard form (M3 or whatever).

 

I got a good deal on mine in the end. Just keep your eyes peeled and the right car at the right price will come along.

Mine had 25 miles on the clock as a few weeks old demonstrator and I got 15% off list and a great deal on my p/x.

 

 

Thanks again for your post.  

 

I certainly agree that people get very carried away when specc'ing cars and are heavily influenced by forums such as this one - something that I have been very guilty of in the past.  

 

For me the more I read and based on my own test drive the base spec:

 

Leather

19" wheels

DSG - I really like the DSG.  My CSL had SMG and I loved it - you just have to adjust your driving style.

Parking Sensors

Decent Audio

 

Agree with performance, however for a few hundred pounds bluefin or DMS does look very tempting.  I had a DMS map on a 535d - transformed the car, and would absolutely do it again.

 

Although I am a little worried that I will get bored of it - too anodyne, which is why I was/am considering the 135i.  I remember after I had my CSL for a while I tried a 996 Turbo and, to me, it was dull.  Very fast, but dull nevertheless.  I took the sales guy out in the CSL as they were fairly new and he loved it!  Every time i got in it I had a huge smile - different car I know.

 

Also, I am not sure I understand all this concern over rear wheel drive cars - almost all of my cars have been rwd, some with silly bhp/ton - just makes it more fun.  Although I agree re the snow - the 1 series was the worst car I have ever driven in the snow - I couldn't get the car off the drive!

 

I digress, back to the Golf R - I have spoken to a couple of dealers that have them for sale and they are very reluctant to do a deal, even though it is the end of the month - good news for owners I guess!!

 

Again thanks to all for the input much appreciated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I dont see what the fuss about ACC is. Had the Mag Ride on my old TTS, hardly used it and it wasnt stunning. Maybe if it was free on the R I wouldnt mind, but I wouldnt pay for it and it certainly adds very little come resale.

 

If I was specing an R again, Leather is top of the list - sorry but on a +30k car it doesnt stack up with cloth and alcantara -you can see cars without leather seem to struggle to sell.

DSG is a must as is RCD510 and 19". Parking sensors nice.

 

Is the R a car that you will get bored in - very possibly. I still struggle to get excited about a drive in the R and have never just taken it out for a blast. Mine would of been/was sold the other month until I discovered the business finance settlement was a touch high :o Now sorted.

 

I am now looking to inject some excitment into my car life. Went out yesterday testing Porsche's - Cayman S and Gen 2 911 Carrera. Had the std 2.9 PDK Cayman before the R. Had expected to go out and be blown away. Strangely enough I wasnt. Both cars were manuals which might not of helped, but the Cayman didnt feel stunningly fast. The 911 a little little bit quicker, but didnt seem to have as much character as the Cayman. I got back into my Golf and I guess I could see how capable it is in comparision taking the money you are paying into consideration. Plan might still be to get a Boxster Spyder and a daily runaround. Will also look at the TTRS and a wildcard the C63 AMG - great deals to be had. Finally I could just remap and add a Milltek to the R - cheapest option, but not sure it will deliver the character I'm after.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I dont see what the fuss about ACC is. Had the Mag Ride on my old TTS, hardly used it and it wasnt stunning. Maybe if it was free on the R I wouldnt mind, but I wouldnt pay for it and it certainly adds very little come resale.

 

If I was specing an R again, Leather is top of the list - sorry but on a +30k car it doesnt stack up with cloth and alcantara -you can see cars without leather seem to struggle to sell.

DSG is a must as is RCD510 and 19". Parking sensors nice.

 

Is the R a car that you will get bored in - very possibly. I still struggle to get excited about a drive in the R and have never just taken it out for a blast. Mine would of been/was sold the other month until I discovered the business finance settlement was a touch high :o Now sorted.

 

I am now looking to inject some excitment into my car life. Went out yesterday testing Porsche's - Cayman S and Gen 2 911 Carrera. Had the std 2.9 PDK Cayman before the R. Had expected to go out and be blown away. Strangely enough I wasnt. Both cars were manuals which might not of helped, but the Cayman didnt feel stunningly fast. The 911 a little little bit quicker, but didnt seem to have as much character as the Cayman. I got back into my Golf and I guess I could see how capable it is in comparision taking the money you are paying into consideration. Plan might still be to get a Boxster Spyder and a daily runaround. Will also look at the TTRS and a wildcard the C63 AMG - great deals to be had. Finally I could just remap and add a Milltek to the R - cheapest option, but not sure it will deliver the character I'm after.

 

Chins, i fully agree about the options, in UAE where i live the R comes fully specced in STD form. i only added 19" wheels and sat nav and paid less than 300pounds for both which is a good deal otherwise i would have been very careful with options ???.

 

and i am happy that after dring couple of porsches you see the value of the R. now i am more confident with the car and i think based on my car background i will be satisfied. i havent yet owned any porsche, M3 or AMG  ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I dont see what the fuss about ACC is. Had the Mag Ride on my old TTS, hardly used it and it wasnt stunning. Maybe if it was free on the R I wouldnt mind, but I wouldnt pay for it and it certainly adds very little come resale.

 

If I was specing an R again, Leather is top of the list - sorry but on a +30k car it doesnt stack up with cloth and alcantara -you can see cars without leather seem to struggle to sell.

DSG is a must as is RCD510 and 19". Parking sensors nice.

 

Is the R a car that you will get bored in - very possibly. I still struggle to get excited about a drive in the R and have never just taken it out for a blast. Mine would of been/was sold the other month until I discovered the business finance settlement was a touch high :o Now sorted.

 

I am now looking to inject some excitment into my car life. Went out yesterday testing Porsche's - Cayman S and Gen 2 911 Carrera. Had the std 2.9 PDK Cayman before the R. Had expected to go out and be blown away. Strangely enough I wasnt. Both cars were manuals which might not of helped, but the Cayman didnt feel stunningly fast. The 911 a little little bit quicker, but didnt seem to have as much character as the Cayman. I got back into my Golf and I guess I could see how capable it is in comparision taking the money you are paying into consideration. Plan might still be to get a Boxster Spyder and a daily runaround. Will also look at the TTRS and a wildcard the C63 AMG - great deals to be had. Finally I could just remap and add a Milltek to the R - cheapest option, but not sure it will deliver the character I'm after.

 

I think if I have remap done then it will tick most of the boxes - the car will never set the world on fire, but it will be a good everyday car.

 

You mention putting milltek exhaust on... for what reason?  The performance gains will be marginal and not noticeable.  If it is for noise - one fundamental problem, you are starting with a four cylinder engine - no matter what you do it will never sound great.

 

It has been a long time since I have had a car that I felt excited enough to go out just for a drive.  But to be fair that is mainly due to having a 3rd car for track day's and weekend blasts.  Also doing reasonable mileage for work, means there is no desire to go for a blast in a car you spend all week in.  I had a 911 for everyday and I started to resent using the car because of the mileage I was doing, the poor fuel economy and the amount of time I spent at the petrol station and ultimately the amount of money it was costing me.  That initial excitement of a new car soon wears off.

 

Also, what defines "character" in a car - for me that would need to be a car that is raw, it's fast, it's noisy - your senses are in overdrive. I couldn't live with a car like that every day.  Most modern cars are too sanitised, because that is what the market demands. 

 

If you can afford it, keep the Golf R or downgrade to something for everyday and then buy something special for the garage!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a Subaru P1 when they first came out and in the days before Chavs could afford them. It's still my benchmark. Had 30+ cars since then and none have delivered the same ownership experience. Tried lots more expensive and lots cheaper to no avail :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark, after several Bimmers from 528iT, 540iT, X5 4.4i, 545iT and now a 130i with AFS (my favorite Bimmer so far  :)

 

I ordered a R DSG about a month ago with delivery 1/2011. Why: after 4,5 years I wanted something new and BMW will release the new 1 series end of next year and a new 3-series only in 2012. Audi's A3 will have a facelift and of 2011 as well. :( The current 135i is no option as I want a 5 doors car.

 

The R has much more space in the back than the 1-series and I would say the quality is in pair with BMW's. (at least with my 130i) Sure BMW gives the status but that is not of my interest.

 

If you have problems with paying 30K for a Golf, I think that all has to do with the perception of the brand and its value. Yes it is a lot of money but can you imagine that the VW dealer actually gave me more money in return than my BMW dealer. I am still pissed.

 

Chosen a car is a very personal decision. Take the car for a test drive and see if it fits. Alternatively think of a GTI. (still my reference hot hatch). The R is a different league, but testdriving really gave me a very big smile  ;D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a Subaru P1 when they first came out and in the days before Chavs could afford them. It's still my benchmark. Had 30+ cars since then and none have delivered the same ownership experience. Tried lots more expensive and lots cheaper to no avail :)

 

Maybe a Nissan GTR would fit the bill...?! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark, after several Bimmers from 528iT, 540iT, X5 4.4i, 545iT and now a 130i with AFS (my favorite Bimmer so far  :)

 

I ordered a R DSG about a month ago with delivery 1/2011. Why: after 4,5 years I wanted something new and BMW will release the new 1 series end of next year and a new 3-series only in 2012. Audi's A3 will have a facelift and of 2011 as well. :( The current 135i is no option as I want a 5 doors car.

 

The R has much more space in the back than the 1-series and I would say the quality is in pair with BMW's. (at least with my 130i) Sure BMW gives the status but that is not of my interest.

 

If you have problems with paying 30K for a Golf, I think that all has to do with the perception of the brand and its value. Yes it is a lot of money but can you imagine that the VW dealer actually gave me more money in return than my BMW dealer. I am still pissed.

 

Chosen a car is a very personal decision. Take the car for a test drive and see if it fits. Alternatively think of a GTI. (still my reference hot hatch). The R is a different league, but testdriving really gave me a very big smile  ;D

 

I take on board your comments about the outgoing models...

 

Space is not the issue - we have an X5 for the family duties.  In fact I hardly have anyone in the passenger seat never mind the rear seats.

 

It has been a long time since I have owned a "hot hatch" - I associate that with my early 20's (a few years ago!) Maybe it just feels like a backward step.  Ignore the 123d, I bought that for everyday duties while I had a nice car in the garage - now that has gone, thanks to the business, then it is time for 123d to move on.

 

FFS - if the right car comes along at the right price I will probably just do the deal an be done with it - I am sure I will like it!  8-|

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...