Wismerhill Posted November 5, 2010 Report Share Posted November 5, 2010 Its a wanna be!!! Its like a young boy trying to be like his elder brother. Doesn't work for me. It still looks pig ugly underneath all that Halfords frippery. It says "GOD, I REALLY WANT A FAST BMW, BUT I COULD ONLY AFFORD THIS FISHER PRICE VERSION" I think i've made my point. A bit harsh perhaps...bet hey ho hey boy racer!! You've said it, but it still knows how to kick your a$$ you on red light grand prix... >:-D What, exactly are you saying!!!??!!! ;D Well nothing else then even though it looks like a Fisher Price you might not see much else then the rear light of that M1 on dry roads. I mean it still a serious performance machine with much less weight than the R and very capable engine... even though it looks dull... and that the M3 would be way ahead ;D Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kram67 Posted November 5, 2010 Author Report Share Posted November 5, 2010 So by your analogy M3 owners should aspire to own an M5 or M6?  Basically if any car has a “bigger†or “faster†brother than that is what you should aspire to?  So do you have to be top of the food chain in the manufacturer you can afford – is that why you bought a Golf R? In a way, yes and no... It's like the Porsche dilemma, if you own a Boxster, even if it is a great car, it is an advertisement that you can't own a 911...? The M3 vs. M5 / M6 doesn't fit, in my opinion, the same dilemma but for the GTI vs. the R, yes. The 135i is a great driver's car that has the best 6 cylinder engine in production today.  You don't really want to compare the performance of the Golf R to a 135i or M1 do you... you would look very silly! I already tried and lost to a 135i.... Great car, but not my cup of tea for 2 reasons. Switzerland has snow. Lots of it. My old car, a 350Z was a BILLION times better than my R in my opinion, but the R is a car with a dual personality. Comfy and fast. Its the jack of all trades! RWD is so much better and more fun to drive than FWD or RWD... You should try it!  Your little incident the other day with the rear stepping out while "turning and accelerating"  (LOL) that put a smile on your face can be achieved far easier and more controllable in a RWD car... only takes a bit of tuition. RWD is awesome except in snow. 300 BHP + fat 275 rear tires = my death last year. The idea of a light weight high revving M1 (not to say that is what BMW will produce) appeals to me more than the current M3! It would be nice if manufacturers could start to think that way again - although EU crash test regs will prevent that. The problem with modern cars is they have become fatter and heavier - Golf R included, over 1500kg for a small hatch FFS !! The only time I would want AWD is in the snow - the rest of the time a well set up RWD is perfect.  As we only get a couple of weeks of snow a year, that is a hell of a compromise for the rest of the year. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sandok Posted November 5, 2010 Report Share Posted November 5, 2010 The idea of a light weight high revving M1 (not to say that is what BMW will produce) appeals to me more than the current M3! It would be nice if manufacturers could start to think that way again - although EU crash test regs will prevent that. The problem with modern cars is they have become fatter and heavier - Golf R included, over 1500kg for a small hatch FFS !! The only time I would want AWD is in the snow - the rest of the time a well set up RWD is perfect.  As we only get a couple of weeks of snow a year, that is a hell of a compromise for the rest of the year. Agreed, a small and lightweight car is what I always wanted. My old 350Z was a fat bugger too =P~ The Golf R is heavy because of 4WD. Weighs the same as the new Subaru STI more or less. If I were in your shoes, I would not even think of the Golf R to be honest. It's a great car, but I need it for snow more than anything. For the same money, a 370Z, a 135i, a second hand 335i and all are possible. Seriously agree that RWD ownz AWD on anything but snow. I live at 3000 feet so snow is an issue. If snow isn't, get something that will enjoy a bit of tail hanging Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kram67 Posted November 5, 2010 Author Report Share Posted November 5, 2010 The idea of a light weight high revving M1 (not to say that is what BMW will produce) appeals to me more than the current M3! It would be nice if manufacturers could start to think that way again - although EU crash test regs will prevent that. The problem with modern cars is they have become fatter and heavier - Golf R included, over 1500kg for a small hatch FFS !! The only time I would want AWD is in the snow - the rest of the time a well set up RWD is perfect.  As we only get a couple of weeks of snow a year, that is a hell of a compromise for the rest of the year. Agreed, a small and lightweight car is what I always wanted. My old 350Z was a fat bugger too =P~ The Golf R is heavy because of 4WD. Weighs the same as the new Subaru STI more or less. If I were in your shoes, I would not even think of the Golf R to be honest. It's a great car, but I need it for snow more than anything. For the same money, a 370Z, a 135i, a second hand 335i and all are possible. Seriously agree that RWD ownz AWD on anything but snow. I live at 3000 feet so snow is an issue. If snow isn't, get something that will enjoy a bit of tail hanging Interesting as I thought about a 370z but have not pursued it. The problem with the 135i is that it returns low 20's mpg, which is not good for me, at the moment. Having said that I am hopefully going to get one for 24 hours next week , so I will see then. If you like lightweight fast cars, you would have liked my last track car - An S1 Exige with a Honda Supercharged (charge cooled) engine - around 340bhp at the fly wheel!!  Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Helmi Posted November 6, 2010 Report Share Posted November 6, 2010 All great cars, the 135, 335, Z370, cayman/boxter, Evo, STi, TTS/RS, potential M1 and last but not least the GolfR. i was considering them all but i finally went for the R. let us put some questions: 1- which car has best performance but at same time doesnt cost you a fortune to maintain and doesnt break your back if use it every day for work trips? 2- which car has practicality to carry your small family and at same time if you are alone can put a smile on your face? 3- which car host you best in the cabin and has best level of options/technology with the best level of price (in dubai, the R is the cheapest among the group apart from the japaneese)? 4- which car has the best image/prestige/brand satisfaction? so looking at all the above, the R won in most of the questions. yes performance only it is not the winner for sure. brand alone also it will not win...but the beauity of the R is its ability to do so many things in a good way and others excel only in 1 or 2 departments. there is nothing like a perfect car out there in the market. even bentleys and lambos have their own issues. the perfect solution as Kram indicated earlier is to have another car in the garage for weekend/track blasts and for image reasons. me personally i can't afford this for the time being. also i personally do not agree with the concept of the cayman is the "poor man's 911" and the the M1 is the "poor man's M3" each car has its own beauity and appeal. i personally love the cayman S more than basic 911s and i hate the M1 Â ;D last comment, IMHO the 1 series has a big design problem in the front end. the front head lamps are really ugly. the 3 coupe is ways better looking. and of course the golf R/GTI looks much better than most of the hatches. but the look is a personal thing. i hope i have proved than i am not fully biased to the golf R (or am i ???) 8-| :-X sorry for long reply, just wanted to participate in that interesting debate... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kram67 Posted November 26, 2010 Author Report Share Posted November 26, 2010 Just thought I would let people know what car I ended up with in the end. I couldn't get the deal I wanted on a Golf R and to be honest the VW dealers weren't that keen on doing business - obviously awash with sales! Half of them didn't even call back! So, I ended up with a low mileage 135i (cracking engine) - needless to say I am happy. I appreciate it is not everyones taste...! Cheers, Mark Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Danno Posted November 26, 2010 Report Share Posted November 26, 2010 Just thought I would let people know what car I ended up with in the end. I couldn't get the deal I wanted on a Golf R and to be honest the VW dealers weren't that keen on doing business - obviously awash with sales! Half of them didn't even call back! So, I ended up with a low mileage 135i (cracking engine) - needless to say I am happy. I appreciate it is not everyones taste...! Cheers, Mark Well done mate. Let us know what it's like....I'm sure you won't have any regrets, a new car, no matter what it is, is going to be the apple of your eye....have some rear wheel drive fun for all of us!!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mhoutman Posted November 28, 2010 Report Share Posted November 28, 2010 and you genuinely believe the Golf R looks better than this? Believe I am a huge BMW fan. Owned a 528i Touring, 540i Touring, X5 4.4i, 545i Touring and currently a 130i. My wife currently drives a 325i Touring. BMW are generally speaking awesome drivers cars and my current 130i gave me the best experience so far, but.... a 1M doesn't appeal to me for the same the reason the Audi RS3 can't. Too much over the top and too much these bling bling parts if you know what I mean ;DÂ But hey i am the guy who does adore a Porsche 997 2S in stead of the GT3 full monty Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kram67 Posted November 29, 2010 Author Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 Well, I think a few of you are going to find this funny... I have decided not to buy the 135i after taking my 123d out on Saturday on lightly covered snow roads - I was reminded how terrible the car is in snow. Last year I had to abandon the car when other cars, such as ford fiesta’s, golf’s were driving past me. I had convinced myself that I didn’t want to compromise myself by buying a front or all wheel drive car for the few weeks a year we suffer snow. But now I have decided that I can’t live with another 1 series! So, I will keep looking for a Golf R - I am sure there will be a few deals to be had in Jan - quiet time and they will have come down in price by then. :-[ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Chris_tkd Posted November 29, 2010 Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 What a really informative thread! Thanks guys! I've been out of the car market for a while, however I'm very much back in now. I think we're all in the same decision point: Roughly all agree we want a german badged car. Golf R BMW 1 or 3 series Porsche Cayman maybe a few others that I forgot! For me, it's deciding once and for all if I want a "Q" type car like the Golf, that can also carry decent volumes of luggage. Or if I want an out and out sports car like the Cayman. It's not easy, but test drives should tell you all you need to know! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TP27 Posted November 29, 2010 Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 We've got a good 10 inches for snow here in Edinburgh - I've been everywhere in my R32 and am reminded by my Dealer that my new R has an improved Haldex system so it'll be even better in these conditions. I cannot tell you how many BMW's and Merc's I've seen over the weekend, stranded in snow, going nowhere !! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
astroman Posted November 29, 2010 Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 East Lothian has 15 inches of snow but roads were generally cleared & drivable once I got out of my drive - had to go and get supplies. Left the new R in the garage - it's got 200 miles on it now but I don't fancy some plonker pranging into it - not so worried about my wife's car so took that. Good move because the Tesco car park was like the dodgems! Wife was amazingly sympathetic to me taking her car and touch wood nothing untoward happened. As an aside how many of you R people park at the far side of a car park away from the masses and the doors of an establishment in places like B & Q or supermarket car parks? Is it just me? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Helmi Posted November 29, 2010 Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 East Lothian has 15 inches of snow but roads were generally cleared & drivable once I got out of my drive - had to go and get supplies. Left the new R in the garage - it's got 200 miles on it now but I don't fancy some plonker pranging into it - not so worried about my wife's car so took that. Good move because the Tesco car park was like the dodgems! Wife was amazingly sympathetic to me taking her car and touch wood nothing untoward happened. As an aside how many of you R people park at the far side of a car park away from the masses and the doors of an establishment in places like B & Q or supermarket car parks? Is it just me? ^^^^^ ;D i do that too Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
harryhackenbacker Posted November 29, 2010 Report Share Posted November 29, 2010 No not just you I think a lot of people with nice cars try and park safely  always thought the diabled was safer in the supermarket (wide bays ) until at my local tesco 10 cars were badly damaged by an elderly heart attack victim stuck on full throttle in an auto 5 series what a mess,the Guy in a old auto triumph (neighbour) went backwards through bushes through a duck pond and out the other side  ;D ;D Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dariusmarius Posted November 30, 2010 Report Share Posted November 30, 2010 Dealer that my new R has an improved Haldex system so it'll be even better in these conditions. does anybody know what kind of improvements were made? I find this idea quite often but nobody gives any details. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.