Mainframe Posted October 13, 2015 Report Share Posted October 13, 2015 Between axles is fine. Thats an absurd thing to say. It's a daft thing to do, that's for sure. But for each reason that you can give for the statement being absurd, I'll give you a reason that it's a daft practice. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AdDaMan Posted October 13, 2015 Report Share Posted October 13, 2015 I beg to differ. I know for fact there's no harm in it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gadget Posted October 14, 2015 Author Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 Its caused a problem on mine that and the difference in tyre depth. Getting 2 new Michelins next week and see if that cures it Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Limey Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 I've been driving haldex cars pretty much every day for 15 years and have had lots of tyres! You do not need to replace 4 tyres at the same, but you do need to replace in same axle pairs. You also dont need the same brand/model front to rear, but it does look better in the snow Dave AdDaMan 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gadget Posted October 14, 2015 Author Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 Cheers mate must be tread depth then. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mainframe Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 MB state that you shouldn't mix tyres in their owners manuals, Porsche insist on same tyres, VWFS do not advocate mixed tyres in their at& Cs Why? Manifold reasons, most are obvious, but the first post here encapsulated most of them. http://www.350z-uk.com/topic/36637-mixing-tyres-and-why-you-really-shouldnt/. Someone nearly lost their bacon later in thread, thru mixing n matching. Why wouldn't you run the same 4 rims? is more apposite. You car was not developed on different tyres with different grip compounds, sidewall flex, water clearing channels, rotational differences (even in ostensibly same-sized tyres from different manufacturers). etc. Sure you are OK. It's advisory...but if you don't drive like a granny, if you go 9/10s, in that one in a million event that can be potentially tragic, why bank on anything but your 4 contact patches, coming from the same tyre design present in all four corners, and optimised for your cars chassis settings by the oem teams, to give a consistent response, and to allow the cars safety systems to function as designed. Or, put another way, show me the tyre test that gives all the top tyres performing the same in the Evo (etc) tyre tests on same car and across all dimensions - in respect of wet/dry slalom, wet/dry braking, high speed circuit, emergency stops. They all perform differently. If you are cool with your F/R doing same, good luck. rotate tyres properly and renew 4 at a time. Would anyone replace with two different brands then? tobys 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Limey Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 Not saying you should put run flats on the rear and track slicks on the front - they need to be of similar calibre performance wise. I ended up with 2 mixed brands when they stopped F1's at my local garage, ended up with Bridgestones until the F1's worn out. Didnt even notice, but I dont hoon around trying to get banned/crash Dave Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mainframe Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 Get a tdi^ Limey 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tom 2000 Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 Surely it's a simple matter of balance, or imbalance of traction/grip best and easiest achieved by matching tyres. Mainframe 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AdDaMan Posted October 14, 2015 Report Share Posted October 14, 2015 MB state that you shouldn't mix tyres in their owners manuals, Porsche insist on same tyres, VWFS do not advocate mixed tyres in their at& Cs Why? Manifold reasons, most are obvious, but the first post here encapsulated most of them. http://www.350z-uk.com/topic/36637-mixing-tyres-and-why-you-really-shouldnt/. Someone nearly lost their bacon later in thread, thru mixing n matching. Why wouldn't you run the same 4 rims? is more apposite. You car was not developed on different tyres with different grip compounds, sidewall flex, water clearing channels, rotational differences (even in ostensibly same-sized tyres from different manufacturers). etc. Sure you are OK. It's advisory...but if you don't drive like a granny, if you go 9/10s, in that one in a million event that can be potentially tragic, why bank on anything but your 4 contact patches, coming from the same tyre design present in all four corners, and optimised for your cars chassis settings by the oem teams, to give a consistent response, and to allow the cars safety systems to function as designed. Or, put another way, show me the tyre test that gives all the top tyres performing the same in the Evo (etc) tyre tests on same car and across all dimensions - in respect of wet/dry slalom, wet/dry braking, high speed circuit, emergency stops. They all perform differently. If you are cool with your F/R doing same, good luck. rotate tyres properly and renew 4 at a time. Would anyone replace with two different brands then? Sorry but no. Seeing as the Golf R is being sent out with at least 4 different tyres on them i dont see your point in saying the manufacturer developed the car around the tyre. Also i have Michelin PSS on the fronts and Contis on the rear. The balance is far better than standard. I want slightly more grip at the front than the rear. And mine gets driven at 10/10ths let alone 9/10ths. Fair enough if you put budgets on the rear and branded up front or vice versa. But whne your talking about performance tyres it makes no odds. In fact semi slick on the front in a FWD and road tyres on the rear is also a very good setup. Counteracting understeer etc.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tom 2000 Posted October 15, 2015 Report Share Posted October 15, 2015 I think you are both right. The manufacturer finds it easiest to recommend uniformity all round just in case someone mix n matches the wrong way round and ends up in the soup however the OEM balance can be improved upon and logically worsened. AdDaMan 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mainframe Posted October 15, 2015 Report Share Posted October 15, 2015 Posted 22 June 2010 - 17:40 There's a lot of conflicting threads and posts on here with regards to the subject of tyres and in particular mixing them on the car, so I've been asked to write this which should hopefully clear a few things up as well as giving you something to think about and make your own mind up on.I'll start with the very obvious: Tyres are the only thing keeping the car in contact with the road. As daft as it sounds it's always worth remembering, as whether you're chasing tenths of seconds on track or munching motorway miles you will always want tyres that give you full confidence that they are doing their job properly at all times and in all conditions. That's the really the key point I'm getting at through the whole of this post, confidence in your car and tyres. If you take nothing else away from this, just remember that stability will lead to confidence and you won't go far wrong.I'll start with an oft-used example of tyres here, the RE040 (left pic) and RE050 (right pic). These are OEM fitment on the DE and HR engined cars respectively, and the latter on the 370Z as well. They seem pretty similar at first glance: Five main bands over the tyre, slots all pointing the same way where appropriate, both made by Bridgestone and only one number apart... Now look closer. See the centre band? On the 40 it's split with a line down the centre, on the 50 it has no line and the cuts into it are much more pronounced. The next two bands out are completely different, look at the angle and sweep of the cuts. Finally look at the out bands, and see just how different the cuts in there are.Two tyres, both by the same manufacturer, both fitted as standard to the Zed over the years, both just one number apart, both completely and utterly different. This is absolutely key in understanding why mixing tyres is a bad idea. I've driven on both of these tyres in the dry, the wet and on track, and they are even further apart than they now look. The RE040s are noisy, uncomfortable, have good grip in the dry but atrocious grip in the wet; The RE050s have a very progressive feel, outstanding water displacement at high speed and excellent dry traction. They're the tyre equivalents of a Ford Escort and a Ferrari Enzo. That said, as long as you keep all four tyres on the car the same (be it all 040s, all 050s, or whatever you prefer) you'll find a car stable and predictable. Now what happens if you mix them...Let's think about this logically. Let's picture the Top Gear test track at Dunsfold as it's a place just about everyone is familiar with, and let's say it's bone dry. Our test car is a stock 350Z naturally, and in the first instance is fitted with RE040s all round. Get in, drive, enjoy. No issues at all, car feels just like it should. After a few laps it starts raining, so you adjust your driving and speed to match. Car feels noticeably slower, tyres have nowhere near the grip you're used to, but nothing feels drastically out of place. Car goes back into the pits, time for a spot of lunch, and ZOMG! THE SUN'S OUT! YAY FOR A DRY TRACK IN THE AFTERNOON! Now we leave the RE040s on the front but put RE050s on the rear. Jump in the car, off you go, giving it full beans. Will you notice any great issues? No, probably not. Remember, both tyres are good in the dry, so you'd expect the car to be fairly balanced. It handles just like it should, but you do notice a bit more traction from the back when coming out of the Hammerhead.Soon the heavens open and the track is soaking wet. Same car, same setup (40s on the front, 50s on the rear), same driver. Once again, you go for a fast lap. First time round is slow as you get used to the wet surface again, then you start picking up the pace as you get used to the conditions again. You come round Chicago and brake hard for the Hammerhead, and start to turn in. The front washes ridiculously wide and you're in the gravel. Why? The RE040s have much less wet grip than the RE050s, and so you get chronic understeer despite the rear feeling very planted.Now we change the tyres around, so that the 40s are on the back and the 50s on the front. Same wet conditions, same driver. Out of Chicago, onto the power, brake hard for Hammerhead, car turns in fantastically well to the left, same to the right, but the second you get onto the power coming out the arse end overtakes you and you're suddenly facing the wrong way. As you've put the grippier tyres on the front the car now wants to oversteer everywhere, and as you carry on round the track and all tyres get hotter the differences become more pronounced. Yes, very huge and over-complicated scenario perhaps, but it illustrates the basics very well. There's a million and one things you can do to adjust grip balance between front and rear (suspension settings, weight balance, tyre pressures etc) but all those things will give you a subtle difference you can learn: Completely different tyres will always behave at such extremes you'll always struggle to cope, and that's on track when you've got the space to get it a bit wrong. Tracks are made of one material and all laid at the same time (for the most part, airfields are a different kettle of fish), and as such you can almost cope with different tyres as the road surface doesn't change. I can't think of too many roads in the UK that are the same!Imagine you're driving on a motorway at 70mph in our mixed-tyre Zed in the rain. You're in a straight line, in all honesty very little is going to go wrong. Suddenly there's a car in front you of that you need to overtake, so you indicate and pull out to the right. At the same time you happen to cross a section of road that has been repaired and replaced so has different grip to the rest. Your axle with 050s on takes it fine but a combination of surface, temperature, camber, suspension travel and steering angle combine to make the 040s aquaplane and you suddenly find yourself in a spin at 70mph in the middle of the M6. Your odds of walking away are pretty slim at this point.If you were on 040s all round you'd know how crap they are in the wet and drive appropriately, but on mixed tyres you don't get that kind of warning as you're getting such mixed signals. It's not a scenario that would happen often, but given the nature of driving would you really want to take that chance? There are so many different variables on a car and we take them all into account when driving, most of them subconsciously, and I simply can't understand why people would want to add another one in there just for the sake of a couple of quid. Let's make no mistake here: Mixing tyres is done 99% of the time because people are too tight to buy the correct tyre. That goes for all other cars as much as it does for the Zed. You need a new set of rears a couple of thousand miles before the fronts, but instead of replacing them all with something different people tend to take the cheap option, and then wonder why the car feels horrible to drive.Driving isn't cheap, I appreciate that, and sports car driving even more so, but is it worth risking your £10,000 car for the sake of a couple of hundred quid? No, of course it isn't and anyone who does so knowingly is an utter fool. If you can't afford to swap tyre brands for something different then don't! Some tyres are better than others but ALL tyres have been through EU type approval, which makes them all perfectly safe to use on the road. A set of Michelin Pilot Sport 2s will be infinitely better than a set of Nankang Ditchfinders, but a car with four Nankangs will be more controllable, more predictable and safer than a car running two of each. There's so much more to it, not least of all different compounds, different thermal expansion points at set temperatures, amount of water dispersed at set speeds... So much detail that you need a degree in physics to understand it all properly. Thing is, common sense is more than enough once you know the basics. I appreciate that there are people out there running mixed tyres who say that it's perfectly safe and they've never had an accident, and good luck to them in that, but I maintain it's always just a matter of time and the wrong circumstances that is going to lead to tears. It might not even be their fault: It might be the idiot that pulls out without looking causing them to swerve and end up in an emergency situation that they have no control over due to mixed tyres. Hell, that could happen even on matched tyres, but I know which is going to give you a more predictable and balanced car to give you the best chance of getting yourself out of any trouble. I'll leave you with a thought: There's not a car manufacturer in the entire world who supplies their cars with different tyres on. Their combined research budget is billions of billions of pounds. There isn't a single professional race series that would ever consider running mixed tyres, and they're aiming for hundredths of seconds so surely if it gave them an advantage, they'd do it. It won't, and they don't. andy13, Martdy, stiggy786 and 2 others 5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mainframe Posted October 15, 2015 Report Share Posted October 15, 2015 Surely it's a simple matter of balance, or imbalance of traction/grip best and easiest achieved by matching tyres. That is the more straightforward point. if folk do wish to mix compounds and designs, and then drive 10/10ths, good luck, when it's needed. I am sure they can handle all eventualities, and will be OK in 99% majority of driving situations. For the other and majority of keen and moderately skilled/experienced drivers, and I count myself there, tuning same tyres with same characteristics F/R makes sense, and may just save horrors if the 1% occurs. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tom 2000 Posted October 15, 2015 Report Share Posted October 15, 2015 Having said all that there was a recent instance of a F1 car lapping with a mis matched tyre and the driver couldnt feel it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mainframe Posted October 15, 2015 Report Share Posted October 15, 2015 Not exactly what Bottas was quoted as saying after the debacle cost Williams 5 places and several million in Bernie's points make prizes contract. “It wasn’t too bad but it felt a bit strange, and then I heard there was one prime tyre on an option set, so obviously disappointing because we lost a realistic fifth place at “ And he is most definitely a (relative) driving God who can handle a car in extremis. I guess he could have, in an ideal world, chosen a pair of rear bridgestones to give some rear end slip against the front Pirellis...and then made up a few places. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.