Jump to content

andrewparker

Members
  • Posts

    685
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by andrewparker

  1. His anti-R stance smacks of someone who is desperately trying to justify their purchase decision. Maybe the CS is a better drivers car, but it’s far from the best drivers car where hot hatches are concerned. He’s constantly fuelling this R vs CS debate, but it just comes across as someone fighting buyers remorse to me.
  2. I'd assume so. Hearing the noise under hard acceleration makes me think it isn't the engine mount though. Mine was caused by lateral movement, and it only had any effect under hard cornering.
  3. That little yellow mark is chalk. The mount on the opposite side had snapped and was allowing so much movement that there was contact where that yellow chalk is.
  4. No, it was literally just when cornering. They eventually diagnosed it by putting some chalk to either side of the engine, and could then see it had been disturbed when they drove it.
  5. In my case it was actually an engine mount that had snapped in two! That was allowing the engine to move over to the nearside when cornering hard. The engine mounts are encased in rubber so it's not exactly easy to see.
  6. That's crazy. Genuinely getting very interested in a swap now. We're in the middle of a house move at the moment, but once that's done I think I'll start thinking more seriously about it.
  7. I've said this a few times over on PH, but I had a MK8 R-Line loaner for a week, and honestly, after that time I was completely used to the infotainment system. The people making a fuss about it are the journos who don't spend enough time with the car, and people who don't like the idea of it so have taken it upon themselves to decide it is rubbish with no firsthand experience. Enjoyed Dan's video, it was certainly more positive and in-depth than his written review.
  8. Haha, I generally always get that feeling when PH review VWs. It's disappointing because I like Dan Prosser and he's normally far more detailed. This feels likes he's had a 20 minute slot to form an opinion.
  9. PH review is live – https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=23&t=1918384&i=999999
  10. I read the EVO review also. It’s disappointing that DCC is so integral to how well the car performs, yet it isn’t standard. It’s doubly frustrating that VW can’t engineer a car that performs well on passive dampers, like BMW have evidently done. The EVO review also mentioned traction problems, which is why I guess most of us here drive a Golf R!
  11. I think Chris Harris's behaviour on Twitter is pretty embarrassing to be honest. He constantly has a chip on his shoulder about one thing or another, and seems to specialise on throwaway comments that are never backed up by any meaningful opinion or criticism. I much preferred him when he was a straightforward automotive journalist, rather than a z-list celebrity.
  12. Hmm, I think you're kidding yourself, but carry on. I'm not here to be a white knight, and I'm certainly not having a tantrum, I'm just asking for people to have more consideration when they post. It might just be banter to them, but the person in question might not see it that way. We all know that things said on the Internet don't always come across as they're truly meant to.
  13. I’m all for lighthearted banter, but I take issue with stuff like this. It’s completely unnecessary. We all know what the inference is. And it’s nothing to do with being a snowflake, it’s just basic decency.
  14. Perhaps I'm alone in this, but I expect a moderator to exercise more restraint. It's just not very classy. You should be encouraging people to be more amicable, ensuring the forum remains an inclusive place for all to enjoy, and where people can have a difference of opinion without being lambasted for it, or worse, have snidey comments directed at them.
  15. I have to agree. The vitriol directed at Andrew has got out of hand round here. It’s unjustified and it really doesn’t reflect well on the VWROC community. We should all be able to debate differing opinions without resorting to personal slights.
  16. Sorry, that was a typo, should have read 316bhp in my post, hence the 19bhp difference. I think we all know that sort of difference is negligible.
  17. Between the Type R GT and the GTI Clubsport there is a 19bhp difference (316bhp vs 297bhp). Price difference is £895 (£36320 vs £37215), or in my eyes, more-or-less the same. I suspect the Type R GT will probably still be the better drivers car, but without any direct comparisons, or even full reviews of the Clubsport, I'd say it's too early too say.
  18. Impressive that the negative camber has resulted in a 10mm drop over the standard GTI. It also sounds incredible. It's frustrating that there are so many complaints elsewhere on the Internet about the price. In my eyes this is a direct competitor to the Civic Type-R GT and Megane RS Trophy, both of which cost more-or-less the same. I'd be happy with Reflex Silver, winter pack and DCC, but would definitely source alloys elsewhere. Matt bronze Oz Alleggeritas maybe.
  19. Although neither would affect my enjoyment of the car, it does reek of cost cutting and leaves me wondering where else they have saved money. No doubt this cost saving won't be passed on to the consumer.
  20. I think the MK8 has potential, certainly looks nice and planted in this image of the GTI.
  21. Not sure if you've seen it, but this was the thread I started when I was trying to diagnose the problem –
×
×
  • Create New...