ShinyAndy Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 (edited) So, was about to put my deposit down and then memories of my slightly tweaked MY00 Scooby came flooding back. An amazingly capable car but ultimately incredibly dull unless you're doing traffic light grand prixs or 100mph down a country lane with the fear of ending up on your roof about 300m away in a farmers field. After the Scooby, which thankfully got stolen, I went down the Elise/VX220 and Caterham route.. all about 500% more fun than the Scooby and with the bonus of being at legal speeds too. I've grown up a bit (lot) since and with child/associated tat but still do trackdays and so not adverse to a "spirited" drive. Has anyone done a similar thing in terms of previous Scooby/Evo owner and how does the R really feel comparatively - is it a similar straight line junky car that's mainly unstickable in the twisties? Of course all this could be answered with a decent test drive but that's not an option here! Edited May 30, 2017 by ShinyAndy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Splats Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 I had an MY99 classic with 275bhp and then a 315bhp STI-V. First of all, the Golf is a better steer than both of them and feels (even in Estate form) much more like a hot-hatch that can be adjusted on the throttle. Turn in and outright grip are better, although 15yrs of tyre technology could be the main factor here. Amazingly, I'd even say that Gen 5 Haldex with its electronic wizardry is better than the symmetrical and 'proper' set up of the scooby. Never driven an Evo but on paper it would be hard to beat its AWD technology. The Golf is a great car and I much prefer it to my Impreza's - it's simply better and faster in every single area. However, the fact remains that it's just a Golf and is very safe, secure, and borderline dull until you get it loaded up near(ish) to the limits. Driven at 6-7/10ths you will a) still be driving irresponsibly and b) bored. Driven at 8/10th it comes alive and is far more mobile, adjustable and communicative. In most dry situations this will require you to step up to a pretty anti-social level. I love my Golf but I'm well aware that when I'm truly having a ball of a time I am getting flashed and the wanker sign from anyone that sees me. To be fair though, I think this problem affects nearly all modern hot-hatches and fast saloons. They are just too damn good. As an example, there's a nasty quick left/right over a little bridge (on a racetrack of course) near where I live where every other month someone has rolled their shopping cart because they wen't through it at 60mph, lifted and then lost the back end. The Golf takes it at 90mph like it wasn't there. At 100mph it's fun and I would hazard a guess it would manage north of 115mph before it would come unstuck. Think about that for a moment: poorly driven normal cars are crashing at 60mph and I have to fire through at 100mph just to feel like the car is being tested. There are days where I wish I could drive down a national speed limit road at 50-60mph and have a ball but then you also can't deny the fun in launching away from lights or pulling 100mph in under 10s. If life was fair I'd have my R Estate and a Caterfield. ShinyAndy and PhilC22 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tweaked9107 Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 I'd have to echo what Kenny has said. I've only had mine a few days but I can tell already that this isn't a car that comes unstuck easy. I think if you want something fun at lower speed you need to go RWD with the option to turn TC off. Maybe a GT86 for example (after a few mods of course). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ShinyAndy Posted May 30, 2017 Author Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 I appreciate it will stick forever (and that is fun too on occasion), I was more thinking that is it just going to leave me cold like the Scooby did when you've got past the novelty/excitement of how quick it is off the line. GT86 does nothing for me and I still need it to be a practical 5 seater to ferry grandparents and child around in comfort. I think as Splats says, all modern fast cars are probably the same and just a bit too good! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Billy Whizz Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 At the end of the day it's horses for courses, and expectations. I also have a Civic EP3 and a ZZR1400, both are immense fun to drive/ride, EP3 like a go cart and sooo reminiscent of the MK1 GTI, just raw/agile and brisk, the 14 is verging on suicide if ridden hard. The G7R for me is perfect, I genuinely doubt there are better real world A to B cars out there for the money (or for that matter considerably more expensive), comfortable, rapid, and handles damn well. You have to remember, you can only drive/ride so fast on public roads, if you need more, then it's a track day fix that you have to go for..... Camnhoj 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
42ac Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 RS? If you can live with the choppy ride the RS is way more fun than the Golf. I couldn't live with the ride so I got my Golf R. However, I miss the RS from time to time when I want to have fun, the Golf is stubborn, it won't get lively unless pushed hard, the RS lets go with a dab of the throttle (in the right driving mode of corse!) and can be fun at low speeds, just blip the throttle and pop 'n bang. The modern hot hatch choice represents a huge dilemma for buyers, I agonised over my Golf, even cancelling at the last minute to get the RS only to sell 2 months later to get the Golf. I got my money back selling the RS and saved ££s on the Golf but even now I find myself looking at RS ads. Ultimately the Golf is such a good all rounder, in race mode it just about satisfies my inner rally driver. It has the unflappable nature of Scoobys (I had a "98 wagon and a '99 saloon) but with a nice interior thrown in. If the next STI has adaptive dampers, bucket Recaro's, around 350hp, 35mpg, and sunroof option then sign me up. Oh wait, I've just described the RS! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Pumatron Posted May 30, 2017 Report Share Posted May 30, 2017 I've only had the R for 3 months or so done very low mileage but have had some hot hatches Etc in past (civic type R, Clio 172 cup, Rx8 etc), I've driven some fast French cars (Clio V6, Clio Williams, Alpine GTA, 5,9,11,21,25 Turbos in various guises). I have to say though the Golf R hands down scares the brown stuff out of me more than any other car I have ever had or been in, it allows you to drive so stupidly but at no point does it feel like it is about to throw you up the road and into the nearest ditch. It is dangerously good in my opinion. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ShinyAndy Posted May 31, 2017 Author Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 12 hours ago, 42ac said: RS? Ultimately the Golf is such a good all rounder, in race mode it just about satisfies my inner rally driver. I couldn't have an RS as friend here has one and he only lives about 250m away (you may have seen the video about the engine failure in another post). It's the only one for 100s of miles around so would look a bit like we were a couple or something 👨❤️👨 I think the modes is what can save me, shove it in Eco mode for my endless motorways journeys sat at 140kph and then pop it in Race for the school run and Sunday morning trips into some of the completely empty back roads here - plus the occasional trackday of course 👍 12 hours ago, Pumatron said: I have to say though the Golf R hands down scares the brown stuff out of me more than any other car I have ever had or been in, it allows you to drive so stupidly but at no point does it feel like it is about to throw you up the road and into the nearest ditch. It is dangerously good in my opinion. Each to their own, exactly that was what bored me about the Scooby! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Splats Posted May 31, 2017 Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 When I had my RS on order (for whole bloody year) Justin's videos kept me going. I still love every time I see one on the road and would, I'm sure, enjoy owning one. However, I'm very happy with my Golf and glad I made the switch. I also have a private game going where I mentally clock up RS vs Estate R seen on the road. At the moment it's pretty close but I'd say the Estate is rarer The big difference between the Golf and the Scooby is the feeling and sensation you get through the steering and chassis when it's properly loaded. Scooby's just grip until they don't and then they get messy quickly. As previously explained, the Golf has a nice envelope where it rides on its tip-toes and will give subtle movements and feedback that allow you to trim lines, get little squirms, and have some fun. Just don't go into it thinking it'll feel like that round a roundabout at 20mph in the dry. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ShinyAndy Posted May 31, 2017 Author Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 Cheers Kenny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ShinyAndy Posted May 31, 2017 Author Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 Interestingly given my procrastination has gone on so long, my order would now mean a MY18 car which aside from going up in price, has the following changes according to the dealer: Quote MY18 3rd brake light with black framing Light height adjustment is now through the touch screen instead of a switch Alarm de-activation is now through the infotainment Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Splats Posted May 31, 2017 Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 As changes go, it's not the most exciting of line ups Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ShinyAndy Posted May 31, 2017 Author Report Share Posted May 31, 2017 Quite! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.