Jump to content

More low coolant concerns


ferraridomuk

Recommended Posts

Didn't know about this issue -- so another big thumbs-up to the Forum hive brain...!!  👍   Thanks, chaps!  😁

 

I had noticed that the coolant level in my estate has been a little low but it does appear stable and I was planning to top it up when I get back from holiday anyway (and, no, I'm not driving that car).   It's not a new car (66-plate with, as far as I could tell, a decent service from the dealer before I picked it up) and I don't do a huge number of miles but I'll definitely keep an eye on it from here on in.

 

What's your strongest argument in terms of replacement for the water pump / thermostat housing?  I bought the car from a big independent rather than a VW dealership, so I have no direct previous relationship with my local VW dealer.  Should it ever become a problem, with an obvious leak, is it really as simple as pointing out to them that this is a *recognised* problem, I know it, they know it, they know that I know it, and they just need to get on with it...?  🤔

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Booth11 said:

 

Yours probably a result of the air left from the factory which leaches out over time and makes it look like a leak as the coolant level drops.  An initial top up and usually fine after (but monitor).  Very common issue with VW and Golfs leaving factory with airlock in the coolant system.  Almost as common as the water pump/thermostat housing leak issue itself!  😁

 

Yeah I had to top mine up as it dropped to halfway. A bit shot back in when the lid was removed. Been fine ever since top up.... random cars

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Should it ever become a problem, with an obvious leak, is it really as simple as pointing out to them that this is a *recognised* problem, I know it, they know it, they know that I know it, and they just need to get on with it...?  


The residue from posts 2 and 5 eliminates the need for any discussion. The coolant drips down from the thermostat/water pump housing down on to the oil pan indicating a need to replace them. “My thermostat housing is leaking and this is a well documented issue” should be enough. Any garage that hesitates is a sign to go elsewhere.

I put my car on a lift before my powertrain warranty expired for a thorough inspection and was able to get this photo as well right above the oil pan but that isn’t necessary:

aabd63cd209bf46d5c5d1bb4ced8018c.jpg
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

My warning light came on so drove like a granny.

 

Undid the cap and a popping noise and coolant went from just below min to about halfway.

 

My Das Welt runs out in 1 week so fingers crossed it either is air pocket or if leak does it in next day or 2.

 

Im going to give her a booting tomorrow just to check if light comes back on or not. 😁

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Mhmm mines just been done as well, I smelt coolant last week and upon checking on the garage ramp it’s the dreaded thermostat housing/water pump leak, can’t believe this wasn’t a recall.


Are these photos after repair? My car had coolant drips everywhere and yours almost looks like it rolled off the assembly it is so clean.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am very bad almost ocd about it being dirty and I think it’s filthy at the moment, will post some pics up after I’ve cleaned it again, regards stripping it down that much we had a leaking headlamp washer jet assy  so had to remove bumper also it needed a a/c recharge so really for the sake of disconnecting intercooler pipes as we had to drain coolant anyway and some bolts it was way easier just to remove the front and have complete access to the water pump and thermostat.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

My 2013 VW Golf begun leaking coolant in April 2019. Coolant light came on, so I bought some G13 coolant and topped it up but within a short time the coolant light had come back on and I took it to the car repairers for a fix. At first, the water pump was found to be the culprit and I got the water pump, thermostat and thermostat housing replaced with genuine VW parts. I had to wait for a few weeks until all the parts arrived because they were sourced from VW and the toothed belt housing (which seems to be the issue causing all these coolant leaks) was replaced also. From what I understand, VW is still replacing the defective housing with the original, plastic designs. I strongly urge you to ensure that this housing is not repaired by VW.

 

It only took a month and the light was back on. On second inspection, the repairers were unable to find a cause of the coolant leak and were aware that there were other VW customers who were confused about their own heat exchangers leaking internally. Since my coolant was leaking at such a rapid pace, it would only hold a full tank for about 12 hours. Consequently, the engine light came on and it repeatedly overheated. Throughout this whole repair process, I was unable to find any comprehensive explanation online to gain a better understanding of what I should do about my problem. I have written this post in goodwill to assist with any future concerns that VW mk7 vehicle owners might have regarding their coolant leaking.

 

I took the car to the manufacturer later in the year and paid $250 for a diagnosis which read “low compression/defective water pump” as the cause. As mentioned above, I had this replaced earlier in the year. I came in to collect the vehicle and I asked to see the mechanics. When I came into the workshop, I was immediately handed a piece of plastic and told “this is your problem” by one of the guys. Consequentially, the internal damage due to overheating of the engine would make further repairs somewhat futile for me if engine failure was an inevitable likelihood.

 

That melted plastic (pictured) was left out of the diagnosis report but handed to me as the first finding by the mechanic. I kindly asked the VW service centre to include this as a finding on the report provided to me. I waited over two weeks whilst they told me they were amending the diagnosis report – but in the end I was told that they were unable to include the finding. Screenshots of their emails admitting about it are linked below. The discrepancy between my diagnosis report and email correspondence suggests that VW is not being honest about this design flaw and seems to be purposely misleading their mk7 owners about the melting plastic casing.

 

As you may not already know, the new mk7.5 range has now used steel casing rather than plastic to avoid this issue. If I had known about the melting plastic sooner than I would have been able to identify the problem and have it replaced with a suitable material (i.e. steel casing rather than plastic). I hope I can show the online community concerned about coolant leaks that there is most likely an issue with melting plastic around the coolant tank, specifically encasing the “toothed belt”.

 

Diagnosis report: https://pasteboard.co/IFZp5jk.jpg

Email correspondence: https://pasteboard.co/IFZsEtI.png

Melted plastic casing top-side: https://pasteboard.co/IG6hvbG.jpg

Melted plastic casing bottom-side: https://pasteboard.co/IG6hQnj.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...