Jump to content

EBC Redstuff


Clarkie48

Recommended Posts

20 hours ago, RS6BRIT said:

Wow, that was a read and a halfemoji38.png

I'm not going to aggree or dissagree with what you said but for one exception. The mechanic that has seen more pads than most has probably seen 99.9% at simple pad change time, and that doesnt really qualify him to say which are better than other, with perhaps the expection that if he fitted them in the first place, he may be able to tell the longiveity of one pad over another.
Whilst I wouldnt take one persons word on a forum as gospel, I would take somones word who has actually run them over a mechanic who doesnt, unless said mechanic used them himself. If he hasnt then he is infact no different to everyone on foruma who says "my mate used them and they woz shit".

Other than that, I think you made some valid pointsemoji106.png

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk
 

 

Sorry for the novel.  And don't worry, I see the irony between forum post and a forum post about another person who said :). 

18 hours ago, Gavras said:

Some valid points, however picking up on your last point.

 

if you are going to use data, try getting conclusive data, a post about a single person having problems is bollox.

 

its like saying there is a post on Xbox forum where an Xbox blew up, don’t buy an Xbox.

 

There is zero evidence to back up your data that, the person with the brake pad problem could be a total cockwomble and brought the issue on themselves, equally it could be fact and they did simply fall apart.

 

equally they could have been fakes, there are plenty counterfeit pads out there. Those will literally fall to bits.

 

A lot of times when root cause is found, counterfeit products are found to be the culprits.

 

https://www.incoproip.com/counterfeit-car-parts-risking-lives/

 

using singular posts from a year ago from a link from an online forum, to try and state things as a fact is flawed from the outset.

 

Your 2nd post if a bit shorter was better, also there are plenty YouTube videos on the review and failings of both Red and Yellow. These would have provided more of a balanced argument, rather than ‘my mate Jon, says...’

 

now the question of valuing opinions....

 

a mythical track god mechanic that only exists because you say he does, or forum members that provide numerous supporting photographs, reviews, various build reviews, comments on mods etc, that have far more years experience driving cars of various types which gives them a wealth of experience..... yep tough call that one.

 

Please keep posting, it’s a great forum, however just try supporting points a bit more.

 

 

I agree, conclusive data would be best.  Unfortunately, conclusive data requires a large sample size.  EBC reds on a mk7 golf is extremely specific and would be an exhaustive task to find enough reliable data to create a large enough sample size to weed out statistical insignificance and create conclusive data.  The juice isn't worth the squeeze.  Because that data is not readily available, it leaves little else other than "my mechanic says..." or "track people who have used it say..."  or "I used them before..." type posts.

 

To address your last statement, IMHO, I have provided more support for my claims than anyone else in this thread.  Additionally, if you read my initial post carefully, the only claim I made was I avoid them due to information from numerous sources I find reliable.  While you may dismiss this data due to previously stated reasons, I believe at least some is worth more than "I like them" posts.  If, as you posted, there's equal chance of the pads failing as there is the driver being a cockwomble.  I ask myself, is that a good enough chance to trust my life on, when there's many different alternatives that don't require that chance?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...