Jump to content

DarkArrow

Junior Members
  • Posts

    48
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

DarkArrow's Achievements

Advanced Member

Advanced Member (3/9)

20

Reputation

  1. The car was running with an upgraded intercooler and intake. Official post from EQT is here. APR claims to make 410bhp or 364whp with their turbo & tune with no downpipe. EQT's uncorrected doesn't seem to be a stretch of possibilities. USA shops are moving towards factory downpipe mods, since federal government is cracking down on everyone doing anything to tamper with emissions.
  2. Intercoolers don't make more power, they help keep the power you have. So, a downpipe will have a higher power bump than an intercooler. That being said, I would recommend an intercooler before a downpipe. The factory intercooler gets heatsoaked incredibly quickly, especially on a tuned car. My datalogs on a stage 1 car was seeing IATs 30+ degrees f over ambient on a single 3rd gear pull. For some data points of some of the more popular intercoolers intercooler test
  3. From how many people will quote me and argue in every brakes topic thread, I'm clearly in the minority on this forum of thinking that the factory brakes are fairly capable. It honestly surprises me how quickly everyone jumps at completely replace your brakes if there's any question about them. OP has said nothing about the condition of his current brakes, pads, tires, etc on a 5+ year old car. Most likely by this point, pads and tires have either gotten to the point they should be replaced or they have been replaced. No one knows (even OP has stated he's unsure of condition), yet with absolutely zero information about that, the first 4 responses are change your brakes to RacingLine, RacingLine, TTS calipers, RacingLine. But, I agree. No point in arguing over the internet. It's OP's money. If throwing money into a BBK, pads, lines, fluid, and tires makes him enjoy the car more, then more power to him.
  4. Your car is 5+ years old. Do you know the history of the car? Maybe the basics like was it a daily driver or was it a weekend track warrior? I ask because very different maintenance requirements need to be done depending on usage. When was the last brake flush? What pads are on the car? What tires were you running on the AMG vs what's on the R now? So many things affect braking ability and I believe a common mistake is to assume upgrading the brakes means better braking. But, like anything else on a car, the brakes are only one part of a system. If you upgrade a piece of a system that isn't a limiting factor, then you don't really realize much benefit. There's also times where that "upgrade" actually results in worse braking performance. An example would be mismatching a BBK to the master cylinder.
  5. You also said Heat management is a big benefit. Bigger brakes deal with and dissipate high heat cycles far better than the stock setup. Ideal if you are doing spirited driving and almost essential for track work. OP asked for better stopping power. That's what my answer is aimed at. You keep bringing up different reasons for a BBK, Modulation, pedal feel, heat management, initial bite, weight, power, piston size etc are all things that could be taken into consideration too. None of which address the OP's question, which is stopping power. Yes, my only concern is if OP can trigger ABS because if he can, the ABS literally is reducing braking force to unlock the wheels, so he can not get any more stopping power from the brakes. If he can't trigger ABS, then that's something that has to be addressed with hardware, either failing parts or insufficient brakes. Because that's what he's asking about! Stickier tires will affect stopping distances WAY more than throwing on a BBK will. That's not an opinion, but a lot of people believe it is. Honestly, to me, it's interesting that your only concern is all the benefits of a BBK that do not address the OP's question.
  6. He mentions how poor the AMG is around town and doesn't mention track days at all. Assuming track duty seems to be a far jump. And even if we include track days, I had minimal issues with stage 1 power on factory calipers and rotors with better pads, fluid, RS3 ducts, and titanium shims. Stage 2, on the other hand, I'm running into a lot more issues. My point still stands that a BBK does not give better stopping power unless you're unable to activate ABS. (heat issues you're mentioning usually results in the inability to activate ABS)
  7. If you can lock your wheels and have ABS kick in, you won't get any better stopping power from a BBK. ABS is reducing your brake force to unlock the wheels and adding a bigger brake kit doesn't increase the amount of force before your wheels lock. The only real benefit at this point would be most BBKs might save some weight, so you have slightly less rotational mass and unsprung weight. If you can get ABS to kick in, stickier tires will affect your stopping power significantly more than pads, rotors, lines, a BBK, or anything else will.
  8. You're absolutely right, I am stateside and have not had the pleasure of experiencing roads in the UK. My first track event in my R was completely stock (including factory brake fluid... eek!). If you're able to drive even close to that in the UK, I'm not sure if I should be excited by the opportunity or afraid if your drivers are as terrible as they are over here. Rotors will always be up for debate. Wilwood has this warning on their site for drilled rotors: Caution on drilled rotors: There is a common mis-perception that rotors are drilled to improve cooling. The reduced mass of a drilled rotor will dissipate its retained heat quicker, but it also builds up heat a much faster rate. The decision to use drilled rotors should be solely based on the merits of the lower rotating and unsprung weight, and Nt for improved cooling. It is Nt wise to use drilled rotors in sustained high heat on hard braking tracks unless the team budget affords a high frequency of rotor and brake pad replacement. You had already highlighted the positives of SS lines in a previous post, so I just wanted to add the positives of keeping the factory lines. There's no wrong answer going either way. I've already gone through 3 sets of track pads and 1/2 of my factory pads, and my car only has 28k miles. I think I'm using the car for what it's made for. 😁
  9. You're really overthinking this. Do you like how the car feels currently? Is there any reason why you think you need better pads other than being stage 1? IMHO, you should modify only if you're unhappy with something. The R brakes are more than capable on street application, regardless of how much horsepower you make. If you're overloading your factory brakes on the street, you're either taking twisties extremely hard or you're doing something highly illegal. As long as you can lock your wheels, you can NOT get any better braking from your brakes, period. Your ABS is literally reducing braking force to unlock the wheels. The short version is, unless you're overheating your brakes which shouldn't happen on public roads, tires will affect braking a million times more than upgrading braking components. If you want the longer version.... Pads are purely subjective. Most people seem to be fine with the factory brakes outside of how much they dust. If you're happy with them, why spend more on pads that will not increase brake performance? Fancy discs are mainly for aesthetics on the street. Cross drilled, slotted, j-hooks, etc will not benefit a car driving on the street and will only increase pad wear and dust. Unless you're someone like Lewis Hamilton, you won't notice the 1kg loss of weight by running CSS discs. Solid, high carbon discs are more than sufficient for daily street driving, and are preferred by track drivers unless upgrading to a 2-piece set. Lines are also subjective. I prefer factory lines for street driving due to less maintenance requirements. While stainless lines usually have a teflon or PVC coating, it's still possible for debris to work its way into the weave and accelerate wear as it rubs the lines while they flex as you drive. Since the lines are covered by the stainless weave, it's more difficult to see any damage. Up to you if you think a tiny better brake pedal is worth the cost. My advice is to save your money on upgrading brake parts, and if you want better braking put that money towards better tires. Buy better pads/fluid if you schedule a track day. Swapping pads is very simple on the R.
  10. Vorshlag and Ground Control make plates that do not require cutting into the body and can be adjusted without dropping the suspension. I personally run the Ground Control plates and I like them. There is an increase in NVH, but not significant enough that I wouldn't do it to a daily driver. Can't speak from personal use on the Bilsteins, but most of the information I've seen is they're too soft for any real track usage.
  11. The factory brake system is more than enough for a stage 1 or 2 on a non-track application. The reason why Stage 1 or more on track starts to overwhelm the factory brake system is due to the extra heat the brakes generate from having to stop a faster car. This increases the chance of boiling the fluid, glazing the pads, etc. You shouldn't experience these issues on a public road without doing something stupid or illegal. The main reasons for a BBK on these cars are a larger disc acts as a better heatsink, the increased surface area of larger disc sheds heat faster, and a lighter 2-piece disc is less rotational mass. None of these benefits are really applicable to a road car. I don't have any first hand experience with the Macan calipers. I did research on them when people started swapping them over, but I currently don't see a benefit worth the cost. From my understanding the benefits are top loading pad swaps, using Mk6 R 345mm discs, and you get 4 piston calipers. The extra 5mm will very slightly increase the torque arm of the brakes allowing for slightly increased braking force and the 4 pistons will give you a more even clamping pressure and better modulation of the brakes. That being said, if you can consistently lock your wheels and activate ABS, that extra braking force isn't doing anything because your ABS is releasing brake pressure to unlock your wheels. Once the braking force overloads the tire's grip, you're not stopping any faster. A better tire will have a bigger impact on stopping distance, which is where I'd rather put the money towards instead of buying the Macan calipers.
  12. A couple highly recommended modifications for a track day to add to your list: - RS3 brake ducts. Inexpensive, fit like OEM, and are fairly effective. Won't replace a true ducting system, but people have shown they do help cool the rotors a decent amount. - Rear sway bar. IMHO, one of the biggest bang for buck mods for the R. Helps neutralize understeer. I haven't had any issues of snap oversteer that some other cars struggle with when you put a big rear bar on. On factory power, the factory brakes on an R are adequate. You'll run into heat issues towards the end of a typical 25 minute session, but they hold up okay with DS2500s and good fluid. Don't waste your money on "upgraded" discs/rotors. The only ones that would probably help are Girodiscs and they're $800USD/pair. Not worth it. High carbon blanks work just fine, and you won't feel bad when you need to replace them often or swap to a BBK. If you run a stage 1, you're pushing the capability of the factory brakes, and stage 2 will most likely run into heat issues very early and should be thinking of getting that BBK soon. FWIW, my OEM rotors have lasted ~12 track days and they'll be needing replacement before the next event. Not sure about pricing in Europe, but SuperPro makes almost identical camber plates for cheaper than 034. If you want adjustable camber, I recommend Vorshlag or Ground Control. AFAIK, they're the only adjustable camber plates that don't require cutting into the strut top or pulling the suspension to adjust. Since the R doesn't have any adjustable front camber, outside of shifting the subframe, I bought adjustable to keep the camber even. I'm running the Ground Controls with ~ -2* of camber and have very even wear. I'm looking to add more negative camber next alignment. If you zero out the front toe, you won't have any significant tire wear issues with modest camber.
  13. Sorry for the novel. And don't worry, I see the irony between forum post and a forum post about another person who said . I agree, conclusive data would be best. Unfortunately, conclusive data requires a large sample size. EBC reds on a mk7 golf is extremely specific and would be an exhaustive task to find enough reliable data to create a large enough sample size to weed out statistical insignificance and create conclusive data. The juice isn't worth the squeeze. Because that data is not readily available, it leaves little else other than "my mechanic says..." or "track people who have used it say..." or "I used them before..." type posts. To address your last statement, IMHO, I have provided more support for my claims than anyone else in this thread. Additionally, if you read my initial post carefully, the only claim I made was I avoid them due to information from numerous sources I find reliable. While you may dismiss this data due to previously stated reasons, I believe at least some is worth more than "I like them" posts. If, as you posted, there's equal chance of the pads failing as there is the driver being a cockwomble. I ask myself, is that a good enough chance to trust my life on, when there's many different alternatives that don't require that chance?
  14. The value I see in the link is a person showing what happens when they literally followed a How-To on EBC's website titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving" along with a spattering of other posters who have had bad experiences with EBC. While there might be an updated method, that article is still available on EBC's website and it should not have destroyed their pads to that level. If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree. When I make claims, especially negative claims, I like to back up my claims with data. I'm sorry you don't find value in this. The value of a mechanic who specializes in VW & Audi and has over a decade of experience has probably seen more brake pads than most people on this forum would see in a lifetime. I would put more trust into their opinion than random people on a forum (I know that's all I am as I post this). Again, I'm sorry you don't find value in this. Feel free to block me and ignore my posts from now on, because from my perspective, I see you place higher value in random strangers on a forum who say "I use them, they're great" with no additional information. You do you, I won't be offended by you ignoring me. Addressing the track use (which I never said redstuff was recommended for), when a brake pad company advertises a use for a specific pad and it does not perform up to that, it throws a red flag. As stated previously, Redstuff is advertised for "fast street" and "repeated heavy brake use." Yellowstuff is advertised as "track OK" and "zero brake fade" yet from what I've seen by people who I trust (why I even brought up track usage), EBCs have a reputation to fall short. Nowhere did I say redstuff was suggested for track use, because they're clearly not. EBC is a company, not one specific pad. Pad quality across their different lines is not mutually exclusive. If they have pads that, from multiple trusted sources for me, have fallen short, I would stay away from them. I agree mechanical sympathy is important to driving situations, but following a posted bedding strategy by the manufacturer resulting in pads literally crumbling would scare me away from ever using those pads when there's so many other options available. I wouldn't classify following manufacturer's procedure being mechanically asympathetic. I'm also not sure how that classifies the operator as a "f**k all" or "does not know how to drive with new pads and brakes." I've posted before about EBC and have gotten similar reactions. That's why I included the last paragraph. Guess it didn't help. Across the pond in the US, EBC does not have a very good reputation and I guess I should keep that information on this side of the pond. Most of this was posted just above. The method the poster used is still available on EBC's website and is titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving" I'm not sure how I could determine this is an outdated method and to actively search for an alternative? If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree. Even worse, if his pedal really did drop on the 8th stop, you're less than 3 hard stops away from bedding vs completely thrashed crumbling pads. Eeek. I've learned my lesson, though. Don't post about any bad experiences of EBC pads on this forum.
  15. I have never used EBCs due to warnings from my mechanic, friends who have 10x as much experience on track as I do, and seeing stuff like this: https://www.golfmk7.com/forums/index.php?threads/messed-up-my-new-brakes.367755/ I find it strange how there's a lot of people who have bad experiences on golfmk7, but I've seen a lot of posts like RS6BRIT who have great experiences on this forum. I hope you don't get pads that end up looking like that guy's on golfmk7. Be careful bedding them.
×
×
  • Create New...