Jump to content

EBC Redstuff


Clarkie48

Recommended Posts

I have never used EBCs due to warnings from my mechanic, friends who have 10x as much experience on track as I do, and seeing stuff like this: https://www.golfmk7.com/forums/index.php?threads/messed-up-my-new-brakes.367755/
 

I find it strange how there's a lot of people who have bad experiences on golfmk7, but I've seen a lot of posts like RS6BRIT who have great experiences on this forum.  I hope you don't get pads that end up looking like that guy's on golfmk7.  Be careful bedding them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldnt recommend Redstuff for track use, but then neither do EBC. I've used both Redstuff and Yellow stuff in the past on different applications and have never had any kind of issue. But then I drive the car sympathetically, and allow the brakes time to cool etc between heavy uses. On track this isnt really possible and for that reason I'd opt for a track purposed set of discs and pads.
I cant seem to open the link so dont know what happened there.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, DarkArrow said:

I have never used EBCs due to warnings from my mechanic, friends who have 10x as much experience on track as I do, and seeing stuff like this: https://www.golfmk7.com/forums/index.php?threads/messed-up-my-new-brakes.367755/
 

I find it strange how there's a lot of people who have bad experiences on golfmk7, but I've seen a lot of posts like RS6BRIT who have great experiences on this forum.  I hope you don't get pads that end up looking like that guy's on golfmk7.  Be careful bedding them.

Not sure what value the link adds, if anything it highlights one individual that either has f**k all idea on driving or does not know how to drive with new pads and brakes. That very much looks like someone has excessively ‘bedded them in’.

 

Also as mentioned, they are for a road setup, not for tracking, so again not sure why you mention a mechanic and track experience, however no one else in the thread has suggested using the pads for track use.

 

mechanical sympathy is key to driving, understanding what changes are, what bedding in strategy is required, invariably gentle driving and variation is required with any change, understanding the system.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, DarkArrow said:

I have never used EBCs due to warnings from my mechanic, friends who have 10x as much experience on track as I do, and seeing stuff like this: https://www.golfmk7.com/forums/index.php?threads/messed-up-my-new-brakes.367755/
 

I find it strange how there's a lot of people who have bad experiences on golfmk7, but I've seen a lot of posts like RS6BRIT who have great experiences on this forum.  I hope you don't get pads that end up looking like that guy's on golfmk7.  Be careful bedding them.

After reading that link it is obvious the OP followed some old (2013) instructions on the EBC site which said 10 hard stops in a row, which was way too much and totally cooked his street pads. The correct procedure for his pads (also on the EBC site) was only 5 hard stops in a row, which his pads may have survived OK (he said his pedal went down on the 8th stop).

 

Me, I use ATE low dust ceramic pads on my R and am very happy with them.  They do produce way less dust than the OEM pads.  They have slightly less initial bite, but grab really well when you lean on them harder (ie they are more progressive).  No noise or squeaks whatsoever. They are NOT marketed as a performance pad for track use etc, but I am very easy on brakes so they suit my driving style quite well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, Gavras said:

Not sure what value the link adds, if anything it highlights one individual that either has f**k all idea on driving or does not know how to drive with new pads and brakes. That very much looks like someone has excessively ‘bedded them in’.

 

Also as mentioned, they are for a road setup, not for tracking, so again not sure why you mention a mechanic and track experience, however no one else in the thread has suggested using the pads for track use.

 

mechanical sympathy is key to driving, understanding what changes are, what bedding in strategy is required, invariably gentle driving and variation is required with any change, understanding the system.

 

 

The value I see in the link is a person showing what happens when they literally followed a How-To on EBC's website titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving" along with a spattering of other posters who have had bad experiences with EBC.  While there might be an updated method, that article is still available on EBC's website and it should not have destroyed their pads to that level. If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree.  When I make claims, especially negative claims, I like to back up my claims with data.  I'm sorry you don't find value in this.

 

The value of a mechanic who specializes in VW & Audi and has over a decade of experience has probably seen more brake pads than most people on this forum would see in a lifetime.  I would put more trust into their opinion than random people on a forum (I know that's all I am as I post this).  Again, I'm sorry you don't find value in this.  Feel free to block me and ignore my posts from now on, because from my perspective, I see you place higher value in random strangers on a forum who say "I use them, they're great"  with no additional information.  You do you, I won't be offended by you ignoring me.

 

Addressing the track use (which I never said redstuff was recommended for), when a brake pad company advertises a use for a specific pad and it does not perform up to that, it throws a red flag.  As stated previously, Redstuff is advertised for "fast street" and "repeated heavy brake use."  Yellowstuff is advertised as "track OK" and "zero brake fade" yet from what I've seen by people who I trust (why I even brought up track usage), EBCs have a reputation to fall short.  Nowhere did I say redstuff was suggested for track use, because they're clearly not.  EBC is a company, not one specific pad.  Pad quality across their different lines is not mutually exclusive.  If they have pads that, from multiple trusted sources for me, have fallen short, I would stay away from them.

 

I agree mechanical sympathy is important to driving situations, but following a posted bedding strategy by the manufacturer resulting in pads literally crumbling would scare me away from ever using those pads when there's so many other options available.  I wouldn't classify following manufacturer's procedure being mechanically asympathetic.  I'm also not sure how that classifies the operator as a "f**k all" or "does not know how to drive with new pads and brakes."  

 

I've posted before about EBC and have gotten similar reactions.  That's why I included the last paragraph.  Guess it didn't help.  Across the pond in the US, EBC does not have a very good reputation and I guess I should keep that information on this side of the pond.

 

 

7 hours ago, gregozedobe said:

After reading that link it is obvious the OP followed some old (2013) instructions on the EBC site which said 10 hard stops in a row, which was way too much and totally cooked his street pads. The correct procedure for his pads (also on the EBC site) was only 5 hard stops in a row, which his pads may have survived OK (he said his pedal went down on the 8th stop).

 

Me, I use ATE low dust ceramic pads on my R and am very happy with them.  They do produce way less dust than the OEM pads.  They have slightly less initial bite, but grab really well when you lean on them harder (ie they are more progressive).  No noise or squeaks whatsoever. They are NOT marketed as a performance pad for track use etc, but I am very easy on brakes so they suit my driving style quite well.

 

Most of this was posted just above.  The method the poster used is still available on EBC's website and is titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving"  I'm not sure how I could determine this is an outdated method and to actively search for an alternative?  If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree.  Even worse, if his pedal really did drop on the 8th stop, you're less than 3 hard stops away from bedding vs completely thrashed crumbling pads.  Eeek.

 

 

 

I've learned my lesson, though.  Don't post about any bad experiences of EBC pads on this forum.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow, that was a read and a half

I'm not going to aggree or dissagree with what you said but for one exception. The mechanic that has seen more pads than most has probably seen 99.9% at simple pad change time, and that doesnt really qualify him to say which are better than other, with perhaps the expection that if he fitted them in the first place, he may be able to tell the longiveity of one pad over another.
Whilst I wouldnt take one persons word on a forum as gospel, I would take somones word who has actually run them over a mechanic who doesnt, unless said mechanic used them himself. If he hasnt then he is infact no different to everyone on foruma who says "my mate used them and they woz shit".

Other than that, I think you made some valid points

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, DarkArrow said:

The value I see in the link is a person showing what happens when they literally followed a How-To on EBC's website titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving" along with a spattering of other posters who have had bad experiences with EBC.  While there might be an updated method, that article is still available on EBC's website and it should not have destroyed their pads to that level. If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree.  When I make claims, especially negative claims, I like to back up my claims with data.  I'm sorry you don't find value in this.

 

The value of a mechanic who specializes in VW & Audi and has over a decade of experience has probably seen more brake pads than most people on this forum would see in a lifetime.  I would put more trust into their opinion than random people on a forum (I know that's all I am as I post this).  Again, I'm sorry you don't find value in this.  Feel free to block me and ignore my posts from now on, because from my perspective, I see you place higher value in random strangers on a forum who say "I use them, they're great"  with no additional information.  You do you, I won't be offended by you ignoring me.

 

Addressing the track use (which I never said redstuff was recommended for), when a brake pad company advertises a use for a specific pad and it does not perform up to that, it throws a red flag.  As stated previously, Redstuff is advertised for "fast street" and "repeated heavy brake use."  Yellowstuff is advertised as "track OK" and "zero brake fade" yet from what I've seen by people who I trust (why I even brought up track usage), EBCs have a reputation to fall short.  Nowhere did I say redstuff was suggested for track use, because they're clearly not.  EBC is a company, not one specific pad.  Pad quality across their different lines is not mutually exclusive.  If they have pads that, from multiple trusted sources for me, have fallen short, I would stay away from them.

 

I agree mechanical sympathy is important to driving situations, but following a posted bedding strategy by the manufacturer resulting in pads literally crumbling would scare me away from ever using those pads when there's so many other options available.  I wouldn't classify following manufacturer's procedure being mechanically asympathetic.  I'm also not sure how that classifies the operator as a "f**k all" or "does not know how to drive with new pads and brakes."  

 

I've posted before about EBC and have gotten similar reactions.  That's why I included the last paragraph.  Guess it didn't help.  Across the pond in the US, EBC does not have a very good reputation and I guess I should keep that information on this side of the pond.

 

 

 

Most of this was posted just above.  The method the poster used is still available on EBC's website and is titled "How to bed in your new brakes for street/urban driving"  I'm not sure how I could determine this is an outdated method and to actively search for an alternative?  If you think it's acceptable for pads that are advertised as "fast street pad" and "capable of repeated heavy brake use" to fall apart like that on 10 hard 60-10 stops, vs the updated 5 hard 60-10 stops, then we'll just have to agree to disagree.  Even worse, if his pedal really did drop on the 8th stop, you're less than 3 hard stops away from bedding vs completely thrashed crumbling pads.  Eeek.

 

 

 

I've learned my lesson, though.  Don't post about any bad experiences of EBC pads on this forum.

 

Some valid points, however picking up on your last point.

 

if you are going to use data, try getting conclusive data, a post about a single person having problems is bollox.

 

its like saying there is a post on Xbox forum where an Xbox blew up, don’t buy an Xbox.

 

There is zero evidence to back up your data that, the person with the brake pad problem could be a total cockwomble and brought the issue on themselves, equally it could be fact and they did simply fall apart.

 

equally they could have been fakes, there are plenty counterfeit pads out there. Those will literally fall to bits.

 

A lot of times when root cause is found, counterfeit products are found to be the culprits.

 

https://www.incoproip.com/counterfeit-car-parts-risking-lives/

 

using singular posts from a year ago from a link from an online forum, to try and state things as a fact is flawed from the outset.

 

Your 2nd post if a bit shorter was better, also there are plenty YouTube videos on the review and failings of both Red and Yellow. These would have provided more of a balanced argument, rather than ‘my mate Jon, says...’

 

now the question of valuing opinions....

 

a mythical track god mechanic that only exists because you say he does, or forum members that provide numerous supporting photographs, reviews, various build reviews, comments on mods etc, that have far more years experience driving cars of various types which gives them a wealth of experience..... yep tough call that one.

 

Please keep posting, it’s a great forum, however just try supporting points a bit more.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...