Jump to content

Engine acting weird when idle


nickotje

Recommended Posts

Hi,

 

I drive a 2018 Golf 7.5 R with now 62000 miles on it, had it from new and it is yearly serviced at the dealership.

 

When cold the rpm’s stutter from 900 to 1000 rpm and back for a few seconds, then it returns to normal. But I can hear that the engine isn’t running smoothly. When driving I have no issues or powerloss at all.
 

Changed sparkplugs and checked pcv valve but could not hear any vacuum leaks.

 

Anyone have a guess what it could be? 
I tried recording it, the first 3 seconds you can see/hear it.

 

 

 

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, nickotje said:

Update:  used Carista to see any misfires or fault codes, no fault codes but at cold start it misfired 5-20 times on all cylinders. When the engine was warmed up no more misfires..

Is the 2018 direct injection only or mpi and direct. That is often what carbon buildup in intake ports feels like.

 

Have the plugs been changed? Other than that wouldn’t be a bad idea replacing 

fos/pcv at that sort of mileage to entirely rule out. They often only work properly for 50k miles.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, fastandy said:

Is the 2018 direct injection only or mpi and direct. That is often what carbon buildup in intake ports feels like.

 

Have the plugs been changed? Other than that wouldn’t be a bad idea replacing 

fos/pcv at that sort of mileage to entirely rule out. They often only work properly for 50k miles.  


hi, plugs have been changed few days ago. It is a 2018 non opf version EU spec. Will look into replacing pcv and coilpacks. What does fos mean?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, nickotje said:


hi, plugs have been changed few days ago. It is a 2018 non opf version EU spec. Will look into replacing pcv and coilpacks. What does fos mean?

Oh, the Fine oil separator (fos)  it's integrated into the same assembly, the assembly has the oil separator and various check valves and a diaphragm in it. 

 

If its all cylinders showing misfires then I doubt coil packs would help unless, one counter  is a lot worse than others. If the misfires persist that would normally trigger a eml and sometimes cylinder deactivation... 

 

Some reported misfires are normal in cold start situation. I can't recall how many mine normally shows I'll try to have a look and report back. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, fastandy said:

Oh, the Fine oil separator (fos)  it's integrated into the same assembly, the assembly has the oil separator and various check valves and a diaphragm in it. 

 

If its all cylinders showing misfires then I doubt coil packs would help unless, one counter  is a lot worse than others. If the misfires persist that would normally trigger a eml and sometimes cylinder deactivation... 

 

Some reported misfires are normal in cold start situation. I can't recall how many mine normally shows I'll try to have a look and report back. 


thanks for the reply, I’ve ordered a new pcv and new coilpacks.

 

Did some checks again today on coldstart and noticed cylinder 4 was misfiring.

 

 

A70A9D43-E3F6-4241-9E74-39A080299A52.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, golf7.5r said:

Could be PCV as it's not easy to see when these fail. Also make sure you're dipstick is sealed correctly. Also, check you're fuel cap is on correctly.

Dipstick when pulled out with engine on makes the engine stutter, goes back to normal when dipstick is back in. Fuel cap is on correctly.

 

Have ordered a new pcv. Thanks for the reply.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
2 hours ago, nickotje said:

I finally got a fault code through Carista.

Could this be the camshaft magnets? I’ve read it could be either this or the sensors on top.

 

 

F6311EF6-5041-44FF-9248-56F3D2C27049.png

68AE32C9-491E-47E0-B787-1A57DD216F41.png

0FCF7483-5385-4ACC-9BA9-86402705E948.png

It is likely to be the magnets or if not the valves inside the camshaft that the magnet pin presses on. If it is not either of those it gets progressively more scary. Does it say intake or exhaust anywhere. Normally it is the intake magnet that freezes first. You can remove it, clean it with brake cleaner and loosen of the pin and it will probably work for a while. But it will freeze again in my experience but at least in confirms that is the issue before you buy parts.... 

 

The other appraoch is to use measuring blocks or advanced measures or whatever the obd calls them now, and monitor caamshaft timing specified and actual both intake and exhaust and you will see if one or both is not following specified very well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/04/2024 at 12:31, fastandy said:

It is likely to be the magnets or if not the valves inside the camshaft that the magnet pin presses on. If it is not either of those it gets progressively more scary. Does it say intake or exhaust anywhere. Normally it is the intake magnet that freezes first. You can remove it, clean it with brake cleaner and loosen of the pin and it will probably work for a while. But it will freeze again in my experience but at least in confirms that is the issue before you buy parts.... 

 

The other appraoch is to use measuring blocks or advanced measures or whatever the obd calls them now, and monitor caamshaft timing specified and actual both intake and exhaust and you will see if one or both is not following specified very well.

It were the magnets, thanks for the response! 😀

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...