Jump to content

Top mount issues


ben120280

Recommended Posts

Hi all...  I've a 2016 R Estate that recently had an overhaul of its suspension (long story but a pot hole forced my hand)  Anyway, I went for new OE shocks and top mounts all round and a set of Eibach springs... the smallest drop they offer so about 10mm I think.

Almost instantly the NSF was creaking and knocking, the garage did mention it to me when I collected the car and told me to keep in touch if it doesn't stop.  After about 2 months and no improvement, they replaced the top mount under warranty and it looked messed up (cant think of any technical way of saying it!)  all in all, pleased with the service and everything else as things do happen.

 

That was about 3 months ago and since its been fine but now the OSF has started knocking loudly and I suspect that's now also shot.  The last time I ran a lowered car was about 20 years ago on a MK1 focus, dropped about 30mm and didn't have a single issue.  I cant find anything on the net about OE top mounts failing after less than 5k miles.  I will go back to the garage again to see what they say but if they havent fitted them correctly then dont really want to keep going back.

 

Anyone have any experience or suggestions?  Currently looking at replacing the top mounts for uprated ones if this is an issue..

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a MY2016 Estate as well. Dec 2015 Mfr.  All I can say is they are fussy one you've moved the struts out of position and re-installed.  Mine was all nice and quiet until I had to remove the nearside strut and driveshaft for a boot repair. Then it moaned like mad. Then I replaced bearing and top mount and mostly fixed it. Then the otherside did it as well, I know I should of done both and I bought the full set but I was pressed for time. So then I did the other as well. Whilst it is bearable now I would still say it isn't perfect. I don't know whether I should be loading the suspension before tightening to torque - I need to check the Etka workshop manual. That could help I guess.... I'm kind of used to it now, along with the rattle from the steering wheel airbag - my wife doesn't even notice that anymore!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have done this exactly the same as you on my estate about 5 weeks ago, I replaced everything though even the dampers all VW stock except the Eibach springs.

Did you have OEM top mounts when replacing also did you do the bearings ? 
As I have read that OEM from VW is best way to go rather than other name replacements that are OE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Swerve said:

I have done this exactly the same as you on my estate about 5 weeks ago, I replaced everything though even the dampers all VW stock except the Eibach springs.

Did you have OEM top mounts when replacing also did you do the bearings ? 
As I have read that OEM from VW is best way to go rather than other name replacements that are OE.

You maybe asking the OP but for the record,  I used Lemforder repair kit which includes the topmount and bearing. It didn't look substantially different to the oem, the oem will be made by one of the big part manufacturers. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, fastandy said:

You maybe asking the OP but for the record,  I used Lemforder repair kit which includes the topmount and bearing. It didn't look substantially different to the oem, the oem will be made by one of the big part manufacturers. 

Not gonna disagree with you mate as you absolutely know more than me, but I have read before that for some reason people changing to ones supplied by VW cured the issue. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 28/11/2024 at 12:02, Swerve said:

I have done this exactly the same as you on my estate about 5 weeks ago, I replaced everything though even the dampers all VW stock except the Eibach springs.

Did you have OEM top mounts when replacing also did you do the bearings ? 
As I have read that OEM from VW is best way to go rather than other name replacements that are OE.

Other than the Eibach springs, I went full OE with shocks, top mounts, bearings and all sundry parts needed for a complete overhaul.  Ive since been back to the garage and its 100% failed again for the OSF.  They have offered to replace it again FOC under warranty but now thinking that some uprated top mounts may be the way to go.. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Imteyaz said:

How about this "OEM+" solution:

 

Genuine VAG MQB Front Suspension Top Mount Upgrade Kit

 

I have no experience of using this but have bookmarked it for when I overhaul the suspension on my own car.

That is interesting as the bearing with this kit is described as a 'plain bearing' which suggests that this does not use a ball race but perhaps a phospor bronze thrust ring (seems improbable to me). Can anyone confirm this? If so then this may be the solution for getting rid of creaks and groans from the top mounts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, SS100 said:

That is interesting as the bearing with this kit is described as a 'plain bearing' which suggests that this does not use a ball race but perhaps a phospor bronze thrust ring (seems improbable to me). Can anyone confirm this? If so then this may be the solution for getting rid of creaks and groans from the top mounts.

No idea what any of that meant to be honest!  As long as they are better than the OE and dont turn to duct in 6 months from a 10mm drop, id be happy!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@SS100 The part number from the link is 8S0412249. I've looked at a few descriptions but they all mention 'plain' bearing. No mention of phosphor bronze. 

 

Common fitment on  Audi A3 and TT from the fitment list - do these suffer top mount issues ? 

 

Cheers 

Crick 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...