Jump to content

Is this the right OBDeleven for me ? plus they have a sale


Crick

Recommended Posts

Hi all, 

 

probably been discussed before but I guess everyone's requirements are different. 

 

I have a DSG oil change planned soon and was going to read the oil temp by using a laser thermometer on the case but isn't entirely accurate and I want to do it right so though I'd buy a OBD device and read the temp from there. 

 

So other than that, I might use it for changing rear pads and perhaps check how many launches but : 

- I only have one car so its not for multiple use

- I have no desire to code rear light changes, adjust interior lights etc

- car runs fine so I'm not chasing any faults (for now at least) 

- I don't really want to subscribe or pay for a license etc 

 

My car is mk7.5 ,2017 and I'm in the UK. Phone is Iphone using ios 18.2.1. 

 

Would this suit my needs - https://obdeleven.com/products/nextgen-obdeleven-device

 

I noticed they have a sale too, 30% off packs and credits but don't think it applies to me. 

 

Thanks 

Crick 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Following some more reading, as far as I understand it : 

 

- The NextGen will work with my car plus my phone 

- The same but with 200 credits is just for 1 click apps which I've learnt from the teachings of @dv52 aren't recommended but this still has the same level of diagnostic as the standalone device.

- Pro Pack. unlimited credits for 12months ?

- Ultimate pack. Same as pro but with pouch and phone holder etc. 

 

So NextGen sounds right for me with no credits (sorry if this all sounds obvious to you but this is the first car I've owned that you can plug into 😅, my other car doesn't have an ecu)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Crick: Darren - your brief-synopsis of the OBD11 product offerings is kind-of correct - but it really doesn't tell the full story (no offense intended).

 

The deities on the OBD11 mother-ship basically offer 3 x pricing plans - which ALL use the ONE Nextgen dongle (the original white OBD11 dongle is no longer available from official OBD11 distributors). So, the difference in OBD11 products is basically a matrix of software limitations that are tied to your OBD11 account as a result of the chosen OBD11 plan 

 

Hopefully, the side-by-side comparison HERE might be a tad more instructive as an aid to making a buying decision (scroll-down the web-page to see the plan limitations)?

Don  

 

PS: The OBD11 site in my reply above makes the common mistake of using the word "free" for the Basic-plan. Of course there's nothing "free" about the ticked items.

 

The better description for the Basic-plan would be that the listed items are available "at no addition cost" after paying for the OBD11 dongle.

 

If the Basic plan was "free" - anyone could access the ticked list without the need to buy the dongle! Yes, I'm a self confessed and proud pedant!!😉

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Microbe: Tony -Hi. I couldn't find your classified ad!

 

So, I'm not sure what "my OBD" means - but if it refers to "my OBD11" device -then the sale comes with added complications for both the potential buyer, and the seller! The fundamental architecture of OBD11 is very different to other diagnostic devices like VCDS.  

 

If you are selling a Ross-Tech device -then the sale is straight-forward for the buyer because once the dongle is received, the buyer simply downloads the VCDS software from the web-site and uses the product. Ross-Tech's software architecture is based on 20th century technology in that the entire software package (meaning both the VCDS operating-system and the complete vehicle database for every compatible car) is contained within the download file. This is the primary reason why it has been so easy for scurrilous IP thieves to copy and sell VCDS clones - because Ross-Tech continues to make their entire software available to all on their web-page (albeit with some encryption), which is kind-of like open-source software in the 21st century!! 

 

OBD11 however is different because the key elements of their software (including the vehicle database) is hidden behind the firewall of OBD11's central servers. This means that the equivalent software (the App) that OBD11 users download is effectively just a server access permission request. Once this access request is correctly authenticated, the REAL diagnostic software (including ONLY the database for ONE car)  is downloaded to the OBD11 user's mobile-phone/table. This access permission request is a ONE-time only thing - meaning that the operating system and vehicle database is deleted once the diagnostic session ceases. That's why there are no OBD11 clones  - because OBD11 uses 21st century security architecture!!

 

So, the sale of a "used" OBD11 dongle necessarily also includes the sale of the original OBD11 account. Hence the access permission elements of the old user account must be transferred to the new user. This means an exchange of email account and password details - plus the History records of the old user are also transferred to the new user.

 

Don't get me wrong, these are NOT insurmountable issues - but the sale of 2nd-hand OBD11 devices do have privacy impacts that should be made explicit in the ad and most certainly should be clearly understood before the sale is consummated (IMO, of course)!!

 

Don 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Booth11 said:


That’s because @Microbe’s advert hadn’t yet been approved.  It has been approved now and is live in Classifieds.  

@Booth11: Thanks Rebecca. I keep forgetting about this forum's approval protocols - how do you make these decisions (seems to me to be an impossible task even with your sixth sense)?

 

@Microbe: Tony - £35 appears to be a very good price given that Gendan is selling the same thing for £175.00! So someone will be getting a good bargain - maybe? 

 

But I'm confused -what exactly are you selling? Is the £35 price for the dongle only - or will the buyer also get your OBD11 account? I suspect the latter because your advertisement quotes "Ultimate Pack", which has nothing to do with the dongle - the "Ultimate Pack" is a software license that's tied to your OBD11 account. If so, is the license still active - meaning has the recurring annual license fee been paid since you purchased the product? If so, when does the subscription lapse?  These are relevant matters for prospective buyers that I suggest might be worth mentioning in your ad - I think!!

 

Don 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Don

 

Thanks for the feedback.

 

Yes, it's the OBD11 device, accessories and my account details.

 

I have sold an old previous gen OBD11 device previously when I moved over to a Mercedes for a while and had no use for it. It's during this process that I worked out that the account is an essential part of the package.

 

It's good to make people aware of this to avoid misunderstanding and grief !

 

I'll update the text of the ad to be clear.

 

Tony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, dv52 said:

@Booth11: Thanks Rebecca. I keep forgetting about this forum's approval protocols - how do you make these decisions (seems to me to be an impossible task even with your sixth sense)?

 


Don, the approvals criteria for a Classifieds advert is pretty simple - it’s not a subjective decision process,  Rules are here:

https://www.vwroc.com/forums/topic/20947-classifieds-section-and-group-buysdiscounts-rules/#comment-34289

 

But in summary: 

  • ALL adverts will be subject to approval. Please allow up to 24hrs for approval
  • Existing rules apply: at least one photo of the actual owned item for sale is required (generic photos from the internet) , at least one photo must clearly display a slip of paper bearing username and date next to the item for sale (not digitally added), a price must be specified - adverts not meeting these requirement will NOT be approved and will be deleted. If your advert is not approved within 24hrs assume it was deleted for failure to meet requirements 
  • Any attempts to post adverts in the main site will result in a warning and the post being deleted. Repeated attempts will result in a ban

If those criteria are not met then no approval.  Most commonly members forget to include the slip of paper with their username and date, but in those cases I just message asking for that info.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Microbe said:

Hi Don

 

Thanks for the feedback.

 

Yes, it's the OBD11 device, accessories and my account details.

 

I have sold an old previous gen OBD11 device previously when I moved over to a Mercedes for a while and had no use for it. It's during this process that I worked out that the account is an essential part of the package.

 

It's good to make people aware of this to avoid misunderstanding and grief !

 

I'll update the text of the ad to be clear.

 

Tony

Tony: hmm..... forgive my pedant pursuit of this matter - but I'm a self-confessed stickler for detail! Given your philosophy "to avoid misunderstanding and grief" and with absolutely no offense intended - there is still no indication in the ad of the largest expense to a potential buyer if the sale is consummated (which is NOT the £35 advertised price).

 

I'm definitely reading between your words, so I might be wrong - but I assume from the drift of your last reply that the 12 month "Ultimate" license has not been renewed since the original purchase. If I'm correct (and my apology if I'm mistaken), a potential purchaser will need to renew the license for your OBD11account as a necessary condition of use - else your account will lapse to the so-called "free" product option, which is nowhere near as feature-rich as the Ultimate Pack.

 

From the Gendan web-site, the renewal fee for the Ultimate license is £120 - so the actual price for a working Ultimate Pack for a potential buyer is actually  £35+£120 =  £155. This is still cheaper than Gendan's price of £170 for a new Ultimate Pack - but not as much an incentive as the advertised price of  £35 (again - no offense intended).

 

Don 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don - As always you are a wealth of information, explanation and confirmation. Not just on this topic but across the whole forum, answering questions about tail light configuration, fault codes and wiring, sometimes without acknowledgment or thanks. 

 

I would raise a bottle VB in your honour (if I had one to to hand and it wasn't 11.45am) 

 

The link was (as expected) very helpful and at this moment, my only intended requirement is to read the dsg oil temperature. Yes, I could carry out a basic scan for pre-emptive maintenance purposes but the car as far as I'm concerned does everything correctly, no issues there. I'm happy in my blissfully ignorant blinkered world 😂

 

Regarding @Microbe sale of his ultimate pack, we have discussed and I'm aware the additional licence has expired so apart from any accessories, I'm essentially just getting the dongle on the free plan which for now satisfies my requirements. 

£35 plus postage is still cheaper than £51.69 (why not £52) direct from OBDeleven. The price is about right as its a used item plus it goes towards some petrol money for a fellow forum member. 

 

Long may your reign as the forum coding king continue 👑

Thanks again 

Crick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Crick said:

Don - As always you are a wealth of information, explanation and confirmation. Not just on this topic but across the whole forum, answering questions about tail light configuration, fault codes and wiring, sometimes without acknowledgment or thanks. 

 

 

 

Long may your reign as the forum coding king continue 👑

 


Second that!  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Booth11 and @Crick: Arrh..............gosh!!! Thank you  - I'm more than a tad humbled by your generous (and undeserved) words!

 

Truth is that there ain't nothing special about this canard-noir - I just happen to have a limited understanding of stuff that may be useful on forums like this.

 

However,I have absolutely no doubt that both of you know lots of stuff about which I'm completely ignorant and which in a different context I would laud with equal praise!! 

 

So, let's abandon any sense of hagiography because in reality ALL members of this forum community are intellectual equals 

 

Again, thanks!

 

Don 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Crick said:

Don - As always you are a wealth of information, explanation and confirmation. Not just on this topic but across the whole forum, answering questions about tail light configuration, fault codes and wiring, sometimes without acknowledgment or thanks. 

 

I would raise a bottle VB in your honour (if I had one to to hand and it wasn't 11.45am) 

 

The link was (as expected) very helpful and at this moment, my only intended requirement is to read the dsg oil temperature. Yes, I could carry out a basic scan for pre-emptive maintenance purposes but the car as far as I'm concerned does everything correctly, no issues there. I'm happy in my blissfully ignorant blinkered world 😂

 

Regarding @Microbe sale of his ultimate pack, we have discussed and I'm aware the additional licence has expired so apart from any accessories, I'm essentially just getting the dongle on the free plan which for now satisfies my requirements. 

£35 plus postage is still cheaper than £51.69 (why not £52) direct from OBDeleven. The price is about right as its a used item plus it goes towards some petrol money for a fellow forum member. 

 

Long may your reign as the forum coding king continue 👑

Thanks again 

Crick

@Crick: Hmm....... OK. If you are purchasing @Microbe OBD11 account - maybe re-evaluate the advantages of renewing the original "Ultimate" license if you ever consider moving from the "free" option. 

 

OBD11 offers 2 x enhanced Plans: PRO and Ultimate. The difference between these plans is the One Cick App (OCA) builder on the Ultimate option. Personally, I view OCAs as a risk, rather than a useful coding feature. If you are of a similar view - then maybe consider upgrading to the PRO option?

 

And as we have discussed in another place - if you do decide to "roll-the-risk-dice" and use OCA's, do so with care and make sure that you create a Backup of the module before you press the OCA "go" button (please)

 

Don 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...