Jump to content

DSG?


Pigpen

Recommended Posts

I dont need any facts, its common sense that how fast you can drive a car depends on many factors not just DSG or manual.

 

You asserted the FACT that DSG is faster, therefore you must have evidence of this?

 

 

Theres so much evidence that your post looks stupid on this forum, there's numerous videos of DSG vs Manual cars did you not do your research?

 

please be more informed, what your trying to say is that if you drive a LaFerrari at 40MPH you can over take it by a ford fiesta, you don't even make sense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Theres so much evidence that your post looks stupid on this forum, there's numerous videos of DSG vs Manual cars did you not do your research?

 

please be more informed, what your trying to say is that if you drive a LaFerrari at 40MPH you can over take it by a ford fiesta, you don't even make sense.

 

Your clearly just refering to 0-60, thats not an indication of how fast a given person can drive a car is it? Please point me to the evidence that shows the same person driving faster in a DSG than a manual. I am not refering to 0-60 time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My two pence worth...

 

DSG is faster at launching and faster at changing - if you are doing a drag race in the same conditions, with the same tyres etc. then it's probably fair to say the DSG will be the quicker of the two.

 

When it comes to the twisty bits, roundabouts, braking and going into and out of corners etc. then it'll be down to the driver behind the wheel - therefore the argument comes down to where the race occurs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your clearly just refering to 0-60, thats not an indication of how fast a given person can drive a car is it? Please point me to the evidence that shows the same person driving faster in a DSG than a manual. I am not refering to 0-60 time.

 

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=DSG+vs+MANUAL+rolling+start

 

 

^ take your pick, i have no issues with manual drivers but to actually believe its AS fast is a lie. if you stay in 1 gear the cars should be equal rolling from 2nd to 6th however the gap will be quite noticeable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally I have driven both ,I found the DSG car my preferable choice this was because the manual box was notchy and I have had my fill of notchy manual gearboxes from VW (my mk6 GTD was like this for 60,000 miles it wasn't like this from new) VW were uninterested in fixing it as this was how they were (the R had 4000 miles on the clock too and was already like it). There are some circumstances that I feel a manual would be better, but that's because I forget that I have got paddles on the steering wheel (Its only been 3 weeks of ownership please be gentle). My issue is with sport mode, it will red line it without fail each time, where as I think this is sometimes a bit excessive i.e. changing up before the red line (but this is where I need to use the paddles more - my fault). I think it will just take time to get used to but I still love every minute of the farting as it changes whilst in sport mode. I think a manual as the change is slightly slower doesn't create such a neat little fart noise. :afro:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally I have driven both ,I found the DSG car my preferable choice this was because the manual box was notchy and I have had my fill of notchy manual gearboxes from VW (my mk6 GTD was like this for 60,000 miles it wasn't like this from new) VW were uninterested in fixing it as this was how they were (the R had 4000 miles on the clock too and was already like it). There are some circumstances that I feel a manual would be better, but that's because I forget that I have got paddles on the steering wheel (Its only been 3 weeks of ownership please be gentle). My issue is with sport mode, it will red line it without fail each time, where as I think this is sometimes a bit excessive i.e. changing up before the red line (but this is where I need to use the paddles more - my fault). I think it will just take time to get used to but I still love every minute of the farting as it changes whilst in sport mode. I think a manual as the change is slightly slower doesn't create such a neat little fart noise. :afro:

 

 

yeah unless your on a track the S mode is pointless, however.. if your not in "S" before you go into manual the exhaust valves will not open.. so RACEMODE> S then MANUAL 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another hilarious DSG/manual thread. DSG lovers certainly seem to really feel the need to quote the 0-60 figures at every opportunity  :cheesy:

 

Generally DSG people prefer DSG and manual prefer manual (otherwise they have to admit they have made the wrong choice). Most people haven't driven both but are happy with what they have so it's not a complete make or break unless you are unable to drive a manual.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forgot to mention DSG is "frugaler" and 21st century tech.

 

I personally went for DSG as I've never had an auto before and feel like being lazy. I certainly wouldn't go for it based on 0.x second faster 0-60 or supposedly better MPG. Neither of which you will take any notice of during 99% of your driving

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...