Jump to content

DSG?


Pigpen

Recommended Posts

was about to say that... doesn't the RS3 handle like a bit of a pig and is boring as well, whereas the R is really well composed and fun?! as for the 35bhp and 80Nm deficit, that is quite a lot, but not huuuuge?!

Handling was poor, needed a rear ARB to sharpen it up, with a stage 1 map it did 0-60 in 3.6 secs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting... I love a good manual vs DSG debate.

 

I like manual but for the first time I'm going to go DSG with my next car. You just can't argue the positives.

 

Funnily enough I saw an advert for a second hand MK7 R. As soon as I read it I thought this guy knows he has bought the wrong transmission, knows everyone (most ) will want DSG so was banging on at length about how manual is best and all the reviews blah blah say it is the best to go manual on the MK7 R. Suites the engine etc. I thoight what a load of rubbish. It made him look foolish and desperate to feel to need to bang on about it so much.

 

If his car was DSG he would have simply said so and moved on rather than write a massive essay on why his manual was the right choice.

I'm even going to find the advert now to show how badly this guy is trying to convince potential buyers that manual is best... Honest.

 

The way he goes on says to me he knows DSG is better but he can't admit it.

Edited by VWGolf_R
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting... I love a good manual vs DSG debate.

I like manual but for the first time I'm going to go DSG with my next car. You just can't argue the positives.

Funnily enough I saw an advert for a second hand MK7 R. As soon as I read it I thought this guy knows he has bought the wrong transmission, knows everyone (most ) will want DSG so was banging on at length about how manual is best and all the reviews blah blah say it is the best to go manual on the MK7 R. Suites the engine etc. I thoight what a load of rubbish. It made him look foolish and desperate to feel to need to bang on about it so much.

If his car was DSG he would have simply said so and moved on rather than write a massive essay on why his manual was the right choice.

I'm even going to find the advert now to show how badly this guy is trying to convince potential buyers that manual is best... Honest.

The way he goes on says to me he knows DSG is better but he can't admit it.

Ohhhhhh kayyyyyyyyyy

 

Looks like all us manual drivers have been well and truly proved wrong. As the man says, "you just can't argue the positives".

Let's go home guys....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting... I love a good manual vs DSG debate.

 

I like manual but for the first time I'm going to go DSG with my next car. You just can't argue the positives.

 

Funnily enough I saw an advert for a second hand MK7 R. As soon as I read it I thought this guy knows he has bought the wrong transmission, knows everyone (most ) will want DSG so was banging on at length about how manual is best and all the reviews blah blah say it is the best to go manual on the MK7 R. Suites the engine etc. I thoight what a load of rubbish. It made him look foolish and desperate to feel to need to bang on about it so much.

 

If his car was DSG he would have simply said so and moved on rather than write a massive essay on why his manual was the right choice.

I'm even going to find the advert now to show how badly this guy is trying to convince potential buyers that manual is best... Honest.

 

The way he goes on says to me he knows DSG is better but he can't admit it.

 

Hello R400! :hello::grin:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello R400! :hello::grin:

 Not sure what that means ????

 

Anyway I found the advert and for what needed to be 2 words "It's manual" has been somehow turned in to nearly 100 words explaining it s a manual and why that is best. Why the need to try to justify his choice of manual.

 

Here it is in the owners words.

 

"3 door bodyshell and manual gearbox (while DSG has its place I've driven both extensively and made my choice based on that experience, the press tend to agree including Autocar who placed the R number 1 of the 50 best cars on sale today and specifically said a 3 door manual was the best configuration...)

"You can have a double-clutch auto with paddleshifts if you must, but driving the manual Golf R is such a joy of control and co-ordination that you really wouldn't want to forgo it" (Independent on Sunday 9/11/14)"

 

3 door manual best configuration lol. OK i'll buy it just on your say so......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting... I love a good manual vs DSG debate.

 

I like manual but for the first time I'm going to go DSG with my next car. You just can't argue the positives.

 

Funnily enough I saw an advert for a second hand MK7 R. As soon as I read it I thought this guy knows he has bought the wrong transmission, knows everyone (most ) will want DSG so was banging on at length about how manual is best and all the reviews blah blah say it is the best to go manual on the MK7 R. Suites the engine etc. I thoight what a load of rubbish. It made him look foolish and desperate to feel to need to bang on about it so much.

 

If his car was DSG he would have simply said so and moved on rather than write a massive essay on why his manual was the right choice.

I'm even going to find the advert now to show how badly this guy is trying to convince potential buyers that manual is best... Honest.

 

The way he goes on says to me he knows DSG is better but he can't admit it.

Strange as your post seems to be doing the exactly the same thing trying to show us that DSG is the best option! It's a personal opinion, you like DSG, I like manual (after driving both) doesn't make either you or me right or wrong! Enjoy your choice and let him sell the car however he wants! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Strange as your post seems to be doing the exactly the same thing trying to show us that DSG is the best option! It's a personal opinion, you like DSG, I like manual (after driving both) doesn't make either you or me right or wrong! Enjoy your choice and let him sell the car however he wants!

 

Not at all. I've always had manual cars. I'm not trying to justify one being better than the other.

What I was trying to point out is DSG owners don't feel to need to justify it where's manual owners seem to have to justify the choice they made. I think that tells its own story. That is just an observation from reading posts on this forum.

 

I'm not trying to stop him selling his car that way lol, it was just an observation I made. I would hazard a guess if the car was DSG it would simply say DSG transmission and move on.

 

And I like both by the way :-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The manual justification follows DSG owners constantly telling manual owners they're wrong for ordering a manual and that DSG is a no brain option (less need to engage as much of your brain to keep the car moving, I'll agree with that, which might be exactly what you are wanting). I'll happily relinquish control on safety options, but not on my driver enjoyment. I simply wouldn't enjoy a DSG as much.

The arguments go around in circles, more engagement/interaction vs slightly faster 0-62 times. Keeping the car in the gear you really want vs tiny incremental official mpg improvements unlikely to be noticed or achieved in the real world.

 

DSG allows anyone to do a stig-type launch from a static start, regardless of their driving ability (might've been something I was keen to impress my mates with when I was 17), and allows for a relaxed drive when you want to do as little as possible. In a congested city this is fine, plodding along on the motorway this is fine. Not what i'm after out of the car.

It is a personal choice, either one results in a great car.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not at all. I've always had manual cars. I'm not trying to justify one being better than the other.

What I was trying to point out is DSG owners don't feel to need to justify it where's manual owners seem to have to justify the choice they made. I think that tells its own story. That is just an observation from reading posts on this forum.

 

I'm not trying to stop him selling his car that way lol, it was just an observation I made. I would hazard a guess if the car was DSG it would simply say DSG transmission and move on.

 

And I like both by the way :-)

Sorry you are justifying it by making these comments about manual owners, especially where you are stating that "manual owners seem to have to justify the choice they made" VWROC is such a small subsection R Drivers yet you feel you can speak for the silent majority! As I said DSG is not a better option it is a different option, just as choosing one colour over another doesn't make it a better colour just better to you. I will enjoy the car without trying to debate which is better, at least we all made the right choice about the car we chose :) BTW look at the above post (KnightK1982 I rest my case!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry you are justifying it by making these comments about manual owners, especially where you are stating that "manual owners seem to have to justify the choice they made" VWROC is such a small subsection R Drivers yet you feel you can speak for the silent majority! As I said DSG is not a better option it is a different option, just as choosing one colour over another doesn't make it a better colour just better to you. I will enjoy the car without trying to debate which is better, at least we all made the right choice about the car we chose :) BTW look at the above post (KnightK1982 I rest my case!)

Yes he's clearly a muppet ;) ^^

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The manual justification follows DSG owners constantly telling manual owners they're wrong for ordering a manual and that DSG is a no brain option (less need to engage as much of your brain to keep the car moving, I'll agree with that, which might be exactly what you are wanting). I'll happily relinquish control on safety options, but not on my driver enjoyment. I simply wouldn't enjoy a DSG as much.

 

The arguments go around in circles, more engagement/interaction vs slightly faster 0-62 times. Keeping the car in the gear you really want vs tiny incremental official mpg improvements unlikely to be noticed or achieved in the real world.

 

DSG allows anyone to do a stig-type launch from a static start, regardless of their driving ability (might've been something I was keen to impress my mates with when I was 17), and allows for a relaxed drive when you want to do as little as possible. In a congested city this is fine, plodding along on the motorway this is fine. Not what i'm after out of the car.

 

It is a personal choice, either one results in a great car.

 

 

i get your point but you can set DSG to manual and keep whichever gear for as long as you so wish?

 

anyway i wish i could choose manual every so often but 90% of the time i prefer DSG.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i get your point but you can set DSG to manual and keep whichever gear for as long as you so wish?

 

anyway i wish i could choose manual every so often but 90% of the time i prefer DSG.

 

It's not quite the same though is it. For one example: sitting at 50mph in 6th and then an overtaking opportunity arises.

 

Slot it in from 6th to 3rd, and away you go with the throttle opening of your choosing (manual)

 

Click (5th), click (4th), click (3rd) on the flaps and away you go (DSG in manual mode) - takes longer, i'm sure it will become instinctive eventually.

 

Plant your foot on the accelerator and see which gear the car decides to be in (DSG in D mode).

 

DSG = letting the car do your thinking for you, one dimensionally (relative to throttle press), for D mode gear changes.

 

Manual = a little more effort and interaction, the car will do what you want it to do, every time, directly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not quite the same though is it. For one example: sitting at 50mph in 6th and then an overtaking opportunity arises.

 

Slot it in from 6th to 3rd, and away you go with the throttle opening of your choosing (manual)

 

Click (5th), click (4th), click (3rd) on the flaps and away you go (DSG in manual mode) - takes longer, i'm sure it will become instinctive eventually.

 

Plant your foot on the accelerator and see which gear the car decides to be in (DSG in D mode).

 

DSG = letting the car do your thinking for you, one dimensionally (relative to throttle press), for D mode gear changes.

 

Manual = a little more effort and interaction, the car will do what you want it to do, every time, directly.

 

Something to consider is that while I'm downshifting using the paddles my foot could be flat to the floor. So while it may (and I'm not convinced it would) take longer the DSG car is still on the gas. A manual car has lifted off. 

 

To be honest it's an endless cycle of pros/cons and arguments. It's all about what you want, not what is "best" or "fastest"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not quite the same though is it. For one example: sitting at 50mph in 6th and then an overtaking opportunity arises.

 

Slot it in from 6th to 3rd, and away you go with the throttle opening of your choosing (manual)

 

Click (5th), click (4th), click (3rd) on the flaps and away you go (DSG in manual mode) - takes longer, i'm sure it will become instinctive eventually.

 

Plant your foot on the accelerator and see which gear the car decides to be in (DSG in D mode).

 

DSG = letting the car do your thinking for you, one dimensionally (relative to throttle press), for D mode gear changes.

 

Manual = a little more effort and interaction, the car will do what you want it to do, every time, directly.

You don't have to click the paddles in a DSG in manual for it to change from 6th to 3rd as in your example, hold the - paddle and it'll drop it I to the lowest gear it can safely manage and then you're away.

 

I've always had a manual, drove both ordered a manual then week later went in and test drove the DSG and ended up ordering one... 0-60 times don't bother me, not fussed about l/c just felt like a different car - I could plod along in D with the car doing the work or I could have it in S or manual and give it some.

 

I felt with the manual I would probably have been giving it some more often - just me though. So thought I'd go DSG see what it has to offer, will I miss the manual possible don't know yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...