Form should follow function. However, sadly, all the flappy paddles you see on VAG and other German cars seem to be flawed in design. Paddles should really be static with the steering column which makes much more sense.
So if they’re not then I simply want them to be as big as possible in terms of giving me more reach. That’s why I chose pinalloy. These seem to be marginally longer reach than most designs and so more useful when pushing on. Still a compromise on the right set up mind.