Yas_Man Posted August 27, 2017 Report Share Posted August 27, 2017 I'm in a bit of dilemma and need some help to decide what to do. We currently have standard dampers with Eibach springs, which is a good combo. My issue is I think the high speed damping in the OEM shocks leaves a lot to be desired, low speed they're good, high speed, not so good. In my eyes I see there are four options. 1) Ohlins Road & Track coilovers, they're the best, most comfortable coilovers I've had, had them on both my Evo X and IX, truly amazing but they're 2K a set for the Golf R, which is too much and I don't know why they're so expensive for our Golfs. 2) KW V3s, everyone rates them very highly, I've had them on my TTRS and thought that they were not very good but this could be as I could not find the right set up. The reason I am considering these is due to the fact they have a blow off valve which lets the shock work faster when they take a fast hit. 3) Bilstein, I see great comments from all that have had them and many say they ride with more comfort than the KWs. 4) Lastly the MSS Sport Kit which has the ability to set ride height, are supposed to offer better stiffness but still maintain a smooth ride. My issue here is that the OEM dampers are still involved. I would welcome feedback from anyone that's had any of the above on their Golf R, both positive and negative comments welcome. Thanks in advance. BTW our R does not have DCC. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteveH Posted August 27, 2017 Report Share Posted August 27, 2017 I had the Ohlins Road & Track coilovers fitted in January by Mick Gardner Racing and am extremely happy with them. I am running on 19" prets and the ride is amazing, comfortable but so controlled through the corners and the level of control over bumpy roads is staggering (probably down to the dual flow valve). I also had the Supapro lower control arm fitted and this in conjunction the Ohlins has helped enormously with any understeer. They are expensive but as you know they are a quality bit of kit and fully serviceable as well. Rsleyum, Yas_Man and SidewindeRj 2 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
andy13 Posted August 27, 2017 Report Share Posted August 27, 2017 If it's any help I drove the Apr stage 3 which has v3's on. The car car felt like it was driving on silk. I had the v1's and hated them, they lasted a week, but leaving speed a side that s3 drove better than the rs3 with similar power I drove on the same day. neilp has bilsteins (b16 I think) and rates them highly. I went out in his golf r when he had it to listen to his bcs exhaust and was again a very very nice feel. I noticed the ride quality more than the exhaust!! Never been out a car equipped with the other make but I know they're raved about in the evo tuning world. id say v3s/ b16s and you will not be disappointed. 👍🏾 Yas_Man and Rsleyum 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Novus Posted August 28, 2017 Report Share Posted August 28, 2017 I run V3 on my R . The ride is excellent and far better than I expected when I swapped from standard shocks and VWR springs Yas_Man 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gfarmer Posted August 28, 2017 Report Share Posted August 28, 2017 I have kw v1 on and they lasted 5 weeks before I sold them as didn't like them at all!! I now have bilstein b16 on and I'm very happy , I've got them set to 7 and there is 10 way adjustment so plenty room for adjustments. I've been on track with them including the Nurburgring and they were amazing Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Yas_Man and dazie00 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yas_Man Posted August 28, 2017 Author Report Share Posted August 28, 2017 This is my issue - lots of people rate the V3s and I'm really tempted but the Ohlins were so good and they do come with top mounts so you pay more but you get more - not that I am desperate for top mounts as I won't run more than -1.5 degrees of negative camber on the car. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteveH Posted August 28, 2017 Report Share Posted August 28, 2017 1 hour ago, Yas_Man said: This is my issue - lots of people rate the V3s and I'm really tempted but the Ohlins were so good and they do come with top mounts so you pay more but you get more - not that I am desperate for top mounts as I won't run more than -1.5 degrees of negative camber on the car. The Ohlins on the Golf don't come with top mounts - that's why I opted for the lower control arms for the extra negative camber and positive castor they add. Yas_Man 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GuyKitch Posted August 29, 2017 Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 Everyone seems to forget VWR actually make some awesome coilovers for the R. These are mine, and must I say, they are absolutely epic. http://www.racingline-performance.com/vwr-tracksport-coilover-suspension There is also a 'StreetSport' kit which is less extreme; probably the better option for daily/frequent road use. This is my full suspension set up. It's ruthless, the car is very very stiff but it makes for an amazing drive. Suspension/Chassis: VWR TrackSport Monotube Coilover Suspension VWR Adjustable Droplinks VWR Adjustable Camber Plates VWR Uprated Lower Engine Mount and Torque Link VWR Uprated Engine Mount VWR Dogbone & Subframe Mounts SuperPro Aluminium Lower Control Arms 034 Motorsport Solid Rear Sway Bar 22mm 034Motorsport Spherical Rear Anti Roll Bar Links SuperPro Front Wishbone Bush Kit KW ‘DCC Delete’ Kit SteveH and SidewindeRj 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan34 Posted August 29, 2017 Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 I'm running B16's, rate them highly. Yet to run them on track but on the road they're great, I think with the dampening tweaked correctly they'll perform well on track. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Obakong Posted August 29, 2017 Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 The Ohlins on the Golf don't come with top mounts - that's why I opted for the lower control arms for the extra negative camber and positive castor they add. This is also my setup. Ohlins + SuperPro LCAsSent from my iPhone using Tapatalk SteveH 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yas_Man Posted August 29, 2017 Author Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 53 minutes ago, Obakong said: This is also my setup. Ohlins + SuperPro LCAs Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Ohlins don't do a kit for the R so does that mean you have GTI kit and have changed the springs on the rear for heavier springs as the rear diff on the R makes it heavier than the GTI? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Obakong Posted August 29, 2017 Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 Ohlins don't do a kit for the R so does that mean you have GTI kit and have changed the springs on the rear for heavier springs as the rear diff on the R makes it heavier than the GTI?GTI kit with no change to to the springs. The ratio of front to rear spring rate is good for the R and doesn't need to be changed imo. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk SteveH 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteveH Posted August 29, 2017 Report Share Posted August 29, 2017 1 hour ago, Yas_Man said: Ohlins don't do a kit for the R so does that mean you have GTI kit and have changed the springs on the rear for heavier springs as the rear diff on the R makes it heavier than the GTI? Its the same kit for the GTI as for the R - works brilliantly, perfectly balanced spring rates with adjustable 20 clicks for rebound/compression with setting guides for road use / twisty roads or track use. An absolute doddle to adjust as you can get to the adjusters with the car on the ground and the wheels in place. Currently running a setting of 7 on the rear and 9 on the front which seems to work really well for fast road use while still remaining really comfortable - it handles amazingly over bumpy B roads when pushing on. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Msportman Posted August 30, 2017 Report Share Posted August 30, 2017 I spoke to Ohlin's at Goodwood. They there isn't a specific kit for the R but they use / recommend the GTI kit. No adjustable top mounts with their kit. I've been out in Neil P's R with B16's......very nice ride....slightly stiffer than the V3's which are as described silky smooth. I've run the next run up the ladder....KW Clubsports with the 3 way damping and adjustable top mounts. These are not super stiff....spring rates are approx. 10-15% stiffer.....valve and damping rates are very similar to V3's but you get the camber adjustment. Again I found once fitted apart from the odd tweak of the compression adjustment I never altered rebound from factory settings as there wasn't a real need and you have to take them off the car from memory. On the MK7 there's very little room to adjust from the top mount side....not enough unless you start cutting metal from that area to get tools in. Again some extra negative camber for added turn and some degree of less understeer if you go too far you'll start scrubbing out tyres and they're a pain on the motorway especially if the NS lane is heavily rutted by HGV's. In isolation unless you are chasing lap times you'll need to put proper track rubber and go big on camber and rear geo adjustment with custom rate hard springs to get rear steer and counteract the understeer. That's what I see regularly at my local tuner Retro Resus who sets up the race cars for VW Cup and MK5 GTI race series. The MK7R is pretty good and I'm not bothered at ultimate lap times but a good V3 or B16 is fine for most with the addition of say Super pro wishbone for some small increase in camber which is at 'sensible' levels that won't destroy road manners. Clubsports are quite pricey but certainly the B16 or V3's are pretty much on par but for those with DCC you'll need the delete kit which is added expense.. SteveH and Yas_Man 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yas_Man Posted August 30, 2017 Author Report Share Posted August 30, 2017 2 hours ago, Msportman said: I spoke to Ohlin's at Goodwood. They there isn't a specific kit for the R but they use / recommend the GTI kit. No adjustable top mounts with their kit. I've been out in Neil P's R with B16's......very nice ride....slightly stiffer than the V3's which are as described silky smooth. I've run the next run up the ladder....KW Clubsports with the 3 way damping and adjustable top mounts. These are not super stiff....spring rates are approx. 10-15% stiffer.....valve and damping rates are very similar to V3's but you get the camber adjustment. Again I found once fitted apart from the odd tweak of the compression adjustment I never altered rebound from factory settings as there wasn't a real need and you have to take them off the car from memory. On the MK7 there's very little room to adjust from the top mount side....not enough unless you start cutting metal from that area to get tools in. Again some extra negative camber for added turn and some degree of less understeer if you go too far you'll start scrubbing out tyres and they're a pain on the motorway especially if the NS lane is heavily rutted by HGV's. In isolation unless you are chasing lap times you'll need to put proper track rubber and go big on camber and rear geo adjustment with custom rate hard springs to get rear steer and counteract the understeer. That's what I see regularly at my local tuner Retro Resus who sets up the race cars for VW Cup and MK5 GTI race series. The MK7R is pretty good and I'm not bothered at ultimate lap times but a good V3 or B16 is fine for most with the addition of say Super pro wishbone for some small increase in camber which is at 'sensible' levels that won't destroy road manners. Clubsports are quite pricey but certainly the B16 or V3's are pretty much on par but for those with DCC you'll need the delete kit which is added expense.. Mate, that's a fantastic write up and I cannot thank you enough . . . . really appreciate the time you've spent to do that for me and anyone else reading this thread. I've gone for the Bilsteins for a few reasons - I love Ohlins but I'm not paying £2200 for a set as the car will never see the track (well maybe) but I have an M4 Competition Pack as my main car, this is the wife's car but I needed something new to play with - which brings me on to reason two. I've had the KW V3s once before on my TT RS and really didn't get on with them but was tempted back to KW by all of the positive comments and the build quality is excellent but I'm keen to try the Bilsteins, as like your good-self, I'm a huge petrol head and pretty vocal on most forums, so I figured as I've not tried them, I'd give them a go. They seem to get great reviews and seem to be a little more road focused, so I've opted for them, plus as it's the wife's car, so I need to keep the ride as soft as possible but with good handling characteristics - the Golf R is brilliant other than the suspension which is pretty wallowy for a fast car. Thanks all for your help, I'll do a write up and install guide once their on - on a side note, I also bought some neoprene shock socks, which I've run on ever car I've had with coilovers and they do an amazing job of keep expensive suspension looking brand new on the grimey roads of old blighty. Thanks once again. SteveH and Msportman 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.