Jump to content

Servicing


Craigyw1984

Recommended Posts

I'm torn between using a very good local indie and a dealership I've not used before next month. 
 
I'd like the VW stamp for the third service, but would rather have a good job done at the independent garage. 
 
Am I devaluing my car going to the independent? 

Not amongst us. It’s well documented how bad some stealerships are - using incorrect oil, not doing a Haldex service properly, ragging customer’s Rs etc. I use a very good indy that I’ve used for over 13 years.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It’s hard to say. If you can find a good independent with a good rep and a history of working on Rs then that could be the way to go. They should be fully qualified and insured and reviews online will tell the story. I like that they let u stand and watch and some will even talk u through what they’re doing and why. 
My cousin is an ex VW tech. Problem he had was underpaid, poor working environment and was always under time pressure, as in he only has a certain amount of time to get a particular job done. The other issue is as high performance as these cars are they are relatively easy to maintain which is why 9 times out of ten at a VW garage you will have an apprentice working on it who isn’t getting paid and is only there for the experience and a free VW jacket, but I suppose they have to start somewhere. 
For me still within warranty I will be sourcing all my service parts via VW and have an ex VW tech do the work with his stamp in the book and a copy of his certificates from VW etc. That and a folder full of receipts will help future proof the car for resale purposes 

This. My local specialist uses ex VW and BMW techs. They saved me a stack of cash (£800) when a SEAT dealership tried nailing me in the keyster fo £1700. Never used that dealership again.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Not amongst us. It’s well documented how bad some stealerships are - using incorrect oil, not doing a Haldex service properly, ragging customer’s Rs etc. I use a very good indy that I’ve used for over 13 years.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Once you find a good garage it a real relief isn't it

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Once you find a good garage it a real relief isn't it

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk


Absolutely mate. The owner tells me what needs doing and why - I know a little bit about oily stuff from watching various tv stuff, (Edd China) and working with our fitters on the cranes. (Lost Power on my crane on the M40 once - found a bag sucked into the mahoosive air intake!) as well as doing my own car years ago (points, plugs and rotor arm - best anti theft device was whipping the rotor arm out!) Dealerships try to bullshit you and I take that as an insult - although one of the service receptionists at my local dealer is an ex VAG tech so might use them again if he’s there.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Absolutely mate. The owner tells me what needs doing and why - I know a little bit about oily stuff from watching various tv stuff, (Edd China) and working with our fitters on the cranes. (Lost Power on my crane on the M40 once - found a bag sucked into the mahoosive air intake!) as well as doing my own car years ago (points, plugs and rotor arm - best anti theft device was whipping the rotor arm out!) Dealerships try to bullshit you and I take that as an insult - although one of the service receptionists at my local dealer is an ex VAG tech so might use them again if he’s there.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I seem to have found a decent VW dealer thankfully, as I have said before they told me they were cleaning my Haldex before I even realised from here that most didn't do that. Also called round 4/5 Indies near me to fit discs and pads all round that I was supplying and none could beat VW Medways estimate... helps that they are 10 mins away too, fingers crossed it stays a good relationship

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh - don’t forget the dealerships that have forgotten to replace people’s oil filler caps! End of the day, there are good and bad main dealers and indies. You shouldn’t feel put off by an indy stamp.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Absolutely! If Dartford VW was my only dealer choice then it would be Indy all the way!

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, slider09 said:

VW Dealer = constants stuff ups, problems, issues and clueless etc :wacko:

Indy Euro Specialist = Problem free servicing and great advice :smiley:


I must be old school, I would prefer to see main dealer history when buying a performance car.

Who is to say an indie will do a better job than than the main dealer? I emailed my local large VAG indie for a quote last year for a service. Tried telling me I need another brake fluid change and the DSG fluid should be changed - when in fact neither were due.

Plus, I’ve seen photos on here of a very well known indie changing brake disks with the callipers dangling loose on the hoses.

I even took my car for its haldex service at year 3 to VW, just for the stamp; then re do it with filter clean a month later.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Degsy said:

I agree with you on this

Main Dealer Service History is what I would be looking for if looking to purchase 2nd hand, together with matching tyres all round.

You do pay extra but it shows you care about your car, I wouldn't go as far as to get tyres, brakes or any additional work done at a main dealer, but regarding routine servicing it speaks volumes.

I've had no issues with my local dealer so far and used them for many years.

My missus is the same with her TT nearly 9 years old now with full Audi History and not even 45k miles

 

It does come down to personal preference but if you are planning on keeping it a while in the end it will have an impact on resale price.

 

Tyres are a good indicator for me too. If folk are prepared to skimp onnthe one thing that connects you to the road what else will they scrimp on? 

 

As with all things there there are good and bad main and independents. Finding one that you are happy with is the key. I do a 90 mile round trip to Doncaster rather than use the indies or main dealer locally. The indi damaged a sill on a TT I had and swore  build it wasn’t them (clear circular dent from a 4 post hoist in the sill)  but eventually agreed to fix it “as a good Will gesture” but they didn’t cause the damage. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That’s mad!!

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Not if you know my friend, that is a GT350 and he has had it since new, don't think he will ever get rid of it... Also the garage is very well known in the GT-R world as the owner Sly is a Nissan master tech

 

Also it's near me so he gets the pleasure of my company too

 

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 01/01/2019 at 08:21, Andy1a2b said:

 

Tyres are a good indicator for me too. If folk are prepared to skimp onnthe one thing that connects you to the road what else will they scrimp on? 

 

As with all things there there are good and bad main and independents. Finding one that you are happy with is the key. I do a 90 mile round trip to Doncaster rather than use the indies or main dealer locally. The indi damaged a sill on a TT I had and swore  build it wasn’t them (clear circular dent from a 4 post hoist in the sill)  but eventually agreed to fix it “as a good Will gesture” but they didn’t cause the damage. 

Interested to hear that you go to Doncaster, Andy. I’ve used the local dealer for quite a while, and luckily had a technician there assigned to my car who’s as much of a car enthusiast as I am. His attention to detail is fantastic and I’ve been incredibly happy with the work done. A detailing enthusiast, he would guard my car key to ensure that I didn’t get a dealer wash ‘n’ swirl. So I’ve had no issues until....

 

Sadly he’s moved to another marque, and immediately my experience plummeted. A combative service manager and ham fisted technicians left me with a crack in my front grill after the car spent several days in the Workshop. Replaced, but grudgingly, with ‘goodwill’ lacking, I’m unlikely to return, as this wasn’t the only gripe that I had. So I’m interested to hear why you go to Doncaster, and you’re thoughts on their service.

 

I guess it goes to show, it doesn’t matter if it’s Indy or Dealer, what matters is the attention to detail and work ethic of the person working on your pride & joy. 

 

48F54836-EF91-4EB3-B5B4-4FC131A70BDE.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is anyone else confused over the complete variation of the labelling of the different service regimes or is it just me? I know that we have "minor", "major", but now have been told I have a "variable" due as I'm on the long life service regime (>10'000/year), but according to my service book last one done was an oil change inspection so it should be a major? Also the car "service" indicator lists inspection (which I take to read as major) and oil change (minor...?) - why can't they simply pick one set of nomenclature and stick to it!!

 

Plus now I'm at ~39K, so think I'm also due DSG, brake fluid and haldex... this is going to be an expensive couple of months....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 hours ago, LouCyffer said:

Interested to hear that you go to Doncaster, Andy. I’ve used the local dealer for quite a while, and luckily had a technician there assigned to my car who’s as much of a car enthusiast as I am. His attention to detail is fantastic and I’ve been incredibly happy with the work done. A detailing enthusiast, he would guard my car key to ensure that I didn’t get a dealer wash ‘n’ swirl. So I’ve had no issues until....

 

Sadly he’s moved to another marque, and immediately my experience plummeted. A combative service manager and ham fisted technicians left me with a crack in my front grill after the car spent several days in the Workshop. Replaced, but grudgingly, with ‘goodwill’ lacking, I’m unlikely to return, as this wasn’t the only gripe that I had. So I’m interested to hear why you go to Doncaster, and you’re thoughts on their service.

 

I guess it goes to show, it doesn’t matter if it’s Indy or Dealer, what matters is the attention to detail and work ethic of the person working on your pride & joy. 

 

48F54836-EF91-4EB3-B5B4-4FC131A70BDE.jpeg

 

I’ve been happy with the VW dealer in Doncaster and never felt they were ripping me off price wise. The service manger took me through the services required over the next 5/6 years too. Was pleased to find out the engine has a timing chain not a belt so nothing to replace there if I keep the car long term ( a strong possibility unless something exceptional comes along) . The R is way cheaper to service than my C63 and even cheaper than the Diesel Passat Alltrack I had for 4 years. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...