veewiz Posted August 1, 2014 Report Share Posted August 1, 2014 So what your saying while on your moral high horse, is that breaking any speed limits or having any fun is a big no no. With that logic why didnt you buy a diesel? Im genuinly adking here, i am honestly confused? The only explanation is that you sir, are either a troll, a hypocryte or an idiot. Im thinking possibly all 3... So, to be clear, your contention is that anyone who advises against attempting to intentionally induce oversteer on public roads 1) doesn't like spirited driving 2) is boring 3) doesn't like to have any fun in their car, and finally consequently 4) should have bought a diesel? Plenty of people get their money's worth out of an R without going to such irresponsible extremes, and in any event, as long as they get what they want out of it, why should they justify their purchase to others according to another arbitrary forum user's standards? It shouldn't really need to be said, but there are plenty of ways to enjoy a performance car on a public road without adversely increasing risk to other road users (or yourself). Presumably you draw that line somewhere too, unless you think for example a highspeed J turn on a public highway can be defended as long as you're driving a performance car, in which case any and all reckless driving can be justified in the pursuit of "fun" at all costs? What has seemed to get lost here is that in no way I have encouraged dangerous driving in anyway. If the OP had said something like "Im really trying hard to power slide past my local school to impress all the kids, any advice?" then sure, but he didnt. Personally I never drive fast in built up or pedestrian areas. In fact it was only today I had some old bird overtake me in a 30 area as I was sticking to the speed limit. My argument is that its perfectly safe to have fun in your car, attempting power slides and breaking the speed limit. I 100% agree that this is always a risk and is rare that it can be done safely. I just find it irritating when the forum police start getting on their high horses for no reason and come out with bone comments like "make sure its on a track," because at the end of the day we all break the speed limit and are a bit naughty, hence why we all bought high performance cars. Back to my original statement, if you don't do this, then why not buy a diesel! I agree that common sense clearly needs to be applied when evaluating road safety. A friend of my family is a traffic cop and takes a common sense approach to overtaking (i.e. don't sit alongside someone on the motorway for 5 miles crawling past them, if you have to get up to 85 to make a quick, safe pass, do so). I'm sure some people would deem my driving unsafe in some situations - I know people who believe overtaking is unsafe full-stop, regardless of the distance or speeds involved (and by that i mean overtaking on a single carriageway road). Everybody is making a judgement, drawing a line in a different place. That said, putting the vehicle into a skid, however controlled the driver believes it to be, is probably on most peoples' "not safe on a public road" lists, regardless of the circumstances. Mine included. If you want to push that hard, book a track day. Isn't that a more appropriate place? A lot of performance car enthusiasts would say there's no point having a car like the R unless you're going to take it on a track, on the grounds that it is never appropriate to push the car to its ultimate limits on a public road, and if you're not going to drive it to the edge at some point, why buy it? With regards to the book a track day for oversteer, there are even some circuits that consider deliberate oversteer/drifting too dangerous for track days. You only have to look at some 'ring videos on You Tube to see what damage an oversteering BMW can do. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
veewiz Posted August 1, 2014 Report Share Posted August 1, 2014 Doesn't deliberately over steering slow you down and reduce vehicle control anyway? It has no use on the public roads in my opinion. Im pretty confident that when spotted by traffic it would considered dangerous driving. ..and yet there are plenty of videos of Harris doing it on public roads in numerous countries! Some even in German cars on French roads, a dangerous combo Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyR Posted August 1, 2014 Report Share Posted August 1, 2014 Though I think we have established the fastest way from A to B is to be a complete nutter! For me the stopwatch is irrelevant it is what we define as fun getting from A to B and it is a personal choice. A 110bhp RS2000 on skinny 1970s rubber is fun in a very different way than a high tech 4WD 300bhp modern hatch. Which is more fun? Only you can decide. Whilst the Golf R has a more lively drive than its S3 cousin its Haldex 4WD system is never going to behave like a 4WD Impreza or Lancer and certainly nothing like an M135i if the driver yearns some low speed sideways fun. As suggested it is going to need to be provoked at speeds only realistically attainable on a track or in snow. Hoping for it to be a bit tail happy "like the good old days" just seems a bit naive and lacking in understanding of the vehicle IMHO. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trickz Posted August 2, 2014 Report Share Posted August 2, 2014 in the wet with traction control on fully I've found a few times where the back end seams to completely take all the power and swing out until opposite lock is applied it then seams the fronts take more power and pulls me out of it(private road of course)but in the dry apart from lift off oversteer it's rock solid and to be honest that's how I want it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
random_tangent Posted August 4, 2014 Report Share Posted August 4, 2014 So what your saying while on your moral high horse, is that breaking any speed limits or having any fun is a big no no. With that logic why didnt you buy a diesel? Im genuinly adking here, i am honestly confused? The only explanation is that you sir, are either a troll, a hypocryte or an idiot. Im thinking possibly all 3... So, to be clear, your contention is that anyone who advises against attempting to intentionally induce oversteer on public roads 1) doesn't like spirited driving 2) is boring 3) doesn't like to have any fun in their car, and finally consequently 4) should have bought a diesel? Plenty of people get their money's worth out of an R without going to such irresponsible extremes, and in any event, as long as they get what they want out of it, why should they justify their purchase to others according to another arbitrary forum user's standards? It shouldn't really need to be said, but there are plenty of ways to enjoy a performance car on a public road without adversely increasing risk to other road users (or yourself). Presumably you draw that line somewhere too, unless you think for example a highspeed J turn on a public highway can be defended as long as you're driving a performance car, in which case any and all reckless driving can be justified in the pursuit of "fun" at all costs? What has seemed to get lost here is that in no way I have encouraged dangerous driving in anyway. If the OP had said something like "Im really trying hard to power slide past my local school to impress all the kids, any advice?" then sure, but he didnt. Personally I never drive fast in built up or pedestrian areas. In fact it was only today I had some old bird overtake me in a 30 area as I was sticking to the speed limit. My argument is that its perfectly safe to have fun in your car, attempting power slides and breaking the speed limit. I 100% agree that this is always a risk and is rare that it can be done safely. I just find it irritating when the forum police start getting on their high horses for no reason and come out with bone comments like "make sure its on a track," because at the end of the day we all break the speed limit and are a bit naughty, hence why we all bought high performance cars. Back to my original statement, if you don't do this, then why not buy a diesel! I agree that common sense clearly needs to be applied when evaluating road safety. A friend of my family is a traffic cop and takes a common sense approach to overtaking (i.e. don't sit alongside someone on the motorway for 5 miles crawling past them, if you have to get up to 85 to make a quick, safe pass, do so). I'm sure some people would deem my driving unsafe in some situations - I know people who believe overtaking is unsafe full-stop, regardless of the distance or speeds involved (and by that i mean overtaking on a single carriageway road). Everybody is making a judgement, drawing a line in a different place. That said, putting the vehicle into a skid, however controlled the driver believes it to be, is probably on most peoples' "not safe on a public road" lists, regardless of the circumstances. Mine included. If you want to push that hard, book a track day. Isn't that a more appropriate place? A lot of performance car enthusiasts would say there's no point having a car like the R unless you're going to take it on a track, on the grounds that it is never appropriate to push the car to its ultimate limits on a public road, and if you're not going to drive it to the edge at some point, why buy it? With regards to the book a track day for oversteer, there are even some circuits that consider deliberate oversteer/drifting too dangerous for track days. You only have to look at some 'ring videos on You Tube to see what damage an oversteering BMW can do. No doubt. I wasn't really trying to endorse oversteer, just making the point that pushing to the limit is something which is far more appropriate on the track than on the road, and if regularly getting the back end out is something you want to do, then you're better off finding a circuit where such behaviour is allowed rather than attempting it on a public road. Obviously most people on track days want to go quick, and I'm sure most of us know that breaking traction is not the fastest way around a circuit. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
towney Posted August 4, 2014 Report Share Posted August 4, 2014 in the wet with traction control on fully I've found a few times where the back end seams to completely take all the power and swing out until opposite lock is applied it then seams the fronts take more power and pulls me out of it(private road of course)but in the dry apart from lift off oversteer it's rock solid and to be honest that's how I want it. Lucky you got that private road part in there, or the forum police would be on your ass, saying how much of a disgrace to your country you are lol Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RichT Posted August 6, 2014 Report Share Posted August 6, 2014 The car was designed primarily to drive fast on roads. It has clearly been purposely designed to add a bit of oversteer for balance and enjoyment and was heavily marketed as such. There are times and conditions for restraint and there are times and conditions to enjoy the car as our maker intended I don't own this car to impress other people, nor piss them off for that matter. The car is for my pleasure and the further away I am from others while I take that pleasure the better If a track day car is what you want, then there are much better suited cars, quicker and for much less money! If it's a day to day runabout with designed in cheeky thrills and a bit of oversteer, I believe you would be hard pushed to beat the Golf R Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
veewiz Posted August 16, 2014 Report Share Posted August 16, 2014 Bump bump! The Chris Harris review with the R in oversteer mode is now live and links are in the Review sticky Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bromers Posted October 20, 2014 Author Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 Eventually managed to get the R to oversteer - tight 2nd gear corner, very wet, no TC, chuck it in and boot it. Could feel the power moving front and rear - felt a bit like my old Integrale. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FBF Posted October 20, 2014 Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 Lol wtf is with this thread. Im getting an R so it sticks to the road like it's on rails along with some great acceleration. There is loads of enjoyment from coming out a corner imo that you have just tared it round when any other car would have failed miserably. If i wanted a car to kick out id have gone for a GTI or a BM and enjoyed such pleasures as a hobby on the track. And we all have our "idiotic" moments in the car but common sense always rules and dictates the limits of the road/our limits. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
harryhackenbacker Posted October 20, 2014 Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 Lol wtf is with this thread. Im getting an R so it sticks to the road like it's on rails along with some great acceleration. There is loads of enjoyment from coming out a corner imo that you have just tared it round when any other car would have failed miserably. If i wanted a car to kick out id have gone for a GTI or a BM and enjoyed such pleasures as a hobby on the track. And we all have our "idiotic" moments in the car but common sense always rules and dictates the limits of the road/our limits.[ Good for you M4 whatever are slated for lack of soul and anal control My favourite lets face it He is a Star http://www.volkswagen-r.de/#!golf7R/video Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
belfast col Posted October 20, 2014 Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 I was hoping the Golf R would be a bit tail happy with the 4WD systems ability to shift all the power to the rear. Pushing really hard into a dry quite tight 2nd gear corner got a little understeer but then just masses of grip and very little sideways movement. Going to have to going super fast or try in wet conditions to get this car to move around With TC off I assume the 4WD system still works by applying power to the wheels with most grip ? Anyone experienced any oversteer ? Would be nice to have the ability to tweak the bias front and back - just like the good old days Looking forward to snowy days as per VW test day videos I know I'll get a torrent of abuse but if you want/ enjoy over steer buy a BMW or try a Toyota GT-86 (awesome fun but slow). I've had many BMW's and love them. Proper ass out fun that you wont get from 4x4. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
veewiz Posted October 20, 2014 Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 I was hoping the Golf R would be a bit tail happy with the 4WD systems ability to shift all the power to the rear. Pushing really hard into a dry quite tight 2nd gear corner got a little understeer but then just masses of grip and very little sideways movement. Going to have to going super fast or try in wet conditions to get this car to move around With TC off I assume the 4WD system still works by applying power to the wheels with most grip ? Anyone experienced any oversteer ? Would be nice to have the ability to tweak the bias front and back - just like the good old days Looking forward to snowy days as per VW test day videos I know I'll get a torrent of abuse but if you want/ enjoy over steer buy a BMW or try a Toyota GT-86 (awesome fun but slow). I've had many BMW's and love them. Proper ass out fun that you wont get from 4x4. R8 is 4x4 and ass out!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stubsy Posted October 20, 2014 Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 I've found the back end to be livelier compared to the mk6 Not ass out hooligan, but a controlled moment of chaos...... (Has to be wet and Tcs off) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bromers Posted October 20, 2014 Author Report Share Posted October 20, 2014 I was hoping the Golf R would be a bit tail happy with the 4WD systems ability to shift all the power to the rear. Pushing really hard into a dry quite tight 2nd gear corner got a little understeer but then just masses of grip and very little sideways movement. Going to have to going super fast or try in wet conditions to get this car to move around With TC off I assume the 4WD system still works by applying power to the wheels with most grip ? Anyone experienced any oversteer ? Would be nice to have the ability to tweak the bias front and back - just like the good old days Looking forward to snowy days as per VW test day videos I know I'll get a torrent of abuse but if you want/ enjoy over steer buy a BMW or try a Toyota GT-86 (awesome fun but slow). I've had many BMW's and love them. Proper ass out fun that you wont get from 4x4. Got an E36 M3 for those kicks Just saying it is just possible - normally just safely under steers every where. Treat them roughly and you can just about do it. TBH I am staggered by the amount of grip but nothing better than to feel you're fully in control using the throttle Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.