Jump to content

Turbo flutter / compressor surge during acceleration.


Golphin

Recommended Posts

Merry Christmas fellow Golfers 😁

 

I have 7.5R GPF Wagon running Revo Stg 1 (99ron tune) with Revo Turbo elbow, Revo muffler delete, Revo turbo hose and most recently an R600 intake.

 

Prior to the genuine R600 I was running the pikey R600 set-up with all the accompanying mods above. 

 

Over the last few days I have noticed during acceleration mid range the turbo flutter /compression noise (not the let-off woosh) during acceleration.  It is loud enough that my wife even asked what it was.   I can hear the suction of air nice and clearly which is what I like and the let-off noise. 

 

Just wondering if this is normal or if I should be getting anything checked.  I couldn't hear it on the previous setup. Car is fully serviced using premium oil and only done 16k miles.

 

Be glad to hear if anyone else has this or knows anything that can be advised. 

 

Is it possible to have "too much" air trying to be forced in to the turbo by having an oversized intake??

 

If it's nothing to worry about then I'll enjoy the extra mechanical noises 😉 

 

Have a great Christmas holiday. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 7
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

44 minutes ago, samm said:

The r600 flows much better than the pikey mod so I wouldn't be overly concerned. If there was an issue you'd have an epc light on.

 

I'm running the ramair intake, mine is very loud on acceleration 

Thanks @samm is the noise you're referring to the flutter?

Intake noise/whooshing is great, it's the flutter I want clarified. 

Cheers. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some minor flutter/surge is present on number of tunes once you have full intake on. 
 

I’ve had it come and go with various tunes/mods. Had it with APR stage 1 HO with R600. Went away when I added GFB DV+, boost pipe kit and swapped to APR closed intake. 
 

When I then went stage 2 it returned again and I swapped to OEM+ software and gone. This is years ago. I am now APR stage 2 again last few years and with open intake and no issues with it on latest software. 
 

I personally didn’t like it and made me feel like it was bad for turbo but plenty of tuners have commented over the years that no issues with it and my turbo still going strong 7 years tuned on early revision 2014 turbo. 
 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been researching this to death as if late as I have the same "problem" in my Cupra. In a nutshell the IS38 turbos spool super fast. When tuned this is actually faster that the wastegate can operate. Some tuners will say different, but the truth is that under 3500RPM the head can't flow more than 1.4 bar (words from Niki G). Some tuners will set the boost to max throughout the rev range and ask the wastegate to manage the boost level. However I believe our cars spool much faster than the wastegate can handle tuned, especially with mods which induce greater flow. The actual solution is to tweak tunes in the form of reducing boost and possibly some other things which are too technical for me to explain. This is why you will see that certain revisions of APR/Revo tunes either cause or stop the issue from occuring. It is the tune in most cases and the only real way around it is to have a custom tune or get lucky with a off the shelf.

 

So, that's the solution, but how bad is the problem ? "On throttle surge" appears to be "the worst kind" because of the continuous back and fourth in a short space of time - according to the interweb and general consensus 

 

What I don't think there has been a conclusion to is to how relatively bad this actually is. The objective answer would say out of all turbo failures, how many were due to compressor surge, or in a controlled test what was the % wear due to accelerative compressor surge. Of course we don't have that, rather the consensus being some the early is38 revisions were not balanced correctly.

 

So, where does this wear sit relatively. Well purely going off research so subjective as hell, there appear to be two types of compressor surge. The light touch which is audible but you don't feel, and heavy which is audible and you feel and see a drop in revs/bucking like a s misfire.. my view, is that it will increase wear and any surge should be avoided (light either by tune or Downshifting, heavy by getting the issue fixed). Here's my personal view on the light wear; (1 being low 10 being high)

 

1) Leaving your car on for 10 minutes to babysit the turbo after a hot run 

2) Using slightly the wrong type of coolant as a top up 

3) Using the cheapest brand of oil

4) Using full lock despite the whine

5) Using supermarket fuel on a performance engine

6) Light "no feel" compressor surge 

7) Downshifting whilst accelerating in a DSG

😎 Completely missing an oil change

9) Accelerating hard on a cold engine

10) Heavy compressor surge

 

For me I stop at cheap oil, so everything after needs to be addressed :). 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

APR revised stage 2 software using my car as the benchmark for UK customers.

I went to Awesome when APR were here in the UK developing stage 3 and revising the stage 2 software following issues around managing boost fluctuations and waste-gate control..

It was subtle dumping of boost under partial throttle more noticeable under part load when accelerating on the motorway. I reported this issue back in 2016/7 on here after the map was revised. I was driving in the car whilst technicians immediately found the issues and causes. The map has been tweaked twice since then to smooth out boost modulation but with the R609 I’ve always had the odd whoosh and occasional flutter normally coming off throttle at low speed when you can hear it.

The map is super smooth no surge and I’ve also track my car since I’ve owned it new in 2016. Were now 2022 and it’s been perfect as has the IS38 so I’m not worried at all. I may go further to a TTV3 or V5 if I feel the need but may use those funds towards a different car. Trouble is new cars are nightly expensive and when you’ve got a car with the full upgraded items ie stage 2 BBK, Ohlins why bother??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...