Jump to content

Golf R FL vs RS3 FL vs A45 vs Focus RS vs Type R [emoji4]


8YARWY

Recommended Posts

6 minutes ago, Bob said:

I'm happy with my stage 1 and a bit estate R. Need the space which none of the others can provide. We are lucky to have such choice in the uber hatch category. A tuned second hand R is a true bargain and pound for pound perhaps the best car out there. The estate perhaps even more so. 

 

 

Can't disagree with that!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't understand why pretty much every major motoring publication insists on using the manual Golf R in speed comparisons against other hot-hatches, many of which have DSG.

 

Ah well, I'm not going to get bent out of shape about it.  The instant I saw the line up and the manual box I knew the Golf was toast.  I suppose it sort of works to my favour in a round about way because johnny-AMG will be very confused when a DSG JB1 Golf Estate won't drop back on a slip road pull.  Mr RS3 might even get a fright.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What gets me is where is the cupra 300? M140i xdrive? Audi S3? If these head to heads put the golf R in because its the top golf so to speak then where is the astra/gtc vxr? Etc...
The golf is the least powered of that line up and yet with a dsg box it could have been a different story? Not by much maybe come the finish line but would have definatly off the line.
I still think the Golf R is thrown up into the higher crowd when it shouldnt be. Lets not forget that realistically it is exactly the same near on as an S3 so where is the S3 in these tests? Surely it makes sense to show what the RS3 has over the S3.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What gets me is where is the cupra 300? M140i xdrive? Audi S3? If these head to heads put the golf R in because its the top golf so to speak then where is the astra/gtc vxr? Etc...
The golf is the least powered of that line up and yet with a dsg box it could have been a different story? Not by much maybe come the finish line but would have definatly off the line.
I still think the Golf R is thrown up into the higher crowd when it shouldnt be. Lets not forget that realistically it is exactly the same near on as an S3 so where is the S3 in these tests? Surely it makes sense to show what the RS3 has over the S3.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Agreed

They could’ve waited a while then substituted the Focus RS with its specially designed overheating 4wd system for the BMW......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, andy86r said:

Shame they never put an auto S3  in there too, its like they purposely choose cars to avoid. 

 

More cock-up than conspiracy, I expect: it's what cars they could assemble most conveniently at the time. And maybe they thought the S3 was so similar to the R that there was no point having both. So lack of credibility added to their test, which won't bother them as they're a car-broking site and have no rep. as such to protect. It seems to me that Autocar and Evo (for example), who do, don't let that stop them making similar mistakes. We can but complain, as vociferously as possible, in an effort to get them to do things more intelligently.  :evil:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Steve_3939 said:

I dont think its a case of what should have been in it or not. I dont think the Golf should have been in it. Its a hot hatch not a uber hot hatch anymore. 

Now the R400 would have been a different story. 

Really, can you explain more why you think the golf or audi S3 shouldn't have been in it? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Steve_3939 said:

I dont think its a case of what should have been in it or not. I dont think the Golf should have been in it. Its a hot hatch not a uber hot hatch anymore. 

Now the R400 would have been a different story. 

I disagree.....the R does punch itself well into Uber hatch territory but at a comparative bargain price baseline.

Remember 4WD even at 300bhp just 10 years ago would be considered a real weapon. 

Go back to the short wheel base 300bhp Quattro then considered a super car by many.

Hot hatches in my eyes would be a PP GTI, VXR Astra, 308GTI, ( Cupra is closer to the Honda in layout and power).

 

The 8V RS3 even now start at £35-38k on a 2014-15 car. Many new spec'd cars would have RRP north of £50k+ so pretty good residuals but still a £15k+ loss to the first owner. Comparatively a good spec 2014 15 R will command early £20's. Still a hefty loss to the first owner unless they bought with a heavy discount.

It makes a good spec DSG R great value to tune to 400bhp over a similar RS3 where the price point starts at £35k+ then pumping a further £6-£8k to map, FMIC, sort understeer with the heavier front end and possibly uprate brakes. It takes the to 440+ bhp ....nice but it's quite an expensive path in the end for a 2014 car.

 

Back to R IMO it still outshines many rivals and is still great value....shame they just didn't get a DSG car in this test.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, andy86r said:

Really, can you explain more why you think the golf or audi S3 shouldn't have been in it? 

the bench mark moves on with the years. as post above stated "300bhp just 10 years ago would be considered a real weapon" that's right, maybe even 3-4 years ago, but these days the bench mark is a lot higher than 300 brake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Steve_3939 said:

the bench mark moves on with the years. as post above stated "300bhp just 10 years ago would be considered a real weapon" that's right, maybe even 3-4 years ago, but these days the bench mark is a lot higher than 300 brake

That is true, I wonder if vw and audi though have capped these powers for a reason, maybe with the better handling than the rs3 a standard golf say pumping out 390bhp would put the rs3 to shame and possibly loose out on rs3 sales due to a cheaper car being just as quick and slightly more nimble on a circuit. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, andy86r said:

That is true, I wonder if vw and audi though have capped these powers for a reason, maybe with the better handling than the rs3 a standard golf say pumping out 390bhp would put the rs3 to shame and possibly loose out on rs3 sales due to a cheaper car being just as quick and slightly more nimble on a circuit. 

they haven't capped it to save the Audi face, the R400 project shows that. the problem is they are not ploughing money into developing a more powerful car after the diesel gate shit and they are just tweaking the current set up

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would just like to add I am not on here to knock the Golf. I owned a MK6 R and got the MK7 shortly after release, not too many people on here can claim to have owned both, and very few can claim to have had a deposit on the imminent release of the R400 which I indeed did for over a year until they finally admitted it wasn't going to happen. I got my £500 back and went off and got the A45

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Steve_3939 said:

I dont think its a case of what should have been in it or not. I dont think the Golf should have been in it. Its a hot hatch not a uber hot hatch anymore. 

Now the R400 would have been a different story. 

 

I have come to accept a 7R is in a lower league than the RS3 and A45. As it should be, considering the price differential. I agree with you the benchmark is higher now ever since the A45 launched in 2013.

 

5 minutes ago, andy86r said:

That is true, I wonder if vw and audi though have capped these powers for a reason, maybe with the better handling than the rs3 a standard golf say pumping out 390bhp would put the rs3 to shame and possibly loose out on rs3 sales due to a cheaper car being just as quick and slightly more nimble on a circuit. 

 

The MQB and EA888 is a great platform and has high potential at tuning. VAG might be holding the 7R back to market it (and S3) to fill the void between a hot-hatch (GTI, VXR, ST) and a hyper-hatch (RS3, A45) to meet a certain price point. Does not make sense to challenge the RS3 and A45, end of the day sales matters to them most.

 

IMHO, the 7R's closest competitor is the RS, in-terms of price/performance. In the video, with both these cars being manual makes more sense. The Golf looses in straight line speed but wins in build and ride quality (test drove a lot of both cars before buying my R). And the is no way I would trade my subtle looking R for a street racer look RS.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, BornEvil said:

 

I have come to accept a 7R is in a lower league than the RS3 and A45. As it should be, considering the price differential. I agree with you the benchmark is higher now ever since the A45 launched in 2013.

 

 

The MQB and EA888 is a great platform and has high potential at tuning. VAG might be holding the 7R back to market it (and S3) to fill the void between a hot-hatch (GTI, VXR, ST) and a hyper-hatch (RS3, A45) to meet a certain price point. Does not make sense to challenge the RS3 and A45, end of the day sales matters to them most.

 

IMHO, the 7R's closest competitor is the RS, in-terms of price/performance. In the video, with both these cars being manual makes more sense. The Golf looses in straight line speed but wins in build and ride quality (test drove a lot of both cars before buying my R). And the is no way I would trade my subtle looking R for a street racer look RS.

 

 well said.

its the R400 that should be in that group fighting with the big top 2 not the Golf R as it is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...