Jump to content

Persuade me not to cancel my R order....


blower

Recommended Posts


I’m on the babyBMW forum so I can gain some knowledge on the M2 - one chap there said the A45 was the worst car buying decision he’d ever made. He really hated it. For the tech, the Merc can’t be beaten but I think the R is probably a better drive from what I’ve seen.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

A45 was my favourite car. I’m itching to get back in one.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

BMW M2 is a great car in the dry, as is the M3 and M4.
Get a touch of rain/sleet/snow etc or a damp morning and you have to drive them with caution and dont blip the throttle to hard.
I like to get in my golf and just drive it and not care much about the weather.
So if we lived in a med climate id have one for sure but not for me in the UK.
The new generation will be 4WD as per the new M5, so will worth a look when they come out but well above the price of the Golf R.
IMO the golf R is a good all rounder with enough speed/acceleration for most.
 
i got my Base Golf R DSG on lease 18months ago and its costing me £205 pm.
For that price its a no brainer!
 
You could debate this topic all day as its down to personal choise and utlimatly your finances!
 
What ever you coose to buy enjoy it!
 
 
£205 that's an insane price!! Well done I genuinely don't think you can get more bang for your buck in a new Car!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stick with the R as you will be getting the version thats the most refined of the MK7 run and by that the best experience. 

 

The views from the Mercedes with the narrow windows and the awful dash (i know this is subjective) put me off straight away when went to view and cannot see the new model doing anything different as think like the dash even less. 

 

And there is the new model punt,  which I took on the MK7 and it was a gamble that worked out well for me, but have to admit was quite nervous and that extended well into the first year of ownership as all the niggles filled the forums (you will definitely be the same as you know you will be taking a punt) until most of us settled and realised that on the whole the MK7 was a solid series (of course there is always the unlucky one, but overall is what stating) 

 

The MK7 then had a few lifts, optional equipment became standard and quality of equipment improved also and we back to the present R being the result of all the little tweaks, lifts and adjustments and about the best the MK7 will be if all functioning as designed. 

 

So save yourself joining another Q and the worry of having made the right decision as the Mercedes forums pages are filled with early niggles and just go for the R, its a truly cracking car, universally stated as from the many professional and owner reviews . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forget the fact its 'just a Golf' for years the Golf cuts through all the class barriers, the A class is just an A class its not an SL or S class, I would not spend £40k on an A class I just don't like the looks or the Merc, exterior or interior (I hate the iPad look).  That said I paid £31K and list was below £40k so not a problem for me.

In short drive them both again and buy the one you like.  Forget the waiting time (I waited 9 months for my new Mustang (sold it after 6) and 6 months for the Golf).  For me the Merc was not a consideration, but each to their own, just make sure you buy the car you like the most, waiting just adds to the excitement!! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Matrix2020 said:

Forget the fact its 'just a Golf' for years the Golf cuts through all the class barriers, the A class is just an A class its not an SL or S class, I would not spend £40k on an A class I just don't like the looks or the Merc, exterior or interior (I hate the iPad look).  That said I paid £31K and list was below £40k so not a problem for me.

In short drive them both again and buy the one you like.  Forget the waiting time (I waited 9 months for my new Mustang (sold it after 6) and 6 months for the Golf).  For me the Merc was not a consideration, but each to their own, just make sure you buy the car you like the most, waiting just adds to the excitement!! 

 

Love the Bullitt Mustang though think British roads/parking would be a challenge but if just had the spare cash for a car purely for myself to run around in that Bullitt Mustang would be on that wish list :) 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Boj27 said:

For 36k you could get a great spec RS3. Or for an extra 2-3k, a facelift RS3. Hold their value much more than an R, much much better engine, better interior. You’ll never tire of the sound either.

 

Can't really get that price range on a 2017 or newer, just checked Audi approved (only place i would buy one as i'd never buy private or from a non audi dealer for this expense of a car).

 

Cheapest 2017 quattro RS3 is £43k, ya can forget knocking much off that price as well - maybe up to £1k off but that's all they will move if you're lucky. 

Realistically you are looking at 45k for something circa 10k miles and just over a year old with a few options.  (I don't like buying more than a year old)

That's a bit out of my price range. I agree, they do sound absolutely awesome though!

 

But regardless, i've decided 36k is too much to spend on a Golf R and I will chop some of the options down at the very least.

 

I'll be looking at a Mercedes A250 on the weekend to get an idea of what the A35 will be like, it will need to blow me away (interior and feature wise) for me to drop the Golf R order.....i've read a few reviews which indicate this model at least, is no where near as much fun to drive as the R, also concerns me that a couple of reviews have said the gearbox is no match for 7 speed DSG in the R (not as refined and more dim witted).

 

The fact its a brand new engine ,new gearbox and new insanely tech heavy MBUX infotainment/instrument system does all concern me - how reliable is this system!. One good thing the Golf R has going for it, is it's pretty late in it's life cycle - bugs have been worked out, engine parts have been refined. DSG 7 gearbox has only been out a couple of years but it looks to be solid and well refined.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For 36k you could get a great spec RS3. Or for an extra 2-3k, a facelift RS3. Hold their value much more than an R, much much better engine, better interior. You’ll never tire of the sound either.

RS3s seem to be really overpriced against the age of them. Not convinced of their handling on the pre facelift models either.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Boj27 said:

For 36k you could get a great spec RS3. Or for an extra 2-3k, a facelift RS3. Hold their value much more than an R, much much better engine, better interior. You’ll never tire of the sound either.

Very well said...:):afro:....I guess I's go down this route if I couldn't wait any longer to be honest...I love the Golf R but RS was very tempting for me....although I fell a bit short $$$-wise...Lucky for me I only had to wait a day or two for my R...if I had to wait a long time, and if I saw a reasonably high spec Audi RS3..I'd go the RS 3 if the spec was high enough..and within budget :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very well said...:afro:....I guess I's go down this route if I couldn't wait any longer to be honest...I love the Golf R but RS was very tempting for me....although I fell a bit short $$$-wise...Lucky for me I only had to wait a day or two for my R...if I had to wait a long time, and if I saw a reasonably high spec Audi RS3..I'd go the RS 3 if the spec was high enough..and within budget 

Except 16 reg RS3s are still up for in excess of £36k - vastly over priced for a car that doesn’t handle as well as the R.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to say that A35 is no looker. The golf may be a bit understated for what it is but the Merc is a bit munting.
 
Hmm tough choice. S3 Saloon?

It’s got the looks but that’s possibly about it. I’ve been torn between the M240i and M2. The 240 is possibly a better everyday car but I can’t ignore the fat arches and engine noise of the M2.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites


It’s got the looks but that’s possibly about it. I’ve been torn between the M240i and M2. The 240 is possibly a better everyday car but I can’t ignore the fat arches and engine noise of the M2.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I can't ignore the fact it is a Beemer... really not a fan of their styling one bit

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...