Baldchap Posted May 2, 2019 Report Share Posted May 2, 2019 57 minutes ago, gregozedobe said: It's worth checking every now and then that the faraday pouches are still doing their job - I've read a few reports now that some faraday pouches' linings wear out and are no longer effective at blocking signals. Best to be sure, then you (and your car) are safe [pun intended] Shocking punnage!!!! 😂 gregozedobe and SpursMadDave 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuffinR Posted May 10, 2019 Report Share Posted May 10, 2019 I bought one of these and received it yesterday, it works perfectly, obviously it’s only been installed for 24 hours but so far no problems whatsoever. I got the non-tap version (the one schmee150 had in his Focus) that has an accelerometer that engages the lock after being stationary for 3 minutes and disengages as soon as the fob is moved. Officially that version isn’t on sale but I emailed them and they were happy to supply one for the same price. It wasn’t all plain sailing though, I didn’t bother to actually check my fob type before I ordered and just assumed a 7.5 R would be the latest (type 3). It isn’t it’s type 1 so if you order one, choose type 1 VW fob. Luckily it’s the same device and it’s just the padding that secures it into the fob that changes and you can peel the padding off the type 3 and turn it into a type 1. Phew! Parky-SPP 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SpursMadDave Posted May 10, 2019 Report Share Posted May 10, 2019 I bought one of these and received it yesterday, it works perfectly, obviously it’s only been installed for 24 hours but so far no problems whatsoever. I got the non-tap version (the one schmee150 had in his Focus) that has an accelerometer that engages the lock after being stationary for 3 minutes and disengages as soon as the fob is moved. Officially that version isn’t on sale but I emailed them and they were happy to supply one for the same price. It wasn’t all plain sailing though, I didn’t bother to actually check my fob type before I ordered and just assumed a 7.5 R would be the latest (type 3). It isn’t it’s type 1 so if you order one, choose type 1 VW fob. Luckily it’s the same device and it’s just the padding that secures it into the fob that changes and you can peel the padding off the type 3 and turn it into a type 1. Phew!Nice, a much cheaper option that Ghost etc, a clever product.One question, what happens if you are stuck in traffic say for 3 minute? Does the key turn off while in the car and you get the warning on the dash saying key not present? I would I imagine they have coded it so if it is 'paired' with the car then it doesn't go to sleep but I just wondered if this was the case?Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuffinR Posted May 10, 2019 Report Share Posted May 10, 2019 So I’ve had the same thought, what if I’m stationary for 3 minutes, will it shut off? Well I can confirm that whilst travelling the motion of the car keeps it active but I will test it over the weekend by sitting still with the engine running and see what happens. You would think it would have some intelligence in it to spot an active exchange between fob and vehicle but we’ll see. I’ll report back with my findings. SpursMadDave 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SpursMadDave Posted May 10, 2019 Report Share Posted May 10, 2019 So I’ve had the same thought, what if I’m stationary for 3 minutes, will it shut off? Well I can confirm that whilst travelling the motion of the car keeps it active but I will test it over the weekend by sitting still with the engine running and see what happens. You would think it would have some intelligence in it to spot an active exchange between fob and vehicle but we’ll see. I’ll report back with my findings.Yeah that's my thinking too but just curious... Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GrumpyOldMan Posted May 11, 2019 Report Share Posted May 11, 2019 12 hours ago, MuffinR said: So I’ve had the same thought, what if I’m stationary for 3 minutes, will it shut off? Well I can confirm that whilst travelling the motion of the car keeps it active but I will test it over the weekend by sitting still with the engine running and see what happens. You would think it would have some intelligence in it to spot an active exchange between fob and vehicle but we’ll see. I’ll report back with my findings. Not trying to rubbish the product rather consider corner cases.: When the engine is running and you move the key too far away the car flags key out of range but carries on running. I guess if the fob doesn't detect motion then the key turns off an you'll have the same experience. So you will have an alert on the car I guess then you start making vigorous movement in your seat to turn the fob back on again? So as long as worse case is people think you are freaking out seems workable. With stop start your engine probably wont be on for 3 minutes while stationary - guess you will need to check ignition on but engine stopped scenario as well. I guess worse case would be the car wont restart until you start jerking around in your seat? Will be interested in impact on key fob battery life - I'm guessing the first you will know of a low battery is when the chip starts to malfunction which if you are driving would be keyfob lost I guess. With a borderline battery - Impact on Kessy of a fob constantly dropping off then coming back - some sort of logic failure condition perhaps/unknown state/key gets out of sync? Sensitivity - its made to detect walking which is quite jerky motion wise - will it detect slow motion ie crawling along at a steady pace, gentle stop? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuffinR Posted May 11, 2019 Report Share Posted May 11, 2019 Well the other half and I have spent quite a lot of time today trying to trick the keyless protector into locking out the car in the wrong situation and we haven’t been able to do it at all. The accelerometer on the device is extremely sensitive, the tiniest nudge resets the lockout counter on it. Normally the key lives in my pocket on a key ring but today I detached it and placed it in the little key holder below the auto hold button in the centre console. Under normal driving there is no problem, we drove for 20 minutes or so and then parked up with start-stop disabled, set the stop watch going on the wristwatch and timed away 3:30 (to be sure), absolutely nothing, the vibrations of the engine running keep the key alive. We considered that the sound system may also be a problem (I have dynaudio) because we could feel the vibrations from the speakers so we muted that and stopped the engine as well, still no “key missing” warning after 3:30 and the engine restarted on command. We did some shopping and tried again this time with start-stop enabled, when we next parked up start-stop kicked in and we started timing (radio muted), unfortunately we couldn’t reach 3 minutes at this point, the start-stop always restarted the engine after 1.5 - 2.0 minutes due to high power drain or cabin temperature. If I think about it I’m not sure I’ve ever had start-stop kick in for longer than 3 minutes, it’s always restarted due to power drain or the car in front moving off so maybe that’s why 3 minutes is the magic timeout number? Just to be sure when we got home I left the key on the roof of the car, locked with keyless and waiting 3:30, sure enough the protector had activated and the car wouldn’t open. I nudged, literally rocked the key fob in its case on the roof (don’t want to scratch the car!) a fraction and the key reactivated and the car opened. We also tried doing all of this with the key in my pocket and had no problems either, the key is so sensitive that even trying to sit still I think breathing keeps it alive! Certainly while driving the movement of foot from brake to accelerator will definitely keep it alive if momentum didn’t. The one test we haven’t done is to just sit in the car with the ignition off and see if it gets disabled. It’s hard to say whether or not the protector is actively communicating with the car, I would suggest not, it’s just very sensitive to movement. I’ve only had it 2 days so maybe over time I’ll discover some situations that can trick the unit but for now it is flawless. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SpursMadDave Posted May 12, 2019 Report Share Posted May 12, 2019 Well the other half and I have spent quite a lot of time today trying to trick the keyless protector into locking out the car in the wrong situation and we haven’t been able to do it at all. The accelerometer on the device is extremely sensitive, the tiniest nudge resets the lockout counter on it. Normally the key lives in my pocket on a key ring but today I detached it and placed it in the little key holder below the auto hold button in the centre console. Under normal driving there is no problem, we drove for 20 minutes or so and then parked up with start-stop disabled, set the stop watch going on the wristwatch and timed away 3:30 (to be sure), absolutely nothing, the vibrations of the engine running keep the key alive. We considered that the sound system may also be a problem (I have dynaudio) because we could feel the vibrations from the speakers so we muted that and stopped the engine as well, still no “key missing” warning after 3:30 and the engine restarted on command. We did some shopping and tried again this time with start-stop enabled, when we next parked up start-stop kicked in and we started timing (radio muted), unfortunately we couldn’t reach 3 minutes at this point, the start-stop always restarted the engine after 1.5 - 2.0 minutes due to high power drain or cabin temperature. If I think about it I’m not sure I’ve ever had start-stop kick in for longer than 3 minutes, it’s always restarted due to power drain or the car in front moving off so maybe that’s why 3 minutes is the magic timeout number? Just to be sure when we got home I left the key on the roof of the car, locked with keyless and waiting 3:30, sure enough the protector had activated and the car wouldn’t open. I nudged, literally rocked the key fob in its case on the roof (don’t want to scratch the car!) a fraction and the key reactivated and the car opened. We also tried doing all of this with the key in my pocket and had no problems either, the key is so sensitive that even trying to sit still I think breathing keeps it alive! Certainly while driving the movement of foot from brake to accelerator will definitely keep it alive if momentum didn’t. The one test we haven’t done is to just sit in the car with the ignition off and see if it gets disabled. It’s hard to say whether or not the protector is actively communicating with the car, I would suggest not, it’s just very sensitive to movement. I’ve only had it 2 days so maybe over time I’ll discover some situations that can trick the unit but for now it is flawless.Really good write up, it seems so far then to be a great little device and seems to work exactly as expected. This appears to be the way a lot of new keyless devices will work and is sensible and will hopefully avoid scanners being used on people's driveways. I guess it doesn't stop someone scanning it while you are say walking away from your vehicle but o decide or system is going to be 100% in all situations.Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oryxgolfr Posted May 12, 2019 Report Share Posted May 12, 2019 Fair play to schmee for his success but his voice does grind after a few minutes Parky-SPP and Raiden 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuffinR Posted May 12, 2019 Report Share Posted May 12, 2019 UPDATE: If you hadn’t already guessed it, I can confirm that the keyless protector works by cutting the power to the key fob (from the design I think it isolates the negative terminal). Just washed the car, I left the keys on the side in the house out of range to stop the pressure washer from triggering the door lock sensor and when I was finished I pressed the lock button on the key fob (without picking it up) and nothing. I had to pick up the key fob to activate it again and then the buttons worked as expected. A minor inconvenience but if you often just tap the buttons on your fob without moving it then this probably isn’t for you. MMCW, SpursMadDave and GrumpyOldMan 2 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tildascot Posted May 13, 2019 Report Share Posted May 13, 2019 I have just bought the newer version that requires you to 'tap' the device twice approx 1 second apart to enable the key fob. I am on my second one (first one was replaced) and I can't get this one to work, so the replacement is about to go back. It doesn't matter how I tap the keyfob, it won't unlock the car (keyless or by pressing the unlock button). The effect is the same as removing the battery! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SpursMadDave Posted May 13, 2019 Report Share Posted May 13, 2019 I have just bought the newer version that requires you to 'tap' the device twice approx 1 second apart to enable the key fob. I am on my second one (first one was replaced) and I can't get this one to work, so the replacement is about to go back. It doesn't matter how I tap the keyfob, it won't unlock the car (keyless or by pressing the unlock button). The effect is the same as removing the battery! That doesn't sound so goodSent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuffinR Posted May 13, 2019 Report Share Posted May 13, 2019 6 hours ago, tildascot said: I have just bought the newer version that requires you to 'tap' the device twice approx 1 second apart to enable the key fob. I am on my second one (first one was replaced) and I can't get this one to work, so the replacement is about to go back. It doesn't matter how I tap the keyfob, it won't unlock the car (keyless or by pressing the unlock button). The effect is the same as removing the battery! I believe the no tap version is the newest device as Schmee150 said in his review it wasn’t on sale at the time but was coming soon. When I ordered my no tap version it wasn’t available on the website, I emailed them and they were happy to supply a no tap variant. I just checked the website again and noticed that they now have a drop-down on the order page to select the type that you want. Your experience reflects my suspicions of the two tap device, it’s clunky to use and clearly unreliable. I watched the usage video for the two tap and having to halt your gate for 0.5s and then continue before double tapping with 1s between taps just seems to ask for too much new behaviour from the end user. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GrumpyOldMan Posted May 13, 2019 Report Share Posted May 13, 2019 On 12/05/2019 at 18:16, MuffinR said: UPDATE: If you hadn’t already guessed it, I can confirm that the keyless protector works by cutting the power to the key fob <<snip>>. I had to pick up the key fob to activate it again and then the buttons worked as expected. Thanks for taking time to test and share and, of course, for the update, very interesting. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tildascot Posted May 18, 2019 Report Share Posted May 18, 2019 An update to my review: The first 'tap' version that I received didn't work and I contacted the UK reseller (3D AutoKeys) and they sent a replacement. The replacement didn't work either and this also had to be returned (at my cost). After returning the second one, they tested it and found it to be faulty. At this point, they noted that the first one also didn't work but that it was physically damaged. This was news to me and they suggested that it may have been damaged by fitting (although they noted that it was "possibly .... as they are so delicate,"). At this point, they organised a refund for the purchase price (but not the cost of returning the two devices) So, in my experience there may be a 50% failure rate or a 100% failure rate and, even if you get a "good one", the fragility of the device means that it may apparently get damaged beyond repair when fitting. Overall, the experience had cost me two lots of return postage and I have no faith in the efficacy nor the robustness of the product. Definitely can't recommend. gregozedobe, goodbadboy and GrumpyOldMan 1 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.