Jump to content

Auto Engine Stop / Start


Sparky-R

Recommended Posts

I leave it on all the time in mine.  Have done since Sep 14.  But I mainly do long runs, so cutting and restarting a warm engine with a fully charged battery, is little or no overhead on systems.  

 

A tickle of the throttle is all that's needed to stop it cutting out prematurely: Likewise a firm press on the brakes is all that's needed to cut out engine sooner.  In traffic ACC fires up engine as soon as car in front moves, and that's clever.   

Works for you as you say because you do long runs but anyone who does short trips its a killer of components,i have a friend who has a new Nissan quashqai and its had a new battery in its first few months and had the AA out to it 3 times and the chap said it was the stop start he gets lots of call outs because of it .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Works for you as you say because you do long runs but anyone who does short trips its a killer of components,i have a friend who has a new Nissan quashqai and its had a new battery in its first few months and had the AA out to it 3 times and the chap said it was the stop start he gets lots of call outs because of it .

...buts that's a Nissan!  I have confidence that VW will have tested the systems and associated component lives thoroughly in a range of duty cycles.  Germany can get very cold I n it's homeland cities so start/stop needs to perform.

 

do the folk who worry about start stop also worry about launch control effects on associated components?  It's the same principle.  Anyone not using LC due cost of wear scare? 

 

Starters, alternators and batteries are all consumable components.  Is there any empirical evidence to suggest that VW systems lives are compromised? I guess VW has a lot of data.....and must be mindful of potential issues.  Following dervgate, it's product and legal folk would have also required quantitative analyses around component life and predicted failure rates, and also balanced this with its profitable spares business.

 

i guess it's about later owners in cars, lives for all these systems.  I don't keep mine that long, but still take great care of my cars, so no worry.

 

Id be more concerned about LC than stop start, were I of that mind.   Compare a battery/starter motor price to a DSG rebuild.....peanuts 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I too switch mine off as part of my startup routine. I'd much rather prefer if the button function was reversed so if you wanted it, you would turn it on.

 

On the odd occasion, when I was unfamiliar with the car and forget to turn it off, I would find it cutting the engine out at the most inappropriate of times. Approaching roundabouts/junctions where you spot a gap but the gap is soon gone because of the delay in restart.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...buts that's a Nissan!  I have confidence that VW will have tested the systems and associated component lives thoroughly in a range of duty cycles.  Germany can get very cold I n it's homeland cities so start/stop needs to perform.

 

do the folk who worry about start stop also worry about launch control effects on associated components?  It's the same principle.  Anyone not using LC due cost of wear scare? 

 

Starters, alternators and batteries are all consumable components.  Is there any empirical evidence to suggest that VW systems lives are compromised? I guess VW has a lot of data.....and must be mindful of potential issues.  Following dervgate, it's product and legal folk would have also required quantitative analyses around component life and predicted failure rates, and also balanced this with its profitable spares business.

 

i guess it's about later owners in cars, lives for all these systems.  I don't keep mine that long, but still take great care of my cars, so no worry.

 

Id be more concerned about LC than stop start, were I of that mind.   Compare a battery/starter motor price to a DSG rebuild.....peanuts 

Yes get your point ,but what i am saying is if i had stop start enabled it would be used dozens of times a day ,how many people use LC dozens of times a day,

my car was 3 weeks old and i got a low battery warning and had to charge overnight to get up to full charge again.

im sure if the car manufacturers had a choice they would not fit the device to a performance car ,i think it was brought on by the tree hugging EU brigade .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Personally, I was all ready to hate it, and turn it off on every journey. But I actually think it works very well. I do not find it at all invasive, if you only lightly brush the brakes the engine will keep running in most cases. Also when you come to pull away, you don't even need to touch the throttle, just slightly lightning the pressure on the foot brake is enough for it to start again. So I will be leaving mine on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you put the car in race mode, it deactivates the start/ stop as does flicking the dsg box into sport.

 

when I'm approaching a roundabout and there is a lot of traffic I just nudge it into sport as I'm slowing down then if I do need to stop momentarily the start stop doesn't kick in.

 

it also doesn't seem to activate if the outside temperature is below a certain figure which looks like around 5 degrees presumably to protect the battery and other components.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

it also doesn't seem to activate if the outside temperature is below a certain figure which looks like around 5 degrees presumably to protect the battery and other components.

 

I dont think it is to do with the outside temp. more of the engine temp and what load there is when idle, i.e if the aircon is running , heated mirrors / seats etc etc. Or even when the steering angle is too great. 

 

You can see why by looking at the Start / Stop info menu on the infotainment. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As well as engine temp etc, it won't operate if the interior cabin temp is outside of the climate control set temp range, or if you have the demisters switched on. It's pretty fussy about when it will operate. In early days, before I decided to switch it off every journey, I found I was actually glad when it wouldn't kick in because one or more of the condition requirements were not met. That signalled the end of our short relationship.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have left mine one starting from last week and try to not be so hard on the brakes so it doesnt activate unintentionally. Careful driving feathering the brakes and throttle has netted me quite a bit more MPGz , im seeing if i can maintain that this week .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Disabled with OBDELEVEN :) Hate stop/start myself but I do understand why some like it.

 

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Just awaiting delivery of OBDeleven then it will be bye-bye stop/start FOREVER, lol.... along with the equally hated headlight washers.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Works for you as you say because you do long runs but anyone who does short trips its a killer of components,i have a friend who has a new Nissan quashqai and its had a new battery in its first few months and had the AA out to it 3 times and the chap said it was the stop start he gets lots of call outs because of it .

 

Really interesting to hear your argument.....

 

So is this forum awash with Golf R drivers who have ruined their cars through leaving stop/start activated? I've never come any of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really interesting to hear your argument.....

 

So is this forum awash with Golf R drivers who have ruined their cars through leaving stop/start activated? I've never come any of them.

Most owners probably don't need to use stop start dozens of times in a day like I do .jesus the battery has needed charging already in only 4 weeks of ownership .good job I've not been using stop start

 

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...