Jump to content

Tyres


goodbadboy

Recommended Posts

47 minutes ago, Charles M said:

Think I have a choice for my 18s of

 

Goodyear Eagle F1 A3

Conti Sport 6

Mich PS4

 

Goodyear the quietest which appeals quite a bit . Am I wrong thinking this way?? 

Those were my choices when I changed from the Bridgestones. I went PS4 and have been pleased with them, but didn’t dislike the Bridgestones as much as others as I like a bit of fun. The tyrefitters had all of them in stock but were in no doubt that the PS4 were the best tyre for the R. I don’t notice roadnoise at all...it’s never something that occurs to me. Aircon and satnav are more intrusive. Tyrewear has been fast though - I’ve just had another look at them and they’re probably 75% worn after 10k miles, most of which has been very dull motorways. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, Booth11 said:

 

Nearly a year since last time the worm can was properly opened.  It’s overdue.  😁   A good thread with in depth information and debate. 

 

 

I'll just describe my experiences with oversteer & understeer on a wet skidpan - note that this was with near new Conti 5Ps F & R:

 

I found it extremely difficult to get my hearse to oversteer regardless of what I did.  I tried esp on, tolerant and off, power on, power off, handbrake on (just stopped with all 4 brakes on in full ABS mode), excessive speed into the corner.  The only way I could get some oversteer was approaching one particular corner corner a bit too fast, then applying full power in M1 at the apex of the corner, and even then it mostly wanted to grip & go and wouldn't oversteer consistently.  Other RWD cars were drifting all over the place in the same session, and going so much slower I had to keep stopping as I caught up to them every lap or so.  Both the instructors were at a loss as to how to get my R to drift (but were very impressed at its ability to get its power down and go).  I have seen the videos of people drifting their Rs in the snow on a snowy carpark, but observed that the ones I saw were not trying to follow a set track (like I had to on the skidpan), but rather were simply focussed on getting their cars sideways in a general direction (so of less value as a predictor of what happens on an actual road with other traffic)

 

Based on this I would rate the AWD system on the Mk7.5 Gold R as being calibrated to strongly understeer at the extreme rather than oversteer.  If someone wanted to experiment I suppose you could fit two spacesaver tyres to the rear axle and see what happens on a wet skidpan ( I recall seeing a video of someone fitting 4 spacesavers to a Merc E63 and having great fun drifting around a racetrack).

 

I believe I am much more likely to want to do an emergency braking stop in a straight line than suffer unexpected oversteer when cornering or swerving (based on what has happened to me in the past and what I see on the roads these days).  In these circumstances having your best tyres on the front will give you your best stopping distance (particularly on wet roads) and I am confident my cars ABS and ESP systems will help keep my car under control.  Having said that I always replace my tyres well before they get near the legal limit so I never run with near bald tyres anyway.  In fact I usually replace my car tyres dues to age, not wear (old tyres go off and lose grip, particularly wet grip).

 

I guess my message is that there are a number of factors to consider when choosing where to put your best tyres, and a blanket "one size fits all" recommendation may not be the optimum for all the different circumstances that apply to different people and different cars. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good article this probably been quoted on here many times but it explains a bit about the haldex system and how it will not allow oversteer except in the extremest conditions which is why i personally put my new tyres on the front where they will stop me better, and i have no fear of the back coming out, much as i would actually like it too...

 

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.digitaltrends.com/cars/2015-vw-golf-rs-4motion-awd-system/amp/

 

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, AgentFruit said:

Those were my choices when I changed from the Bridgestones. I went PS4 and have been pleased with them, but didn’t dislike the Bridgestones as much as others as I like a bit of fun. The tyrefitters had all of them in stock but were in no doubt that the PS4 were the best tyre for the R. I don’t notice roadnoise at all...it’s never something that occurs to me. Aircon and satnav are more intrusive. Tyrewear has been fast though - I’ve just had another look at them and they’re probably 75% worn after 10k miles, most of which has been very dull motorways. 

 

Road noise.... Did you notice any with the Bridgestone and now don't notice any, or is it you just don't notice any now as well as before the PS4? At present the tyre roar from my Bridgestones is overly intrusive. Maybe the estate is more susceptible?? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Charles M said:

 

Road noise.... Did you notice any with the Bridgestone and now don't notice any, or is it you just don't notice any now as well as before the PS4? At present the tyre roar from my Bridgestones is overly intrusive. Maybe the estate is more susceptible?? 

I’m in an estate too. Nice to meet you :) I  can’t remember tbh...I don’t think I thought oh wow where did the noise go, more wow that’s a firmer ride. I had Bridgestones on my Subaru and they were v noisy, so anything on the three R’s I’ve had have been joyously quiet. I’ve had three sets of Bridgestones previously on the Rs, and always wondered why people complain about noise, but I guess it depends what you’re coming from. The decibel ratings are the best way to compare though, surely? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, AgentFruit said:

I’m in an estate too. Nice to meet you :) I  can’t remember tbh...I don’t think I thought oh wow where did the noise go, more wow that’s a firmer ride. I had Bridgestones on my Subaru and they were v noisy, so anything on the three R’s I’ve had have been joyously quiet. I’ve had three sets of Bridgestones previously on the Rs, and always wondered why people complain about noise, but I guess it depends what you’re coming from. The decibel ratings are the best way to compare though, surely? 

Agree 100%

second set of Bridgestone's here and absolutely fine

ive had virtually every other brand of tyre on my 30 previous cars over last 17 years and the Bridgestone is absolutely fine especially when I got them at £60 each from a mate!

 

Very solid predictable tyre,

I suspect the people that cry about them cant drive for shit haha

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, thanksabunch said:

Agree 100%

second set of Bridgestone's here and absolutely fine

ive had virtually every other brand of tyre on my 30 previous cars over last 17 years and the Bridgestone is absolutely fine especially when I got them at £60 each from a mate!

 

Very solid predictable tyre,

I suspect the people that cry about them cant drive for shit haha

 

The only thing I’ve really disliked about the various Bridgestones I’ve had has been braking in the wet. That’s provided a few moist moments. Otherwise they’ve all been fun...slippy, yes, but on the Scooby every day was like a great day out on a kart track, and in the R it’s so predictable that it’s hard to do anything dramatic. Tbh I didn’t like the PS4 when I first had them as the ride was so jittery compared. I do appreciate being able to stop though, so I’ll have them again for the sake of safety if nothing else. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Juicetin said:

The road noise alone would be enough for me to change the Potenzas. When mine needed doing I went for Goodyear Asymmetric 3 and they are SO much quieter.  

They’re relatively cheap compared to PS4 too aren’t they? Can I put Goodyear on the back and PS4 on the front, or would I need to change all four?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, thanksabunch said:

Agree 100%

second set of Bridgestone's here and absolutely fine

ive had virtually every other brand of tyre on my 30 previous cars over last 17 years and the Bridgestone is absolutely fine especially when I got them at £60 each from a mate!

 

Very solid predictable tyre,

I suspect the people that cry about them cant drive for shit haha

 

 

What has commenting on the noise from them got to do with driving ability?? I've had my licence for 30 years and reckon I am an OK driver. Not the best, not the worst. Of course when I was younger, I thought I was great and everyone else couldn't drive for shit. 

 

I think maybe my 5 series just had better sound proofing, as does my wife's Scooby. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Charles M said:

 

What has commenting on the noise from them got to do with driving ability?? I've had my licence for 30 years and reckon I am an OK driver. Not the best, not the worst. Of course when I was younger, I thought I was great and everyone else couldn't drive for shit. 

 

I think maybe my 5 series just had better sound proofing, as does my wife's Scooby. 

 

Chaps, let’s keep it nice. No swearing in front of a lady ;)  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...