Jump to content

Golf R FL vs RS3 FL vs A45 vs Focus RS vs Type R [emoji4]


8YARWY

Recommended Posts

5 hours ago, Mainframe said:

VW have never paid the power or best handling (read track) game since every generation of Golf.  There was always a 205 Gti etc snapping at the heels for handling.  There was always another RS competing in the power and torque stakes.  Generation by generation.  There will always be an A45 etc to up the power and fiscal ante.    Or an in-house RS3 to take it up a class.

 

But the Golf will keep on appealing to the same sort of buyers who value the broader range of dynamic and ownership and everyday reliable driving appeals that the cars have offered (OK Gen 4 excluded).   And as put, 350 hp plus is easily attained for little cost and risk.    

 

 

 

I agree.

Budget came into what I 'wanted ' to spend as I have other priorities....extension to name one thing.

I could have gone to £50k 2 years ago on the 8p RS3 or put in an order for an M2 but for me the Golf I bought was perfect in spec and was at a price point I wanted to spend. I knew it was quite tuneable as well and quickly worked out I could attain A45 or RS3 performance thereby saving £23k I had spec'd a new RS3.

Knowing me I'd probably spend a further 4-6k on top for modding the RS3!

 

Im glad I saved the money as I can put it towards my build and later on consider a new MK8R or used current RS3 in a few years.

 

The R does exactly what it says on the tin and for most of us is still a serious piece of kit in comparison to most mainstream cars.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A decent specced golf R through drive the deal is about 32k,cheaper than the focus RS and slightly more than the type R GT model.

Video reviews are almost always based on track times or drag races,or how much fun they are on a B road,simple matter of the fact is unless you're very rich and buying one of these cars purely as a toy these videos are irrelevant,the A45 and RS3 are way way out of the golfs, focus and type r price range,the golf and audi are the only under stated cars of the 5 with interiors that i could live with every day,the focus RS interior feels and looks very cheap,infact worse than my fiesta ST,the civic type R is OTT on styling and the A45 although has nice interior isnt a very day to day thing,dont like the look of them neither.

 

A stage 1 map will see a DSG golf R more or less keep with the RS3 and a45,and if thats what you can do with £500,whats the justification for the 60k pricetags.On the road,unless you're both great racing drivers,youre not going to see the difference in cornering ability,as anybody stupid enough to be taking these cars around corners on the public road at the limit wont have their cars for long.

 

To me the audi dash looks very bland,almost like a renault megane,and the bmw 240 looks horrible on the rear end.

 

The Golf,as it has done for decades,ticks every box it needs to for day to day life...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For a bit of foolery this is ok, but for anything beyond that pretty pointless. 

 

The RS3 is the quickest in a straight line? really? O, the shock. 

 

The automatic gearboxes are quicker than the manual ones? really/ O, the shock. 

 

You get the drift so will stop there. 

 

The Ford, VW and Type R are the most comparable if specced them up like for like, so you would choose one of these on preference of AWD over FWD and then whether you want your car to be be a decent day or a performance ride, or with the Golf R, both :) 

 

The Mercedes has more power and costs a lot more and even then I would still choose the R and that leave the RS which I love and would trade my R in without hesitation for, maybe get divorced in the process as try to convince wife that the huge uplift in house expenditure was worth it, but love the new FL version of the RS and in that grey too. 

 

But in the real world, the R is a justifiable selection because its competitive in performance and price with its peers, and out on the road is not just about the drag race, the R is a car you can genuinely live with 100% of the time and more so if a family man who has to be dutiful around his personal need for some performance in his ride - Took 5 adults, including two very elderly to a meal in total comfort Sunday, went for a very satisfying burst through some open A roads up North yesterday. 

 

So for some tomfoolery and to see a nice selection of performance across a wide band and colours to, great video, for any real usefulness, none! 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's a nicer looking car than the focus, civic and merc in my opinion. Yes marginally slower than a few there and bit more than Audi. I would only swop my golf for the Audi in that range.
 
 


I agree, the looks not the price put me off the RS3. Focus....nope. Merc=mini taxi.

In the real world none of this matters. It's down to the driver and in any drag race, I'd win!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...