Jump to content

Destroyed Rear Diff


scott-o

Recommended Posts

Morning,

 

I was getting ABS faults on the rear left intermittently (which knocked a whole load of other modules out), i replaced the sensor and the faults cleared for 4 days and then after id been driving enthusiastically it sounded like there was a wheel bearing noise from the rear and thinking back i'd been hearing this noise on and off for a few weeks.

 

I got the car up in the air and check the diff oil, nothing came out, massive alarm bells along with all the fault lights coming back as i was pulling the car into the garage. I put around 900ml in and it still didnt reach the fill hole some how, which rang further alarm bells. There was no noises and all was well for around 10 miles and then bad noises started to occur which i knew was definitely the diff.

 

I got the car into my mates garage and no oil came out of the diff when the drain plug was removed and 0 signs of any leaks. The oscilloscope waves for the senor were reading correctly so we knew the sensor wasnt at fault and neither was the reluctor ring on the wheel bearing. I decided to bite the bullet and buy a second hand diff (facelift diff from a 2018 car, revision J) and the haldex pump and ecu were swapped over from my previous diff as we knew the history of those and that they were good.

 

God news is its all swapped over and working better than ever but we decided to strip the old diff to figure out where the oil was going and what sort of damage we could see. Pictures below, enjoy!

 

We got the cups out and the oil flowed out:

 

49135784688_99edbd4a25_c.jpgIMG_20191127_190551 by Scott Osborne, on Flickr

 

The reason the oil wasnt draining out, blocked solid with sludge!

 

49135783518_296cd706bb_c.jpgIMG_20191127_191623 by Scott Osborne, on Flickr

 

The diff:

 

49135784438_6b96ee14f2_c.jpgIMG_20191127_190909 by Scott Osborne, on Flickr

 

Pinion Side:

 

49135784588_9c354ab3c2_c.jpgIMG_20191127_190849 by Scott Osborne, on Flickr

 

Now it really doesnt seem like this is a common thing to occur and all the techs i've spoken to havent ever heard of it happening and bearing in mind the diff units are supposed to be 'sealed for life' from VW i.e. dont require the diff oil changing, it looks like a quality fault in the diff. It looks like the crown wheel on the diff just hasnt been treated properly (or at all) and its just ground itself away to the stage where the teeth have broken away completely, which is when i started getting the abs sensor faults as these were skipping over.

 

Has anyone else seen something similar occur?

 

Cheers,

 

Scott

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Norm4n said:

Wow, just out of interest have you owned the car from new and if so how has it been used i.e. launches, doughnuts, drift etc?

 

 

 

Bought second hand (I'm the third owner) and I've got all the mechanical sympathy in the world but that can never be said for certain for the previous owners as I don't know them, although the car itself is great condition and definitely been looked after by them.

 

You can tell from the crown wheel on the diff it's just ground down over time though and points to it being defective, nothing to do with any mistreatment etc. There's no heat discoloration and all bearings etc were solid enough and not defective.

 

When diffs go due to launches etc they tend to be catastrophic and in big Lumps rather than a thick metal paste, this has been happening for a long time and the car did still drive believe it or not! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Norm4n said:

Strange how it's worn in one area, maybe a tooth broke and over a long period of time it has put stress on those adjacent

 

It's worn all the teeth if you zoom in, then they've started to break off as they've got too thin. No doubt the rest were shortly to follow, about half were fully gone. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How would i go about doing that? I was going to email them with pictures just for their info but i've always found VW useless with correspondence and the like!

 

I've scrapped the casings and haldex transfer side and just kept the diff as a memento (the bit thats actually failed i guess) 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, Maplesyrup said:

I can’t imagine that VW would be at all interested in looking at any failed component that’s out of warranty, you’d probably need to pay them for their time to inspect it 🙄

 

Well they are my thoughts as well, i cant imagine they could care less. I've emailed them anyway with pictures etc. but again feel its a waste of time and i dont think its likely ill get any response.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, EcosseGolfR said:

I believe the rear diff oil change is not part of VW’s service schedule, I priced it yesterday from an independent garage, £95 so I’ll probably have it done in the new year.

 

Good idea and the front one can be changed too. I'll be getting mine done next time it's in. 

 

Seems quite expensive for your quote though? Haldex service at my indy is £90 Inc taking the pump out and doing the filter. The haldex fluid is about 2.5x the price of the gear oil.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, EcosseGolfR said:

Yeah I think the haldex was £120 with pump removed and cleaned, so the rear diff at £95 was expected. Things are expensive up here Aberdeen unfortunately.

 

That's fair, I did think after I asked that you might be somewhere more expensive than where I am (the north east, nice and cheap haha) 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...