Jump to content

Considering a switch


RS6BRIT

Recommended Posts

Hi Chaps, first post on here so be gentle. I've owned an A45 AMG since September '15, and got it brand new. I love the car, but its due to go back in a few months, and looking at my options the Golf seems like a great alternative to the Merc.  I'd like some honest opinions from owners as to whether you think I'll regret it. I'll be looking at a brand new 7.5 with DSG.

The 45 doesnt have much in the way of tech, just heated seats, a shit nav system, and a pretty crappy OBC. BUT its fast as hell and handles brilliantly and is obviously (relative to the golf) quite rare. Mine is tuned to 430bhp and is very quick(Vbox'd 0-60 3.7 secs) My main question is can the R be as quick as that ? Revo's stage 2 seems to suggest that it'll be in that region but is it true ? Has anyone on here had an encounter with an A45 and if so what was the outcome ?   

The golf is roughly 200 quid a month cheaper than the Merc, but is there a reason other than the badge ? 

Whats your thoughts guys ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A stage 2 tune (APR has probably the highest yield) with the right linked mods (air intakes, FMIC, downpipe with sports cat) should certainly get you under 4 seconds to 62 so I doubt you'd notice much difference. Personally I can't see the Merc finish any better (if as good) as the Golf's and you'll get better value for money from the VW. I'm sure most of the premium is indeed in the star and the AMG badge. Others' MMV of course. :smiley:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, RS6BRIT said:

, but is there a reason other than the badge ? 

Whats your thoughts guys ?

 

You're on a Golf R forum....guess what people are going to recommend you do :)  Are you saying the Merc badge isn't worth paying for?  Personally, the only Merc I'd get in is a taxi.  I did tentatively look at the 45 as it sounded good as well as it's quicker.  However, the badge and styling of the car were a no no for me.

 

If it's all about 0-62 for you, I'd stick with what you've got/get another or the Golf is obviously as tune-able and you'd get very similar performance at the top end of tune.

 

RS3 maybe?.....that 5-banger is an awesome engine and also very tune-able.

 

For day to day the Golf R is perfect for me. 

 

If you want to save 200 sheets the the Golf R is a no brainer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you’re chasing figures the RS3 is the next step up unless you want to spend big and upgrade the turbo on the Golf.

 

The Golf is a cracking car and a great handling motor, but will pretty much max out at circa 400bhp without leaning on it or upgrade the turbo.

 

At Stage 2 they’re a very quick car, but the £200 saving would be quickly offset by having to spending a few grand tuning it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the replies guys. I'm not chasing numbers or looking go faster than the A45 per say. I'd just like a car on par with it really. The RS3 would be lovely but it's frankly over priced, and goes against the grain of trying to save a little. That's not to say that money is the motivator BUT if the Golf can match the Merc for pace with a map and downpipe for instance then it's a no brainer. As far as I can tell the Golf already licks the Merc for tech so it's just about pace really I think.
Also my A45 is a Pre FL so it's 0-60 is 4.6 which if I'm not mistaken is matched by the MK7.5 ?

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From experience, the previous gen A45 has the edge on my mk7 R but when it came to the bends, I was all over him like a cheap suit. I don’t know whether he had rubbish tyres, rubbish driving or whether he just didn’t know the road but he was seriously going for it - staying with him through the bends was, tbh, effortless. I’d maybe try an A45 for comparison but for me, at the moment, the only car I’d seriously consider other than a new R is an M2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The latest A45 is better all round according to a friend who has owned both. He purchased the latest one in early 2017 and still has it, which is a bit of a record for him as he likes to change cars regularly.

I have driven both and agree there is a significant improvement but I still think the transmission is dimwitted and the ride is fairly harsh compared to the R. 

There is no arguing however that the A45 is quicker in a straight line but overall in real life the R would be as quick from point A to B in my estimation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 13/01/2018 at 14:28, RS6BRIT said:

due to go back in a few months

 

Sorry not wishing to teach you how to 'suck eggs' but is it a lease??  If so you would have a problem with having to do so many mods to the R to get that level of performance that the lease company would know probably know.  You could look at the Ford RS if you like the looks, sadly for me the Merc and RS are just too much 'in your face', would have liked their power but I could not live with either of their styling!!  If 4WD is not a problem..... M2/3/4...but that wont save you any cash!!  R seems to be one of the best performance vfm at the moment, that's why I ordered one, its not the fastest but it definitely seems hard to beat for 'value for performance'.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brit

I came from a '14 plate 45 and have no regrets what so ever. Tech and build quality is far far better imo.

I never modded the merc and I won't the golf as the mrs uses it more than me.

You need to try it😎

Link to comment
Share on other sites

tbh the golf is tamer in respect of noise etc compared to a a45. I would probably throw the S3 into the same mix as its sounds like you are going the civilised route. S is a bit softer than a standard r (in terms of suspension) and the virtual cockpit of the audi wipes the floor with the golf attempt (that feels half hearted to me!)

 

Only way is to try one really, personally I would like the bmw M140i next or maybe a 3 year old m135i run for a year and ditch, never owned a 6 cylinder car, so is a scratch I would like to itch.

 

Happy with the r I have though, I think the build quality of the golf is a bit shit, so assume the a45 will bug me even more than the rattles I currently have

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...