Jump to content

Small power reduction to 2019 Golf R


Booth11

Recommended Posts

4 hours ago, Jon-Paul said:

With this new GPF legislation, leaner and greener 'stuff' being introduced, it makes me wonder whether the chit-chat of the MK8 'R' being mild hybrid might make sense ?

 

2 hours ago, dougaberdeen said:

might be a problem tuning them as if a replacement exhaust is fitted without the particulate filter, to allow higher flow rates, it will likely fail an mot as per the new regulations that if there is any sign of tampering with the particulate filter its an automatic fail

This.  

 

The first instance of gpf for vw is on Up! Gti.   Here’s a cut from Up! Forum. 

<<
GPF and DPF are completely different ways of minimizing noxious exhaust particles.  DPFbeing effectively a temp soot trap for larger carbon particles (carcogenic), which then needs subsequent higher revs to burn up the soot - otherwise out clogs and needs manually emptying.   DPF equipped cars that are not driven within a duty cycle that regularly involves the upper end of the operating temp range, (through revving, can fail to keep their DPFs clear, triggering all sorts of ecu messages and limp home modes etc.   Short journy old farts tend to be the victims in the main of DPFissues.   Nowadays we all know that small diesels are not the best town and runabout cars.

GPF is aimed at nano particles, themselves considered more harmful by virtue that they are more easily absorbed into lung tissues on inhalation.   Petrol engines run hotter than diesel, turbo petrols moreso. Using that heat in 4 way catalysts is key to GPF.

<<<How the petrol particulate filter works: 

The new filter is tucked in behind the engine a few centimetres from the turbo, heats up very quickly and becomes effective seconds after starting from cold. At its core, exhaust is forced through the walls of channels blocked off at alternate ends. The trapped particulates are superheated, reduced to CO2 and, at the same time, the unwanted HC, NOx and CO are converted to small amounts of CO2, nitrogen and water.

After leaving the filter, exhaust gases pass through a second, conventional three-way catalytic converter mounted beneath the floor. This ensures the tailpipe exhaust complies with the latest level of EU6c emissions standards even when the engine is working flat out. >>>

Thats the scientific blurb. Bottom line is that GPF appears to work sooner, hotter, and more efficiently than DPF, without needing the nuts revved off it to clear itself, unlike the Driving Miss Daisy DPFs.  

I dont know what GPF means for servicing, but I suspect it is same as when catalytic converters were made mandatory - a few scaremongers about the aftermarket costs, performances etc, but little real difference to you and I, as these devices become widespread.

I do suspect that the Tuning market will have its work cut out to remap this engine and maintain legal efficiencies, without screwing the emissions and the exhaust temp management for MOT etc.   No doubt they'll get there, but its going to be more work to crack the ECUs properly. By properly, I mean beyond just altering boost and fueling parameters.

I shall watch, with interest, to see what the European tuners come up with>>>>

 

I am old enough to remember the scare of strangled performance engines when catalytic converters became mandatory.  Having driven US market 1980s catalysed cars, I concur, they felt asthmatic and hated revs.

 

...but we don’t even think about cats stifling performance engines now, do we?  So it will be for gpf engines, such is pace of mapping technology. 

 

The tuning market, being ready for the gpf generation, is another thing, as is the likelihood of emissions test fails, and expensive catalyst/gpf replacements for ‘crude’ tuners, mappers and add on box manufacturers. 

 

Happy with my 310hp.  Will watch the after market

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a car previously with a cat that sat very close to the engine in the exhaust.  It was made of a sort of ceramic material.  For some reason it was reasonably well know that that the ceramic would break up (and once it started this would continue), get sucked into, and score the bores of the cylinders.  this increased oil usage, which damaged them more, which led to more oil usage... and well you can guess the rest.

 

I'm not saying that this will be ceramic, or that it'll be likely to fall apart... but is also something worth considering.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This.  
 
The first instance of gpf for vw is on Up! Gti.   Here’s a cut from Up! Forum. 
GPF and DPF are completely different ways of minimizing noxious exhaust particles.  DPFbeing effectively a temp soot trap for larger carbon particles (carcogenic), which then needs subsequent higher revs to burn up the soot - otherwise out clogs and needs manually emptying.   DPF equipped cars that are not driven within a duty cycle that regularly involves the upper end of the operating temp range, (through revving, can fail to keep their DPFs clear, triggering all sorts of ecu messages and limp home modes etc.   Short journy old farts tend to be the victims in the main of DPFissues.   Nowadays we all know that small diesels are not the best town and runabout cars.

GPF is aimed at nano particles, themselves considered more harmful by virtue that they are more easily absorbed into lung tissues on inhalation.   Petrol engines run hotter than diesel, turbo petrols moreso. Using that heat in 4 way catalysts is key to GPF.


The new filter is tucked in behind the engine a few centimetres from the turbo, heats up very quickly and becomes effective seconds after starting from cold. At its core, exhaust is forced through the walls of channels blocked off at alternate ends. The trapped particulates are superheated, reduced to CO2 and, at the same time, the unwanted HC, NOx and CO are converted to small amounts of CO2, nitrogen and water.

After leaving the filter, exhaust gases pass through a second, conventional three-way catalytic converter mounted beneath the floor. This ensures the tailpipe exhaust complies with the latest level of EU6c emissions standards even when the engine is working flat out. >>>

Thats the scientific blurb. Bottom line is that GPF appears to work sooner, hotter, and more efficiently than DPF, without needing the nuts revved off it to clear itself, unlike the Driving Miss Daisy DPFs.  

I dont know what GPF means for servicing, but I suspect it is same as when catalytic converters were made mandatory - a few scaremongers about the aftermarket costs, performances etc, but little real difference to you and I, as these devices become widespread.

I do suspect that the Tuning market will have its work cut out to remap this engine and maintain legal efficiencies, without screwing the emissions and the exhaust temp management for MOT etc.   No doubt they'll get there, but its going to be more work to crack the ECUs properly. By properly, I mean beyond just altering boost and fueling parameters.

I shall watch, with interest, to see what the European tuners come up with>>>>
 
I am old enough to remember the scare of strangled performance engines when catalytic converters became mandatory.  Having driven US market 1980s catalysed cars, I concur, they felt asthmatic and hated revs.
 
...but we don’t even think about cats stifling performance engines now, do we?  So it will be for gpf engines, such is pace of mapping technology. 
 
The tuning market, being ready for the gpf generation, is another thing, as is the likelihood of emissions test fails, and expensive catalyst/gpf replacements for ‘crude’ tuners, mappers and add on box manufacturers. 
 
Happy with my 310hp.  Will watch the after market

That said, the car only has to pass the emissions test one day per year and three years after the car was put on the road. VRS in Northampton (UK) do tuning packages where you can simply revert to the original factory map via an app on your phone and connected to your car. Vehicle manufacturers always claim to have this proof and that proof but tuners ALWAYS find a way in - just like thieves ALWAYS find a way past electronic security systems and internet banking - hence why I don’t internet bank and have a sodding great metal steering lock on my car!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree. Reptuable tuners do find ways and means.   I can imagine new ea888 version for gpf compliance, probably new ecu, probably more security too. 

 

Thinking wider, given Vw political challenges with their dieselgate, I can imagine them also being more transparent with the various market country legislators.  Uber efficiency German test stations could easily be equipped with VW latest tools to detect emissions variances to stock.  Ditto state of California where things are stringent and reputation tarnished. 

 

For good old UK, it’s hard to imagine out DoT getting their act together sufficiently to tool up for new gpf cars specifically.  But they could just as easily up the ante to lower the existing acceptable co2 nox etc etc emissions, and apply for all new cars from a certain registered date, that are gpf equipped. 

 

Expect some bin end bargains for the run out non-gpf unregistered vehicles .👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, EcosseGolfR said:

I did consider trading in my Golf R for a horse & cart......but decided against it due to they'd probably tax me even more for the amount of shit the horse left on the roads....

And the damage it does to our beautiful roads! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree. Reptuable tuners do find ways and means.   I can imagine new ea888 version for gpf compliance, probably new ecu, probably more security too. 
 
Thinking wider, given Vw political challenges with their dieselgate, I can imagine them also being more transparent with the various market country legislators.  Uber efficiency German test stations could easily be equipped with VW latest tools to detect emissions variances to stock.  Ditto state of California where things are stringent and reputation tarnished. 
 
For good old UK, it’s hard to imagine out DoT getting their act together sufficiently to tool up for new gpf cars specifically.  But they could just as easily up the ante to lower the existing acceptable co2 nox etc etc emissions, and apply for all new cars from a certain registered date, that are gpf equipped. 
 
Expect some bin end bargains for the run out non-gpf unregistered vehicles .

.........or no bargains at all due to a mad dash for the pre power drop cars. If the rumoured mk8 is hybrid, I wouldn’t be surprised to see a dash for the last, true internal combustion engined cars either.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, camelsac2002 said:

I’d like to know what’s going to happen to the five pot in the RS3 and their other bigger engined cars like the S4 etc. What about the emissions on those? emoji848.png


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

They’ve closed the order books for the rs3 while they revise the exhaust. It’s most likely going to be even quieter than the facelift is compared to the pre facelift. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised £170
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...