andrewparker Posted February 10, 2021 Report Share Posted February 10, 2021 11 hours ago, veewiz said: And the answer is....? Are you sure you should really be a moderator on here? I have to agree. The vitriol directed at Andrew has got out of hand round here. It’s unjustified and it really doesn’t reflect well on the VWROC community. We should all be able to debate differing opinions without resorting to personal slights. Stobsie, Hertsman, theskivingscholar and 1 other 3 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camelsac2002 Posted February 10, 2021 Report Share Posted February 10, 2021 Just the one reference!, not bad for an R video Gotta say the exhaust sounds terrible, i know that is mainly down to the GPF but the pops and crackles are so muted and metallic sounding.....it just sounds like a rattly kettle that’s struggling to boil. I expect an akro exhaust is a must on this just to get it to sound at least half way decent. The exterior is quite a bit better on the R model, vs other mk8's (the GTI is hideous) but i still don't really like it. Although admit it is better than i expected. There is this perception (or should i say misconception) that newer means better and makes what it succeeds look dated by comparison, especially as it becomes more prevalent. However the design cues are such a sharp change from its predecessor, what with it's bulbous looking bonnet that runs down far into the bumper and its squinting winged headlights - i dunno if i could ever grow to like it, tolerate and accept yes, like - no. Not keen on the SUV boxy rear either, but that's probably just me and my hatred of all things SUV like. As for all the touch controls replacing common everyday functions - that i know will drive me insane in daily use. I hate having to repeat my actions multiple times to do a simple function - and that is exactly what a touch control is, something i have to press / swipe over and over for it to respond. Even the pan roof in your example took 2 swipes, probably more if driving. I'm telling you now its only a matter of time before this horrendous user interface causes a death, and then there will be a rolling back of all this gimmicky interface crap in cars. Still its new, its different, and i don't knock anyone from upgrading from a mk7, esp from pre facelift models - at least ya getting quite a big jump in tech from the older model which is genuinely looking dated on the interior at least.Thing is, it’s still not enough to tempt me out of my prefacelift mk7. Aside from the different interior lights, I don’t think it’s moved on massively apart from the sharpness on the screens. Touchy buttons do nothing for me - I prefer buttons and dials for the heating etc and as you said, I think this new system will cause accidents.Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk blower and 8YARWY 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dopper99 Posted February 10, 2021 Report Share Posted February 10, 2021 11 hours ago, blower said: Just the one reference!, not bad for an R video Gotta say the exhaust sounds terrible, i know that is mainly down to the GPF but the pops and crackles are so muted and metallic sounding.....it just sounds like a rattly kettle that’s struggling to boil. I expect an akro exhaust is a must on this just to get it to sound at least half way decent. The exterior is quite a bit better on the R model, vs other mk8's (the GTI is hideous) but i still don't really like it. Although admit it is better than i expected. There is this perception (or should i say misconception) that newer means better and makes what it succeeds look dated by comparison, especially as it becomes more prevalent. However the design cues are such a sharp change from its predecessor, what with it's bulbous looking bonnet that runs down far into the bumper and its squinting winged headlights - i dunno if i could ever grow to like it, tolerate and accept yes, like - no. Not keen on the SUV boxy rear either, but that's probably just me and my hatred of all things SUV like. As for all the touch controls replacing common everyday functions - that i know will drive me insane in daily use. I hate having to repeat my actions multiple times to do a simple function - and that is exactly what a touch control is, something i have to press / swipe over and over for it to respond. Even the pan roof in your example took 2 swipes, probably more if driving. I'm telling you now its only a matter of time before this horrendous user interface causes a death, and then there will be a rolling back of all this gimmicky interface crap in cars. Still its new, its different, and i don't knock anyone from upgrading from a mk7, esp from pre facelift models - at least ya getting quite a big jump in tech from the older model which is genuinely looking dated on the interior at least. I think if the Mk 8 R was "just an upgrade" (like the S3 is) it would be hard to justify the extra outlay. However, there is more to it than that. Ie subframe changes, rear torque vectoring, slight power upgrade (and probably more technical stuff) ..... so the drive should be a lot better than the old car. My point is, you've only mentioned the cosmetic stuff and not the technical stuff and the fact it should be a better car to drive (we hope!) 😉 blower 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StuR Posted February 10, 2021 Report Share Posted February 10, 2021 Volkswizard is certainly correct about the TCR being more fun than an R .. As you were. theskivingscholar 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camelsac2002 Posted February 10, 2021 Report Share Posted February 10, 2021 Volkswizard is certainly correct about the TCR being more fun than an R .. As you were. So was my Cupra 280 - but my R is a better all round car than my 280.Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk 8YARWY and Darlo 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Booth11 Posted February 15, 2021 Report Share Posted February 15, 2021 Thomas of Autogefuel on the 8 Clubsport mk8r 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hertsman Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 On 15/02/2021 at 18:45, Booth11 said: Thomas of Autogefuel on the 8 Clubsport Just watched all the way through and though there is comment to the improved handling, nothing compelling to make me think present TCR should be replaced by a ClubSport. The issues are quite small and subtle though: Would like to see Clubsport actually written in the graphic that runs along the body Better choice of 19" wheels, some nice black 19" would make huge difference. Love the seats, but would be be nice to have GTI logo on the headrest, and added touch Thomas has said a few times on MK 8 his frustration with the touch tech and was not and still not a fan - the only thing that would be in my favour is that once set up is rarely if ever touch settings so that would be an offset, but happy that hung onto the blended button/touch environment in the MK 7.5 Going to be really interested to see how folk live with the touch tech and how distracting it is to actual driving compared to the MK 7 - Best forum to see the realities as most going MK 8 are very familiar with the MK 7 so the difference will be well understood in terms of distraction from eyes on road. In summery, think its mainly that expect the Clubsport to be the pinnacle and have some bits and pieces that shout that, even in a VW understated way. The R has the performance pack which takes it up a notch and then the Akra also, New set of wheels and change of graphic would not be much of an effort and lift the look immediately to more 'this is a Clubsport' Front end is much better than the GTI and with the R its getting the best of the MK 8 styling. Its obviously going to be a great car to drive and these minor observations as by nature you pick at the details in places like these 8YARWY and Booth11 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hertsman Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 On 10/02/2021 at 08:40, andrewparker said: I have to agree. The vitriol directed at Andrew has got out of hand round here. It’s unjustified and it really doesn’t reflect well on the VWROC community. We should all be able to debate differing opinions without resorting to personal slights. Andrew is a good guy, enjoy his videos far more than some of the extreme in your face folk on you tube, the assessment are presented and you take them into your own thoughts, nothing forced or heavy Bit of a victim of the pandemic and so some videos do feel a little pushed out to fill the gaps and keep content going where as sure we would have wider variety and insight with increased access and of course the car shows and VW events invited to, Remember its only a view, his, worth no more or less than anyone's, and if really not a fan, as my dad always said when TV shows are complained about, no one is making anyone watch Rephlex and theskivingscholar 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Booth11 Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 1 hour ago, Hertsman said: Just watched all the way through and though there is comment to the improved handling, nothing compelling to make me think present TCR should be replaced by a ClubSport. The issues are quite small and subtle though: Would like to see Clubsport actually written in the graphic that runs along the body Better choice of 19" wheels, some nice black 19" would make huge difference. Love the seats, but would be be nice to have GTI logo on the headrest, and added touch Thomas has said a few times on MK 8 his frustration with the touch tech and was not and still not a fan - the only thing that would be in my favour is that once set up is rarely if ever touch settings so that would be an offset, but happy that hung onto the blended button/touch environment in the MK 7.5 Going to be really interested to see how folk live with the touch tech and how distracting it is to actual driving compared to the MK 7 - Best forum to see the realities as most going MK 8 are very familiar with the MK 7 so the difference will be well understood in terms of distraction from eyes on road. In summery, think its mainly that expect the Clubsport to be the pinnacle and have some bits and pieces that shout that, even in a VW understated way. The R has the performance pack which takes it up a notch and then the Akra also, New set of wheels and change of graphic would not be much of an effort and lift the look immediately to more 'this is a Clubsport' Front end is much better than the GTI and with the R its getting the best of the MK 8 styling. Its obviously going to be a great car to drive and these minor observations as by nature you pick at the details in places like these There’s the more comprehensive extended version of the Autogefugel video out now Herstman, worth another watch. I agree with much of what you say about the 8CS. Front end is considerably better than the standard 8GTI. I personally think the R front is better still but that’s just my preferred aesthetic and the two are nicely distinguished so take your pick really. I think the CS styling is more playful and reflects the car’s character. The R styling more purposeful and agressive, reflecting its character. It would have been good to have Clubsport name along the side to mark it out for what it is, and distinguish further from its GTI sibling. Quite why the sill graphics end half way along the side is a strange choice, looks incongruous to me. Perhaps 19” Black Estorils will make an appearance at some point, or some other alloys, maybe they are saving some of the extra touches for an Edition 45? The tech in daily driving, well a few of us will find out soon enough. There are certain things I like to set up and leave, but other types of settings that I do change more frequently such as aircon settings. I’m sure there’ll be plenty of feedback on here and other forums as more mk8 cars come into members’ ownership. I’m looking forward to finding out a lot of these things for myself. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
8YARWY Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 Andrew is a good guy, enjoy his videos far more than some of the extreme in your face folk on you tube, the assessment are presented and you take them into your own thoughts, nothing forced or heavy Bit of a victim of the pandemic and so some videos do feel a little pushed out to fill the gaps and keep content going where as sure we would have wider variety and insight with increased access and of course the car shows and VW events invited to, Remember its only a view, his, worth no more or less than anyone's, and if really not a fan, as my dad always said when TV shows are complained about, no one is making anyone watch It’s not his videos, it’s his attitude when you don’t agree with his point of view on social media, he behaves like a spoilt child would. You put yourself on social media you need to engage with people that support / follow you, not throw your toys out the pram when people express a difference of opinion. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Booth11 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camelsac2002 Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 The latest edition of EVO landed on the hall floor today. There’s a test between an 8CS and a 128ti. The CS got four stars and the 128 four and a half. Chief criticisms of the CS seem to be the poor damping as the test car didn’t have DCC fitted plus the ability for the power and torque to overwhelm the car. What’s grating with this is that it’s a £37k car and it seems that you have to pick this car over the standard GTi to get the best driving experience - which is pretty poor really - the GTi should be a good car and the CS a great car but neither seem to live up to expectations. The DSG paddles came in for criticism against the ones on the R - why not just fit the same ones from the R? I smell cheapness myself......The steering on the CS is better than on the GTi but that should be the norm. I dare say if they bring out an Edition whatever-number-they’re-at-now () it’ll be better again but at what price? Poor show VW.Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lustral Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 I got a GTI Clubsport for a day tomorrow. I think it is a demo car hopefully with most or all the options on it. I dont really have any expectations for as i coming from an R. Ill be prepared to be wowed though. Looking at the vids and reviews , i think the interior will annoy me the most. camelsac2002 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
andrewparker Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 I read the EVO review also. It’s disappointing that DCC is so integral to how well the car performs, yet it isn’t standard. It’s doubly frustrating that VW can’t engineer a car that performs well on passive dampers, like BMW have evidently done. The EVO review also mentioned traction problems, which is why I guess most of us here drive a Golf R! camelsac2002 and marshy 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camelsac2002 Posted February 18, 2021 Report Share Posted February 18, 2021 I read the EVO review also. It’s disappointing that DCC is so integral to how well the car performs, yet it isn’t standard. It’s doubly frustrating that VW can’t engineer a car that performs well on passive dampers, like BMW have evidently done. The EVO review also mentioned traction problems, which is why I guess most of us here drive a Golf R!Daft thing is, it’s been standard on the Leon for about seven years!!Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lustral Posted February 19, 2021 Report Share Posted February 19, 2021 So I got a Clubsport on my drive at the moment .... so a quick drive back from the dealers and yeah it is a familiar place to be with the tech fest going on there. 1st thing on my OCD is how scratch-able the plastics for the Park brake and the centre console, not good. As expected it is so easy to brake traction. (9C and slightly damp here) I do like they have made the throttle response better and actually different in the modes. Ill go and have a bit more play with it shortly. Not sure why they have put some 19 Brescia wheels with Dunlop Maxx tyres instead what it should come with. NRW, Booth11 and FBF 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.